Will Election Betting Markets Get It Right? | Pivot
Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway
Episode Description
Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss how betting markets like Polymarket and Kalshi reflect and manipulate political sentiment tied to the election. Plus, the rise and fall of Trump Media stock, and whether it's an accurate predictor of Donald Trump's fate.
Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or at https://podcasts.voxmedia.com/show/pivot
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- former president uh Trump's true social was briefly worth more than Elon Musk X which has been declining in value as
- we've talked about before true social parent company was shortly valued over10 billion while ex Holdings is valued at
- $9.4 billion and that's probably being generous uh the Trump media stock was briefly halted several times this week
- for moving so sharply it's gone up and down really is interesting there's a lot of weird movement in this stock I'd love
- to really actually see the transactions meanwhile the parent company lost more than $16 million in quarter ending June
- and uh doesn't have very many uh people on it which of course this is not about its its fundamental business issues
- however on Wednesday Trump this the shares Trump social lost 1.3 Trump himself lost $ 1.3 billion in net worth
- after the worst trading day ever for the uh for the company we do disagree on why
- this is happening I think there's a lot of gaming going on here and I would love
- to see the logs say more about what you mean by that well if you're someone who wants to support Trump like these poly
- markets everyone like oh Peter teal owns it like people and it turned out there was one trade in France from one guy you
- know that made made it go up so we're all like oh Trump's winning but he's not because one guy did it right and so I
- worry this stock is being manipulated by uh Trump adjacent people and who knows who they could be to make it go up and
- down I don't think this is a bunch of like maybe it's Wall Street gaming the situation um it feels very gamed like on
- some level the way it's gone up because getting away from the fundamentals of this company which both of us absolutely
- agree is a piece of right it's a Sandwich inside a you know pie whatever um it it seems unusual that
- this is happening I don't think it's popular sentiment it's some other sentiment and you think differently you
- think differently it's an interesting thesis and that is that if if a stock or a poll indicates that Trump is likely to
- win that it gives people confidence or incentive or momentum on the Trump side and then I've also heard a counter
- Theory and that is it's being manipulated by a de a wealthy Democrat who wants to give Republican voters the
- Sens it's in the bag such that people stay on the couch I can see oh I didn't hear that one that's fascinating that
- was my friend Whitney Tilson who sends out a really thoughtful email almost every day um I can see someone
- manipulating well let me back up this is what I think is going on poly Market uh
- Calia is that what it's called anyways there's a bunch of them um that are basically wagering sites
- where you can bet on amongst other things every state you can bet on margin of Victory and you can bet on the
- election and right now on poly Market it has uh Trump at 62 approximately 62 or 63 and Harris at
- 37 or 38% that is that is a wide margin and I think the logical thesis or the most obvious one and kind of aams Razer
- I think the one that probably is correct is that the kind of person that goes to
- a site and bets on an election is probably younger probably more male and those people skew heavily Trump I mean
- the majority of the data across the A+ list polling sites says that it's pretty much a tossup right and so if you are a
- betting person I mean I'm actually thinking of doing this just for fun uh I might put some money on Harrison uh poly
- Market because this is what it means if you bet a $100 on Harris and she wins you get approximately $287 or almost
- triple your money and if someone said you cara bet on this coin flip and you don't know and I would describe the
- election right now from there's the data I see trying to be as unemotional as possible as a coin flip but if someone
- said you cara you bet $100 and you pick heads or tails and if you win you get 287 you would do that because it's
- asymmetric absolutely let's do it let's do it well that's actually what I'm thinking
- because not that I'm I'm hopeful but I'm not that confident I think it's literally a coin flip but if on a coin
- flip you're getting you're getting $287 yeah then again you have disproportionate upside so I think the
- thesis that these markets are driven by who bets which way or the other the most
- obvious explanation is that the people it's like I do you remember when Floyd Mayweather fought Conor MCG the I do not
- anyways this UFC fighter this whiter than white guy red hair Irish guy who's actually not that great in MMA fighter
- he's just very loud and obnoxious oh that guy he was in the movie with with the he he did the sey anyway yes I know
- who he is yeah well anyways and he fought Floyd Mayweather who arguably has the fastest hands in the history of
- boxing but the odds were much tighter because I think I think people still like the idea I think there's some
- unconscious racis racism where people like the idea of the white guy beating up or or winning the you know the
- beating the black guy there's always throughout the history of boxing there's always a little bit of of bias for the
- white guy the Great White Hope so to speak and the best bet or the easiest bet was on Floyd Mayweather fighting an
- OK MMA fighter that had never boxed before anyway did my point is you're getting asymmetric upside to the notion
- of who won that thing I don't even know to Conor McGregor's credit he fought a competent fight but Floyd Mayweather AB
- dominated and and and won as he should have but the thing that I don't think is being
- manipulated for Trump's favor is the stock because the stock is the stock was almost at a 100 a couple years ago it's
- been as low as 12 so I don't know if that's sending signals into the marketplace why why couldn't one or 10
- listen to this this is an interesting Fortune had a really interesting investigation and separate
- investigations completed by the blockchain firms Kos labs and Inca digital and shared exclusively with
- Fortune analysts found that polym market activity exhibits signs of wash trading
- a form of Market manipulation where Shares are bought and sold often simultaneously and repeatedly to create
- a false impression of volume of activity chaos Labs found that wash trading consisted constituted around onethird of
- trading volume in poly Market's presidential Market while Inca digital found that a significant portion of the
- volume on the market could be attributed to potential wash trading um uh the the
- other ones um you know they're looking at those too I think you could do the same thing with
- this with this stuck very little needs to trade to make it go up and if you wanted I I was intrigued by the
- Democratic thing make them feel confident and then you know put $100 for each of us on that will you do that will
- you do that and I'll owe you uh 100% um I might I might do a little bit more than that but anyways I buy the thesis
- around the polls because around the the betting sites because a lot of media reports on the betting sites and when
- the media reports that according to Market or KY that Trump is almost 2 to one favored that sends a signal that's
- probably on the whole good for the Trump Campa campaign where the stock is I don't think does much around a signal or
- confidence or lack thereof I don't I don't think it creates much of a echo act in favor of one candidate or the
- other I would short that stock like nobody's business just well you wouldn't like well it could rise yeah you could
- no you could rise you got to be very careful short a stock like that because yeah
- he there's a scenario where it goes to 100 bucks on November the 6th and you know the the dangerous thing about short
- selling is your your losses are unlimited y that's true anyways but I I guess what I'm saying is I absolutely
- buy your thesis around manipulating and the incentive around manipulating the betting markets I'm not sure I see the
- connection of the incentive around manipulating two it doesn't need that many I'd just love to see it I'd like to
- actually see the trading anyway we'll see what happens uh when we go forward
Brief Summary
Hosts discuss True Social's stock volatility, potential market manipulation, and the implications of betting on election outcomes.
Key points
- Trump's Media Company Valuation. Former President Trump's media company briefly surpassed Elon Musk's valuation, raising eyebrows.
- Stock Manipulation Theories. Discussion on whether Trump's media stock is being manipulated by adjacent parties.
- Betting on Political Outcomes. Exploring how betting markets reflect political sentiment and potential manipulation.
Episode highlights
- Stock Manipulation TheoriesDiscussion on whether Trump's media stock is being manipulated by adjacent parties.“I worry this stock is being manipulated by Trump adjacent people.”1:12Nov 5, 2024
- Betting on Political OutcomesExploring how betting markets reflect political sentiment and potential manipulation.“If a stock indicates that Trump is likely to win, it gives people confidence.”1:57Nov 5, 2024





