Can Chili Crunch Be Trademarked? | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss the controversy around Momofuku's David Chang trying to trademark chili crunch. Can a condiment really be trademarked? How far does IP protection go?

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. David Chang's muku finds itself in the middle of some chili crunch drama muku has trademarked chili crunch a spicy
  2. oily crispy condiment popular in Asian countries after sending cease and assist letters to manufacturers using the name
  3. the brand has been accused of trademarking a generic cultural product some critics have compared it the move
  4. to trademarking ketchup and suggested its mon his Monopoly Behavior a company in Denver previously owned the trademark
  5. and sent a CE to his letter to Mama fuku which instead has instead worked to purchase the trademark for itself I I
  6. Scott you're a branding person what the heck chili crunch I've seen chili crunch
  7. stuff all over the place in Asia and also anytime you go to an Asian market there's a million chili crunch things
  8. this seems crazy for for for M fuku and David Chang to do he looks like an we your thoughts on like this
  9. marketing thing well it's like the majority of bad ideas started out as good ideas and that is our ability to
  10. protect IP is really important whether it's someone's likeness whether it's the the patents or the you know Chemical
  11. Context of a pharmaceutical America's Innovation and our economy relies on what you would Loosely called
  12. intellectual property protection and our ability to legally protect it this has it gone crazy this reminds me of when
  13. Paris Hilton tried to trademark that's hot oh right yeah yeahhuh I knew you'd be good at this go ahead and someone
  14. said that no you can't trademark this so the reason why we have thoughtful judges
  15. in law and and and cases is that we can say all right there is a line here because what you have is it's been
  16. weaponized in the sense that these especially big companies or well resourced companies send cease deis
  17. letters to everyone for anything that smells of anything remote and they use it as a means of suppressing competition
  18. and also they use it as a means of trying to get unearned PR for example Amazon will file a patent for a not only
  19. a floating Warehouse which is probably um physically uh impossible for the the next couple centuries they will file a
  20. patent for a projectile defense Shield of their floating warehouse and the reason they do it is they know that
  21. reporters at Forbes and other Business magazines troll patent filings and then write about them so IP protection has
  22. taken on all this different Nuance including intimidation including well-resourced monopolies they Conant
  23. because if you get a cease and toist letter and you're a small company you're sort of inclined to say am I really
  24. going to take on this well-resourced company or am I just going to find another name but this is an example of a
  25. gone Haywire these are generic terms and I believe the court will say sorry this
  26. term has become generic you can't own it I think this is exactly why to talk about this even though people are sort
  27. of losing their minds on um on the internet here it's really important what he's done here like and I agree with you
  28. I agree with you this is a where do you think it's going to end up it'll be dismissed dismissed meaning he won't be
  29. able to to to cease into system no yeah it'll be this will be as you call it legal harassment they'll say you have no
  30. domain over this name and yeah and you should pay back the legal fees for the people where you're creating you know
  31. what whatever you call it a superflous or whatever the term but it's an issue around the trademark office too because
  32. I think he he does own the trademark right he owns it well but but if it's tradem markable they'll they that's
  33. right I can't believe he got the trademark at all right so I I just don't I I don't
  34. know you know I look this is a this is for IP lawyers but your ability to Inc to encourage people to make the
  35. requisite investment in developing important differentiated intellectual property is really important to provide
  36. that protection at the same time you have to ensure that there's a competitive marketplace where people who
  37. are trying to develop their own IP don't bump into IP that's been inflated Beyond
  38. reasonable protection

Brief Summary

David Chang's Muku faces backlash for trademarking chili crunch, raising concerns about monopolistic practices and cultural appropriation.

Key points

  • Chili Crunch Trademark Controversy. David Chang's brand faces backlash for trademarking a common condiment, raising questions about IP rights.

Related episodes