Will Donors Stick with Joe Biden? | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway talk to Oath CEO and founder Brian Derrick, about political donations to Joe Biden's campaign, and how recent concerns about Biden will impact down-ballot candidates. They also discuss how donations can be directed to achieve the maximum impact, particularly in high-stakes races around the country.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Brian Derek is a political strategist and the CEO and founder of oath a fundraising platform that uses data to
  2. rate and identify high stake elections um the aim is to direct donors to campaigns where their money will have
  3. the Maximum Impact Brian welcome thank you for having me on okay uh so let's talk about Oath talk about how it works
  4. in terms of taking donations and directing the money because as Scott just said a second ago before you came
  5. on money is where it's at and he calls himself a porpus he will explain it to you um of a donation but you said the
  6. problem oath is trying to solve is a tendency for donors to rage donate into the abyss there are a lot of villains in
  7. the political ecosystem that get people very angry and that generate this emotional response whether it's marger
  8. Taylor green or Lauren bobbert or somebody else and in the last eight years that has really turbocharged this
  9. Grassroots donor environment where people see something happen on the news or hear about it on a podcast on Twitter
  10. and then immediately run and donate to try and get that person out of office when really those funds could be much
  11. better used somewhere else maybe just to keep that person out of power um and so
  12. what we set up with oath is a free platform where people can go see what their donations are actually going to
  13. accomplish um we do objective analysis to say where are dollars needed the most to advance the thing that you care about
  14. right now whether that's Repro rights or protecting democracy and how can you direct it as Str ically as possible um
  15. without getting sort of the blowback of a thousand text messages and phone calls
  16. asking for more money all right Scott so before you came on I trifurcated donors
  17. into three buckets and my sense is the thing that gets him out probably the most quickly let's assume that he's
  18. totally defined and doesn't sees Nancy speaker Pelosi at his door and just says sorry Nancy I'm not interested in
  19. talking to anybody and says you know it's Obama on line one and he says I'm not interested he just goes totally
  20. defiant if the money tap gets shut off it gets very hard for him to stay in the race
  21. and Loosely speaking three buckets and by the way tell me if these are the wrong buckets big donors medium-sized
  22. small donor my sense of the big donors is they're just taking a wait and see attitude they're not going to throw
  23. millions of dollars into an abyss and not understand if and who it's going to my sense of the medium-sized B donors
  24. and this is anecdotal evidence and I'm one of them is that we are an open Revolt we are not only signing letters
  25. and have sto giving money to the Biden campaign but are starting to give money and are ready and prepping to give money
  26. to other candidates and then the small D Money donors are just getting inundated
  27. with desperate emails from the Biden campaign as they attempt to show some signs of Life tell me where I got that
  28. wrong and and what it means in terms of is the tap going to get has it been shut
  29. off I think that it has turned into a trickle for sure um a lot of donors are pulling back at least at the
  30. presidential level we've seen a increase in traffic to oath um tens of thousands
  31. of donors looking to give but they're not looking to give to the Biden campaign or or similar they're looking
  32. to give to down ballot races in these competitive states where maybe a progressive or um exciting younger
  33. candidate um could turn out people who might ultimately vote for the Democratic nominee for president regardless of who
  34. that is it's called reverse coattails strategy we're seeing a lot of enthusiasm there at the Grassroots level
  35. but I I think that you're right particularly in this mid-level tier um that people are looking for other
  36. options and they're looking to exert influence to to try to pressure Biden to exit the race and have a more viable
  37. candidate somebody with a A Wider path to Victory take his place there's also um a a partner that oath is working with
  38. called pass the torch which has set a fund where you can give to whoever the nominee might be so long as that person
  39. is a new candidate um it's literally just launching today actually but um I I I think that all of these are examples
  40. of how people are still looking to advance their values people are really concerned about the stakes of the
  41. election but they want to do it in the the Strategic way how how concerned are you will happen to down ballot
  42. candidates if he stays in the race um staying away from that how even if these you're directing him in the right places
  43. How concerned are you you know I I know reverse coattails but there is such a thing as coattail definitely very
  44. concerned oh yeah I want to be clear extremely concerned I had my staff which are mostly engineers and data analysts
  45. prepare a memo last week that said the worst case scenario and so if Biden loses in a landslide right we can
  46. imagine a debate performance similar to happened a few weeks ago another moment like that right before the election um
  47. if he loses in a landslide what does that do to the US Senate the US House State Legislative races State Supreme
  48. Courts and it's devastating to look at the stakes are incredibly high of course for the White House but they're
  49. incredibly high up and down ballot when you have election deniers and farri extremists running to take over very
  50. important parts of our government all across the country and so we can't afford to have a year like 20 10 when
  51. Democrats fell asleep at the wheel in the midterms with Obama in office um truly we we cannot uh sustain or or um
  52. our democracy may not be able to survive a result like that and so that is why we're trying to focus people's attention
  53. on these races that it's true that there's a down ballot effect but even if we underperform at the top of the ticket
  54. for whatever reason we can save some of these Supreme Court seats we can save State Legislative seats and avert a
  55. worst case scenario one of the things that Biden admin Biden people are saying is they raised all that money after the
  56. debate the $28 million or whatever on on small donations but who matters more we've already seen some major donors
  57. including Barry Diller and Netflix uh Reed Hastings AR Emanuel publicly halting their support Rick Caruso until
  58. there's a new Democratic nominee other big donors are are going to support there was one particular one that's
  59. supporting one supporting him and some say they're shifting their funding to House and Senate races a lot of people
  60. are saying that to me um how uh how who's more important these big whales or porpuses like Scott or or what what
  61. matters with the money here you can't make it work entirely without both you you need both in order to put together
  62. the scale of campaign that is required to win in in 2024 but I will say at the presidential level where Biden in
  63. hardside dollars is expected to spend over a billion dollars a significant portion of that is coming in six figure
  64. checks um to the Biden Victory fund and so the Grassroots support is critical and also builds momentum and all of
  65. these um signifiers of party strength and unity very important but when it comes to how many offices you can open
  66. in the Battleground States how much time you can be up refuting attack ads and and those kinds of things a a big chunk
  67. of that money does come from this middle tier that Scott's referring to and and high dollar donors as well what do you
  68. think so what is the next if you will litmus test that publicly and privately sends a
  69. very strong signal uh around fundraising um is it do they get daily reports weekly reports what publicly
  70. says all right this is a this now has his donations have dried up when does when do we see that we will not see the
  71. those figures until early August unless they choose to release some data beforehand um there's a quarterly report
  72. that we'll get on July 16th but it'll mostly have the same information that we just got um from the uh monthly report
  73. that we get about the national committees it will be I will say as someone who's worked in campaign Finance
  74. for most of my career you can weave a lot of different narratives out of uh Finance data about the strength of your
  75. campaign or how much your uh you have versus your opponent um Biden has raised so much money to
  76. date a historic amount of funds that he's not going to be um like shutting down campaign offices or laying people
  77. off that is not sort of in the realm of possibility in the next six weeks um so he he will not face a cash cash crunch
  78. before the convention and if he leaves the Convention as the nominee the money Taps many of many of which I think
  79. they're making the calculation will turn on again because people will have nowhere else to go but what are you I'm
  80. just what what are you seeing you're in this community right across your buddies
  81. that you talk to or meet with over a beer I don't know where you live or coffee or or I'm worried that saying
  82. someone drinks beer is somehow a hate crime now but anyways what are you hearing
  83. what are you hearing in terms of is it off 90% is it off 10% is it am I being alarmist I would imagine it's literally
  84. just stopped what are you hearing in terms of donations to Biden and to Democrats in general what's going on out
  85. there I'm hearing I'm part of multiple um different donor collectives or donor groups um that I either advise or am a
  86. member of that are having parallel conversations around how can we make a change here to
  87. match the crisis of the moment that we're in and so either people are making the choice to um withhold money
  88. entirely uh which would allude to the sort of change that you're referring to but I think that it's more common that
  89. they're changing the targeting um that as you uh mentioned Cara that they're looking at Senate races and house races
  90. that they're setting up new super packs to support alternate candidates um and so there's still a lot of money moving
  91. there's no real way for us to assess the damage being done directly to Biden's accounts and how how much that has
  92. slowed I I can't estimate so in that vein aside from what's going on at the top that what's the most important race
  93. no one's talking about where have you been pushing give us a two examples or one example there's many I would say
  94. state supreme court races in Michigan and North Carolina incredibly important this cycle um people often Overlook
  95. State Supreme Courts but they influence how maps are drawn what voting rights we
  96. have Reproductive Rights gun legislation all kinds of things are decided at that
  97. level um so I think that both of those will be really critical and then I would also point to
  98. the state ledge races happening in Arizona um both Chambers are currently controlled by Republicans but could flip
  99. to Democrats with a strong uh robust turnout campaign in Arizona even if we lose at the presidential level the way
  100. that the districts are drawn it's still possible that we could flip those chambers and reverse Arizona's uh
  101. abortion ban um which would be vitally important to of course millions of people living there and then the the
  102. last one I'll sneak in are the ballot measures big year for ballot measures dozen states putting Reproductive Rights
  103. on on the ballot also anti-gerrymandering ballot measure in Ohio um in Missouri there's one for a
  104. living wage lots of really great opportunities for direct direct democracy when you think about what's
  105. happening now I realize it's unprecedented but everyone's like you can't go into chaos we have to stick
  106. with Joe Ezra Klein made a very good argument why Kos is okay is okay risk-taking is okay do you think it's a
  107. good time to take a risk and I assume the money will flow to whoever they decide if they take a risk and do it in
  108. a non-chaotic way not ridiculously chaotic is what I'm talking about um but is that is is that the worst thing to
  109. create chaos for the Democratic party can you answer those critics that say that that you can't do it now it's too
  110. late I think that the the damage has been done in terms of chaos and unfortunately while I support him and
  111. and have spent a lot of time talking about his successes it was done by President Biden he entered this chaos
  112. into the conversation with his debate performance and so now all we can do is respond to it I said right after the
  113. debate it's going to be a very uncomfortable six weeks until the convention and then after that it will
  114. be settled one way or the other whether it goes the way I hope it does or not we
  115. only have a few weeks left of this of this potential chaos but Joe Biden coming out every single day and saying
  116. he's staying in the race is not going to quiet it either so I think that you can
  117. take the um desire for a a neutral piece out of the equation and just decide what
  118. you want to come out of the chaos do you want a new candidate to come out on the
  119. other side and the energy and sort of the historic nature that might come with that or do we want to stick to Biden and
  120. cross our fingers that we make it across the Finish Line in November but either way now through the convention is going
  121. to be a rocky couple of weeks um with a lot of uncertainty and unanswered questions Scott last question so we've
  122. been talking a lot about Biden do you have a sense for where Trump's fundraising
  123. is in contrast or compared to July of 2020 in a much stronger position um than 2020 I'd have to pull the exact numbers
  124. but he has spent the last three months in back rooms with billionaires and they have really stepped up we saw uh Tim
  125. melon who also is supporting RFK Jr one of his largest owners just write a $50 million check to a trump super pack
  126. absolutely huge amounts of money he also met as I'm I'm sure you're you've talked
  127. about uh with oil exec and asked them to raise him a billion dollars um and said
  128. that he would make some policy changes to his platform in in exchange and so he really has leaned in to the
  129. billionaire club um is amending his platform actively things like flip-flopping on Tik Tok in order to
  130. appease them and it is paying dividends and we're seeing that in his dramatically accelerated uh fundraising
  131. post conviction but you brought up something you mentioned RFK Jr just quickly we'd be not to ask fundraising
  132. for RFK Jr and what that says about the race I think the RFK Junior's campaign um has always been propped up by just a
  133. handful of people who have other interests in his candidacy continuing whether that's his running mate um who's
  134. written Millions at this point maybe over 10 million in checks um to to his campaign or whether it's uh billionaires
  135. who have their own interests in who they think he will take votes away from but there are certainly no Grassroots energy
  136. or Grassroots donation um campaign in order to fund and scale an RFK Jr ticket he would not even have the funds to make
  137. it on the ballot in many states uh without these million plus dollar checks that people have been writing to help
  138. him interesting all right Brian this is really helpful I think people should just calm the [ __ ] down that's our
  139. feeling just like think think logically about where the money should go including these down pallot races you
  140. mentioned but people can go to oath. vote to learn more and figure out what you were interested in voting for and
  141. that you can put money to use in ways that are probably more helpful going forward thank you so much thanks for
  142. having me on

Brief Summary

Brian Derek discusses strategic political donations and the importance of directing funds to impactful campaigns in the current election cycle.

Key points

  • Oath: A New Fundraising Strategy. Brian explains how Oath directs donations to maximize impact in elections.
  • Changing Donor Behavior. Discussion on how donors are shifting their focus from presidential to down-ballot races.
  • The Stakes of the Election. Brian highlights the high stakes of the upcoming elections, especially for down-ballot races.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes