Savannah Guthrie Opens Up About Faith and Family

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Today Show co-anchor Savannah Guthrie talks to Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway about her new book, "Mostly What Goes: Reflections on Seeking and Finding His Love Everywhere." Savannah explains why she wanted to reflect on her faith and family, and also discusses AI book scams.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Savannah Guthrie is the co-anchor of the Today's Show and NBC news's Chief legal
  2. correspondent she's also the author of mostly what God does Reflections on seeking and finding his love everywhere
  3. I want to be clear this is the real Savannah Guthrie we're talking to not the AI or deep fake Savannah Guthrie
  4. we'll talk about that in a minute but I first want to talk about the impetus for
  5. the book because when you told me about it um we text from time to time you said
  6. you're this not what you think it's going to be and you were almost apologetic it was interesting um and
  7. that this would surprise people who know you as Savannah gothy journalist interviewer you do tough interviews uh
  8. you're on the Today's Show you're very well known talk you're talking about your faith here tell talk to me about
  9. what the impetus was because I was surprised actually I had no idea I know I was surprised too and I mean almost
  10. apologetic is just my zone you know that's where I live that's where that's the the emotional space I in habit for
  11. um most of my day but you know honestly I my faith has been important to me always has been and all my close friends
  12. and my colleagues everyone knows that so I don't mean that they would be surprised but more that I was surprised
  13. that it was something I wanted to write about or put out there publicly not because I was ashamed but because it's
  14. so it's so personal it's so vulnerable I mean if you're going to write a book about faith and it is in any way
  15. authentic then you're more or less putting your heart out there and in this world which I don't have to remind you
  16. that's really terrifying and so for me to put it out there like that um I'm certainly not holding myself up as any
  17. kind of model of behavior or anything I'm not any kind of Theologian or biblical scholar it's just Reflections
  18. from a a real person a real life more learning more from disappointments and setbacks at any time sure so one of the
  19. things though is let's leave aside the performative people who talk about religion who do it for some other reason
  20. um you were a quiet faithful person as me as most people are you know what I mean that people they don't do you think
  21. people are scared not scared and asham to talk about it but you because it's so personal that's why you didn't want to
  22. you don't talk about it or publicly I guess yeah well I mean first of all everyone knows yeah
  23. publicly I mean I have talked about it you know from time to time which is how this opportunity to write about it came
  24. to me you know I've certainly never run from it but you know I think people are quiet about their faith because for one
  25. thing AR isn't the Mantra you're not supposed to talk about religion politics Happ one of those has to
  26. hold yes it doesn't it doesn't but also because you know this isn't I'm not out here trying to proti or persuade I'm I
  27. the the truth of the matter is I never thought I would write a book about God I I never thought I'd write any book and I
  28. and I didn't want to really I was happy to just have this be something personal to me but when the opportunity came up I
  29. found myself not able to say the immediate no I've said to every other offer of any kind of writing whatsoever
  30. and the reason was was because it seemed intriguing it seemed challenging it seems terrifying and it's the subject
  31. I'm most passionate and interested in and I'm always telling you know especially young producers or interns or
  32. people that have ever asked me for advice I always say you know get out of your comfort zone anything interesting
  33. you do in your life will be outside your comfort zone it's on the other side of a
  34. big risk that you take and it had been a while since I had taken my own advice and so I thought I'm going to try a lot
  35. about um some deep by the way it's a bestseller so it's doing people are responding to it um in the book you
  36. write about some deeply personal topics including the loss of your father who died when you were teenagers you also
  37. talk about your husband and your kids and how you see both marriage and Parenthood as metaphors for
  38. relationships with god um talk a little bit about this why you wrote it the way you
  39. did well the big Revelation is mostly what God does that's the title of the book and the rest of the sentence is
  40. mostly what God does is love you and I grew up in the church I had a traditional kind of Baptist upbringing
  41. and there's a lot about that that I still love and treasure but there was also a lot of guilt and shame and rules
  42. and of sense for me of always failing never Measuring Up and always kind of wondering what this looming God figure
  43. might have thought of me and through a life of again more mistakes than anything else what I came to realize is
  44. that mostly what God is doing at any given time is loving us it comes actually from scripture it comes from a
  45. verse in Ephesians that was retranslated by a scholar named Eugene Peterson and this the verse goes watch what God does
  46. and you do it too the way children learn proper behavior from their parents mostly what God does is love you when I
  47. read that sentence years and years ago it was a radical reframing of how I thought about God rather than this angry
  48. Taskmaster scolding or being disappointed or you know having a bill of particulars of all the ways we and
  49. all of humanity fails mostly what God is doing is loving you that's true for me it's true for you
  50. it's even true for Scott who's very silent talk a minute comes in with the big I'm I'm I'm teasing but the thing is
  51. is that I I wrote about it in the in the terms of Parenthood because that was another moment where when I had kids I
  52. was in my 40s I was so lucky to get to have kids at that late date long after I thought I had screwed up everything and
  53. would never have my chance and to have a child is truly the most I think the closest we'll ever get to understanding
  54. how God relates to us you know we love our kids we're Amazed by our kids we Delight in our kids we relish their
  55. little accomplishments we Delight in their milestones we not only love them we often like them we adore them well
  56. that's how God feels about every human being and I'm not making this up there's other versions this is the very metaphor
  57. there are other versions of it Scott why don't you come in here by the way you know uh uh God is dog spelled backwards
  58. so dog there you go Savannah it's really nice to meet you um hi Scott first off congratulations on your success I think
  59. this is a brave book for someone in your position to write because you're just subjecting yourself to a lot of scrutiny
  60. and your vulnerability and and I can see why it's a bestseller so acknowledging that I I love what you've written I love
  61. what David Brooks has written about the importance of community and how much comfort religion gives people and
  62. there's definitely a a hole in American society where people are having trouble Bing each other and the agency of
  63. something bigger than them and religion plays an incredibly important role and as a devout atheist I also want to
  64. acknowledge that I think we would probably benefit from an upsurge in religious institutions in America having
  65. said that I Warrior what would you do to provide Comfort to people when you say mostly what God does what I see mostly
  66. God being used for quite frankly right now is often times good people do good things bad people do bad things when
  67. good people do horrendous things usually God is at the center or some form of their vision of God and what I see in
  68. America is the religion and legislation that the line is being blurred and being
  69. used for quite frankly incredible misogyny incredible discrimination so what would you do to provide Comfort to
  70. people that recognize the importance that church plays but see increasingly that that God is being if you will
  71. weaponized well I understand those those sentiments you know I live in the real world too and you know I write a lot
  72. about doubt in the book and the doubt isn't does God exist the doubt The Crucible of of Doubt
  73. for any deeply thinking faithful person is where is God you know does why would why would a good God allow unmerited
  74. suffering yeah you for what you're talking about you say this in one chapter you write waking each morning to
  75. an overnight news summary which often has a headline after headline of bad news you wrote it feels like uh it feels
  76. like uh taking 20 punches to the gut in Rapid succession yeah and I mean I I hear and understand
  77. exactly what Scott is laying out I mean again I live in this world too I I would
  78. only say that what you're describing has more to do with humans than it does to do with God and I understand but I I I
  79. would say try to get back to the source material Go Back to Basics you know look
  80. for God for yourself look Within I mean looking out in the world whether I mean frankly Any Human Institution and every
  81. human even our most treasured and most devout or most faithful or most moral humans we have they're still human and
  82. this is in my faith view this is not the world that God intended we live in a broken world and um there's just no
  83. getting around that and P.S I don't have the answers to that in this little yellow book I don't the only thing I say
  84. is that I believe that God yearns to engage with us even on our doubts even with our doubts in fact I think that's I
  85. think that's part of faith I think doubt is kind of Faith being worked out um it's not an exception to Faith it's it's
  86. an aspect of Faith indifference and apathy now that might get you a little more to opposite of Faith so I
  87. understand all those doubts and I don't try to run from them I try to explain how I have dealt with them either
  88. personally with my own set or the world that I see that breaks my heart every single day what what what do you say to
  89. he just said he's a devout atheist right Scotch just said I happen to be more of
  90. an agnostic because I don't know and I you're closeted atheist but anyway no I'm not no I'm not because I've been
  91. literally walking by Churches recently and thinking I'd like to go in agre I don't know why I don't know I don't and
  92. I don't go in by the way um May sorry I don't mean to answer for you go ahead okay I don't I don't know I don't no no
  93. it's something else I don't know what it is it's not I don't want to see more people Scott that's something I want to
  94. do the opposite of um but what um it's true sanah um what who are you writing for are you writing to reach those
  95. people or what's what were what's the goal here for you I mean the book is not for any particular person I really mean
  96. that it is not in any way prati if it's persuasive that's not what it's intended
  97. to do it's it's a description of a relationship with God and I hope that it's ultimately appealing because I
  98. think God is quite compelling so I I write about um there's a chapter called the fragrance of the Gospel right which
  99. is a line from scripture but I say you know the idea is it's a fragrance right it's not a stench it's not an odor it's
  100. not the person next to you wearing too much perfume it's it's a fragrance I I hope that a life that is lived with
  101. recognition that God loves every human heart yourself and every human you see on the street I hope that life carries a
  102. fragrance that is appealing and compelling but no I'm not trying to write to any particular person I'm
  103. trying to write to every particular person who cares to pick up this book and in a lot of ways I'm writing to
  104. myself because this encouragement is something I need all the time I mean I still need to be reminded that God loves
  105. me that even more radically that God could like me yeah I mean this is if you could let that in if you could re let it
  106. in even for a moment it's pretty transformative but it's not the kind of thing that you learn once and then it's
  107. stands for all time it's like when you get married you don't say I love you sweetie and then in 30 years you're like
  108. remember I told you on her wedding day no you are in it every single day and you have to continue to seek that
  109. connection and that's how I think about faith as well Scott by the way I love you Scott sorry go I love you too Cara
  110. thank you for saying that uh uh so I'm asking this question should I leave no no okay so I'm asking this question
  111. generally for an answer not as a comment um what advice I know you have kids I have 13 and 16y old boys and I genuinely
  112. struggle with the role that I should play in in determining what the role religion should play in their life as
  113. someone who believes at some point I'll look into their eyes and I believe our relationship will come to an end when I
  114. die I also recognize as someone who spent a lot of time in temples and churches that there is something
  115. wonderful for kids about being involved uh in a religious institution but I struggle with how to incorporate it in a
  116. thoughtful way um anyways what advice would you have for someone who you know buys into
  117. the institutions not necessarily the lineage and see some of some of the danger and quite frankly if I woke up
  118. one day and my kid was super religious I got to be honest with you Savannah would
  119. be heartbroken and but at the same time I realize the value it can play in their
  120. lives and I want to incorporate it in a thoughtful way what advice would you have uh uh for for parents that feel the
  121. same way yeah well I mean I'm definitely with with you asked me but I definitely
  122. do not present myself who as somebody who could give any kind of advice on parenting as I'm just struggling along
  123. blindly myself but I'll tell you what I do I'm my husband is Jewish we have an Interfaith household what I have decided
  124. and this is a little different because I do carry a deep Faith within me so what
  125. I try to do is share that with my kids and yes to a certain extent you know you're talking about religious
  126. institutions I have I I I go to church I've always belonged to a religious institution but to me I don't let the
  127. religious institutions um I don't like them I don't let them ruin God for me you know I try to know God for myself
  128. know Jesus for himself through scriptures through prayer through personal interaction and of our
  129. religious institutions which are imperfect as all humans are I I try to take with Grace the best that they have
  130. to offer and and and then have Grace with their failings but what I try to do is teach my kids about the God that I
  131. know and not just in a way of dragging them to church although I do I my sister says in our growing up she said God was
  132. the sixth member of our family and what she meant by that was we were always kind of in conversation with god or
  133. about God you know and when my kids have a problem I might introduce God into the
  134. topic now this is easier for me because I believe in God and you don't but I think that's how I try to do it and if
  135. you you know don't have those feelings you feel strongly that's different but if somebody was wondering they might
  136. just say especially with a 13 and 16-year-old who's I have no doubt your boys are quite smart as you are you know
  137. it's okay if you want to investigate that a little bit and you have to understand that faith is is it's
  138. intellectual but it's also spiritual and emotional we're on multi-dimensional Realms here okay so you know you can't
  139. nobody can sit here and prove it to you and give you a set of facts even if they
  140. gave you in controvertible facts that wouldn't be enough faith is in the end a leap and I if I had older kids I think
  141. that's what I'd say to them my little kids you know these These are they're seven and nine now as they start to ask
  142. questions my view is I've told them what I know they will choose for themselves their
  143. faith or no faith at all and that that will be their choice I only know my responsibility is to expose them how do
  144. you incorporate your husband being Jewish is he how do you incorporate because there's a lot of well we like
  145. this there's like my my wife is Jewish but we we haven't done anything at all and I wouldn't bring them to church
  146. although with my older kids what my ex-wife did was um she took them to all different churches all the time like she
  147. would go to a temple she would go to a seek Temple she would go to a bapt she brought them to a lot un Unitarian was
  148. where she know tended to zero out on but um she took them to a lot of places which I thought was kind of a great idea
  149. I couldn't I didn't I think I I mean look I my view is sort of give God some access to their hearts and let him do
  150. the rest I mean why do we act like we're going to what we say is somehow going to
  151. be what they end up believing anyway so I feel a respon responsibility because I
  152. do feel my faith so strongly that I want to share with them what I know my my husband he comes from the Jewish
  153. tradition and he shares his traditions and we let those all live alongside each other now look I we don't have to get
  154. into chapter and verse why at some point although there's so much in common between our faiths why at some point
  155. there may be questions in a conflict and when that day comes I hope that we can answer it with as much love
  156. understanding Grace and humility as possible for all we know and all we don't know
  157. but you know there's a my kids used to go they don't go to this school anymore but it wasn't a religious Church a
  158. religious school but it had religious it was an old religious schools but 100 years later in New York City it didn't
  159. but they still had Chapel every week and what I loved about it was you know the chapel had nothing religious in it but
  160. it was space and time for something other than the Here and Now for something other than what right in front
  161. of you so maybe it's a long-winded way of getting to something of an answer SC which is to however you do it to leave a
  162. little space and if God chooses to enter that space well won't you be lucky even
  163. though Scott you'll be in despair why should anything change why should anything change well you know
  164. what Scott all I my big View and I write about this in the book is God speaks our
  165. language like you open your heart and you give a little access point then let God do the rest he's God you're not not
  166. or not that we not if you're you but you may be surprised you were sitting here thinking the reason I am interested I I
  167. was grew up Catholic and I they hated gay people they did they did they did and that was what re made me reject it
  168. so strongly one of the and I thought they were horrible in so many ways the people that ran the church including
  169. around uh sexual assault and stuff um but one of the things that I think I'm attracted to is the quiet it's so quiet
  170. in there and I think you're right being quiet is a very difficult thing these days um I'm going to ask you one more
  171. question Scott may have one more but I do have to ask you about these AI generated companion and workbooks being
  172. sold to a company your book mine are I there's full books of Caris Wier with really creepy looking uh Caris swier
  173. faces on them you you you look I don't look hot stop it stop it and this now Savannah we have a nice guest in our
  174. thing we have a nice lady with us stop it um when do you what did you think when you you you brought them up to me
  175. what what did you think when you first saw them pop up and these are workbooks workbooks that they sell them to ACC
  176. company your book and you had nothing to do with them and you could do a workbook
  177. for example well yes I mean and here's the thing my mother's the one who told me about it she said oh honey I'm I
  178. bought your workbook I'm like what workbook right and then she's told me to look it up and then I saw it and you
  179. know what is horrifying about it is well I mean first of all who knows what the heck it says with our names on it but
  180. also people spend their real money it's not like it's $1 it was $4.99 actually at one of my book events
  181. this nice lady brought it to me she said I just wanted you to know there are these fake workbook
  182. and I said oh H I'm I'm all over it I know and I of course immediately said it to the publisher but there's very little
  183. they can do if the I don't understand it you know totally from a legal perspective if there's a true likeness
  184. to your book like there were a few that came on that were light yellow like mine
  185. they could get those taken down but the others they don't and it's just really unfortunate because people are spending
  186. their their money on it and also for authors and even Publishers you know that's that's a book not sold right
  187. somebody I I hope you know I complained to the CEO of Amazon to your behalf so you know I just was it was like crazy
  188. but they can't do anything Scott final question so when you were when you and your boyfriend now husband were thinking
  189. about building a life together and you I I don't know if you had the conversation around religion but
  190. it's it's unlikely unless people meet at church or Temple that they exact views on this topic calibrate perfectly and
  191. did you have conversations around this did you find you needed to accommodate did one person grow into it more than
  192. the other was it less important to one person than the other so it it shape more around who was important to talk
  193. about how you decided that religion should should morph or not such that you could shape a life together we talked
  194. about it a lot and you know of course I came up in a tradition where you weren't
  195. supposed to marry outside the faith and I think his tradition probably was the same as well so right there we're
  196. already you know Heretics in some sense but we talked about it a ton and and um we actually this isn't the only reason
  197. that we faed around and dated for five long years before getting married but it is one of the topics that came up how
  198. can we make this work and still have integrity with both of our faiths and that's something that we're trying to do
  199. and not water down either one and you know I I kind of indicated this when they're little it's easier to do that
  200. when they're older I I anticipate because I believe my kids I hope I'm raising smart thinking kids who aren't
  201. afraid to ask hard questions you know I anticipate that that will come up and that we will deal with it as it does but
  202. what I knew I couldn't do was in any way water down or walk away from my faith and my husband has known this about me
  203. since our very first date and in no way would ever ask me to I have to give him a ton of credit too I mean it for me to
  204. not only be this person but then to be in this strange position where now I'm writing a book about faith which is so
  205. out there you know he never once was like well that's great sweetie but do you need to he he completely and totally
  206. supported me which I am so grateful for and and the biggest thing I've learned is whether you have a lot of faith or a
  207. lot of Doubt or something altogether different I do think to your point Scott people long for connection and they want
  208. to have conversations that are deep and meaningful and I've had more conversations even with friends I've had
  209. forever since writing this book I mean even Cara and I who are text besties and we've talked about a lot of things and
  210. when I said oh I'm writing this book that opened up a conversation or a lane of conversation we hadn't had before and
  211. I loved that she was so open and interested and said like oh I love talking to people about faith it doesn't
  212. mean I agree with your faith it means isn't it interesting to have these conversations it is isn't this more
  213. valuable to spend time talking about what you believe what you don't believe let's connect as humans this is the
  214. stuff that actually matters and I'm hoping that the book at least creates that opportunity this book is really
  215. interesting I've really enjoyed uh reading it um and I think it's good Scott does talk about Community a lot
  216. and it's important to this is what it's about faith and Community which is doesn't necessarily have to have any
  217. religion at all um the book is mostly what God does Reflections on seeking and finding his love Everywhere by Savannah
  218. Guthrie and her AI friends anyway thank you so much thank you I so enjoyed it thanks Scott thanks
  219. Cara

Brief Summary

Savannah Guthrie discusses her new book on faith, personal reflections, and the complexities of discussing religion in today's society.

Key points

  • Savannah Guthrie's Brave New Book. Savannah shares her journey of writing about faith and vulnerability.
  • The Central Message of Faith. Savannah discusses the essence of her book: God's love.
  • The Impact of Fake Workbooks. Authors face challenges with fake workbooks that mislead readers and affect sales.
  • Navigating Faith in Marriage. A couple discusses how they manage differing religious beliefs while building a life together.
  • The Importance of Deep Conversations. Writing a book about faith opens up new conversations with friends.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes