Sam Altman Says OpenAI Not "Moral Police" After Backlash | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara and Scott discuss the fallout from the Young Republicans' Telegram chat leak, Instagram’s new protections for teens, and OpenAI allowing "erotica" for adults.  Plus, Kara has thoughts about Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff’s call for National Guard troops in San Francisco, and Scott has a prediction about the future of the podcasting business.

We're going on tour! Get your tickets at https://pivottour.com

00:00 Intro 6:41 Leaked Young Republican Texts 18:45 AI Safety Bills 28:51 Instagram’s PG-13 Rating 38:23 Meta Removes Ice-Tracking Page 46:46 Marc Benioff: Send Troops to SF 56:29 DOD’s New Press Policy 01:04:42 Predictions

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin

Video Producer: Jim Mackil

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Sam Alman saying we shouldn't be the morality police. No, no, actually you should.
  2. Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisser
  3. and I'm Scott Galloway. Scott, guess where I am? Where are you? Los Angeles. Your favorite place. You
  4. love Los Angeles. Yes. And what are you doing there? Um, I am working on the one of the last
  5. interviews for this secret documentary from Steve with the the hacking guy. Worst kept secret. The hacking guy. Yeah. I met him at the Aspen gathering.
  6. Oh. Um. Yeah. Thoughts. Did you discuss all your body? All my stuff. Yeah. Well, of course he wanted to know my secret. Um, and I said, "Well, actually,
  7. you know, I'm like, other than, you know, the lower faceelift, the chin implant, my eyes done, the pico laser,
  8. the fractal laser, the vitamin A, vitamin D, NAD, and testosterone shots. It's all just genetics. I guess I'm
  9. lucky. I guess I'm lucky. Oh, and I I forgot to mention I've worked out four times a week for the last 40 years."
  10. I think that's called epigenetics, the things that you do to affect yourself. Uh, I I think it's called narcissism
  11. crisis. talk about the age of eight. We're going to talk about that topic because I do think a lot of this is born
  12. of narcissism. See, I feel like if I insult him, I'm insulting you. But here we are. Um I mean, I'm sure it's not you know what though, it's not easy. It's not easy being a four. Like when I
  13. was younger, well, anyways, when I was younger, I was handsome. That was really good. Yeah. I'm getting to the point now. I think
  14. being really ugly is pretty easy because you just sort of lean into it and give up. Like I'm almost there. I'm ready to
  15. lean into the ugly. Ugly is unattractive. You know, ugly can be unattractive. Excuse me. Ugly. That's illuminated. Sounds like you won journalism awards in in college. Uh I did.
  16. I know he did. That's why I brought a fun award. Let's bring that back for people. You You've brought it up several thousand. When I find that medal in my basement
  17. with my Bitcoin, I'm going to wear it every episode. So, wear it as a belt. Anyways, the but
  18. it's not easy being like I'm I'm like the most difficult place is being mediocre looking. It's like when I had great hair that was awesome. I actually like having a shaved head. It was when I
  19. was losing my hair for 10 years that it was a pain. I'm in the transition phase. I'm transitioning from modestly good-looking
  20. to very definitely not good-looking. And it's the transition that's painful. I hate to pay you a compliment, but I
  21. think you're very good-looking. Go on. I'm sorry. My mic was off. Classic deal. You look you're very
  22. classic looks. I think you're classic. No one's ever David's looking too. I guess I don't know.
  23. Oh my god. You just blew it. You literally just blew it. I did that on purpose. Let me think.
  24. Patrick Patrick um the guy who was um Stewart. You have a very Patrick Stewart. Patrick Stewart. I've
  25. had a British accent. It would work for you. I get Ivan Lindle, Bruce Stern, and Ryan
  26. Reynolds. Uh Drunk Uncle. Um no, I would say Oh, I like Bruce Stern. I like Bruce D. Another hand.
  27. Yeah, you have that sort of like face that. Yeah. Yeah. Let me hear your British accent. An elevator face. Let me hear your British accent. No, I can't do accents anymore. It sounds like a dead language twins.
  28. You do your dad one, your Scottish one. But I need a few drinks for that one. You could do French. You could move to
  29. France. You could do the French accent and that was a cheese the cheese eating surrender monkeys. Was that too much?
  30. too much. It's so attractive. I don't know if I was, but you know, I'd be making out with you right now.
  31. Oh, yeah. That's That will never That's what happens when I start. We will never be arrested in a park.
  32. We're never going to We're never going to find either. We We'll never find you topless in a car. We might find me
  33. topless in a car. That's true. We'll find you topless on stage. Oh my god, we got so much feedback. We got so much feedback. Why did people
  34. love that so much? I felt they went together nicely because the gold coin story I did not think was going to land
  35. honestly and then it did like terrifically and then the arrest one people loved both of them.
  36. No, but the thing is when you're arrested twice it's a pattern like you're definitely everyone's like what a gangster cuz if you're arrested once who knows you're in college you never know right or you get pulled who knows but
  37. arrested twice definitely means you know you you you fought the law and the law won. I mean, I almost got arrested one
  38. other time where this, you know, when these sort of local police officers can be like, "Does it involve lesbian sex? Cuz I'm
  39. here for it." No, this guy was yelling at a lady and um and I intervened and he was like
  40. being really abusive. He's one of those like cops. I I love I like most cops actually. I've always had relatively
  41. good Well, most some people don't, other people. It's my favorite stripper is one.
  42. It's true. Oh, I went to a stripper once. They had a cop strip. Yeah. The Hangar Club.
  43. Why? Why are you getting that one? You used to have a loyalty card. I went actually I just heard from all my
  44. college friends are all coming to DC and we're going out and they were kind of wild. They were a wild gang and like
  45. always drunk and everything and I was like the good one and like I'd study and come and they'd like you come back and
  46. there'd be nine guys they made out with on the floor of our place. But we all went to a place for one of my um
  47. roommates birthdays called the hangar club in get it hanger. Hangar. And they would uh let the strippers in. I went to a one of those. It was it was something else. Were you out in college?
  48. No. No. No. But it was terrible. So you were dating dating men or just had crushes on girls?
  49. Vaguely. You know, I I had sort of stopped I had a four-year high school boyfriend essentially and then I had
  50. boyfriends all the way through. Um, but I have the same boyfriend for 4 years. Yeah. Yeah. Mhm.
  51. Wow. Are you guys still in contact? Um, a little bit. A little bit. Um, I haven't talked to him in a while. I
  52. haven't talked to him in a while. He's great. He's a great guy. Yeah. His name was Chris Price. I'll say it. He's really nice. He was really
  53. nice. Yeah, we 10th grade until his freshman year of college. So, I broke up once in the middle of it. I knew I was gay. I should have not done that. I shouldn't have gone out at the time. by
  54. by that time. I should have not I should have not I should have said something. But one didn't do that then. Scott, he
  55. was lovely. I was a really good girlfriend because I put out because I didn't care.
  56. You're probably pretty easygoing. Yeah, why not? Like what do I care? Anyway, we do have a lot to get to today, including Instagram going PG-13
  57. and OpenAI going in the opposite direction with erotica. But first, leaked texts from messaging platform
  58. Telegram revealed leaders of the young Republican groups exchanged racist, sexist, and anti-semitic texts over the span of seven months. The chats included
  59. jokes about enslavement, uh negative comments about minorities. They're really gross. I'm not going to repeat them, but they're like, "Think of the
  60. worst thing and then make it worse was what they were, and discussions about raping enemies and driving them to
  61. suicide." Uh, and if you see the pictures of these people, each one looks like an insult. Honestly, the young
  62. Republican National Federation said it was appalled by the language and suggested those involved must resign. But as usual, JD Vance, couch potato,
  63. took the opportunity to criticize a Democratic Virginia's AG candidate who is texting scandal of his own regarding
  64. political violence. That guy is terrible. But of course, J Vance can't possibly just say sorry. Uh Vance called
  65. the response to the Republican group text pearl clutching in comparison. Uh let's listen to a clip of him on the
  66. Charlie Kirk show. he's going to have a great job as a podcaster when he leaves office. But the reality is that kids do stupid
  67. things, especially young boys. They tell edgy, offensive jokes. Like, that's what
  68. kids do. And I really don't want us to grow up in a country where a kid telling a stupid joke, telling a very offensive
  69. stupid joke is caused to ruin their lives. And at some point, we're all all going to have to say enough of this BS.
  70. I'll tell you who's enough of this BS is JD Vance. uh some individuals exposed and the messages have been fired at
  71. least one young Republicans groups have been disbanded. Um what do you think of this? Because it really was over the top
  72. and you know it's we we do it's not cancel cultures back but it was pretty horrible like it was shock I I was even
  73. surprised maybe I shouldn't have been. What did you think? Initially, all else being equal, I sort of agree with JD
  74. Vance in the sense that well, give me some time here and then you can pose for the woke ring line.
  75. I'm not going to Don't always pull Don't bring that up. Don't always bring woke. That's your excuse. When you're losing an argument,
  76. you say woke, but go ahead. Move on. You do. I don't know. Uh, anyways, so I empathize with the notion that we had the luxury of not having a digital world
  77. where every every ridiculously offensive stupid thing we did, I mean, the [ __ ]
  78. the [ __ ] we did in college, I look back on. I cringe and I thank God I wasn't involved. Now, having said that, can I just interject for people for a fact? No, because you're you're going to steal
  79. my thunder and then everyone's going to come on and say, "Okay, go Cara." Um, all right. One, these aren't children. Some of these, some of these people, specifically, some
  80. of these men are not even young men. They're 31 and 35. Uh, two, he's the wrong messenger for
  81. this because he's totally inconsistent. If this was the Democratic, young Democratic chat, he would have ordered a gunship and [ __ ] the Army Rangers to
  82. their homes. And uh this is the same group of people that says that a joke about uh Donald Trump talking about a ballroom when asked
  83. about Charlie Kirk is so offensive that it should be removed from the air. So it's incredibly hypocritical and inconsistent for Vice President Vance to say anything about come on guys. It's
  84. just speed. It's just, you know, bros, frat kids going to be frat kids. And also, these are not children.
  85. And when you look at what they said, I don't like there is a certain gotcha culture where the media goes crazy around calling people out. But the reality is when you read these texts,
  86. these young men or or adults, these adult men are about to learn a valuable life lesson in that there is no context for which these types of conversations
  87. or statements are acceptable. And distinctive whether they're racist, bigoted, whatever, homophobic, it should it should logically,
  88. practically from a common sense standpoint hurt their careers because these these people just lack so much
  89. common sense. Yeah. And they have such poor judgment. Yeah. To not only think these things, but to
  90. put them down in a text chat. So look, but again, for me, this all comes back to the same thing. go with it because it's one more day we're not talking about Epstein. I think in the the big
  91. picture, this really isn't this is a pimple on the pimple of what's going on in this country. It's a bunch of [ __ ]
  92. idiots who shouldn't who should have a trouble getting a job because this will come up in their Google searches and
  93. it's a good life lesson for young people, especially young men who are more risk aggressive and and and more
  94. more prone to say really stupid [ __ ] And I do believe, and I've said this about the campus protests, I'm less
  95. bothered by what a 19-year-old says at Cornell than I'm by what some of the faculty have said, tweeting and and some of the statements they've issued. I think that they've had time to develop
  96. some critical thinking skills. You have come I I have you have come, you know, this is what the kids say. I I
  97. do give a wide birth to teen teenagers. And also that said, it was this these weren't just little jokes. It went on and on and on and it's weird because it was really upsetting. It was really upsetting. That's what I
  98. was two things came to me at once is I see your explanation here, but um is that it was um first of all, they were stupid. That's what that really struck me and dumb like this is what they think
  99. is funny. Um two is the hypocrisy as you noted about making Jimmy Kimmel making what was a funny joke uh because Trump
  100. said it uh versus this like this haha. But I do think it's a pervasive feeling among these people. They really like it's it's so I I I was that that
  101. the return of this and maybe it would never went away was something I would like it to go away again, but I guess
  102. they're thinking it. So maybe just to see it, we'll just be clear of who these people are. I I don't think they'll be
  103. punished at all. But JD Van should step out of it. That's my feeling. like especially cuz he was he's the one
  104. that's always like you should be able to say all these kids will pay a yeah they'll pay a price
  105. uh look I won't even say kids although they feel like kids when you're getting this old and and folks this is a lesson to young people out there I hate to say this but
  106. a lot of times people will send an email saying I appreciate how provocative and how profane you are I want to be more
  107. bold and I write back don't don't yeah or I write back and say are you already rich Because if you're economically
  108. secure and have people who love you unconditionally, fine. You can take more license with the things you say and occasionally say something stupid and
  109. have people push back and it doesn't threaten your economic livelihood. But in this era, the reality is if you go to
  110. work for JP Morgan or Goldman Sachs, they run a credit check on you. Now, you know what they also do? They check your
  111. social media. What's going to happen when these kids go on to want to be, you know, leave government and want to go be work at Lazar Frera or whatever for a
  112. law firm or a lobbying firm. The first thing the HR director does is they do a Google search on you. What's going to
  113. come up with these kids and this is what's going to happen. They're never even going to know why they didn't get an interview. Oh,
  114. they'll know there because the HR person is going to see, oh, this is a person making light
  115. of gas chambers and using the n-word. Well, you know what? Maybe we should look at the other 99 applicants we have.
  116. Yeah, it's true. It's too much bother and someone will come up with it and someone will know who it was and everything else. But there is
  117. and for them if they if they'd showed up with an AR-15 to the No Kings rally, they they would have found some
  118. Republican weirdos that want to hire them. Yeah. Everyone's going to run from this. There's nothing cool about this. There's
  119. nothing provocative. There's nothing rightwing. I think even most Republicans are working on a limb, I guess, to create havoc, I suppose, with the
  120. distraction. And speaking of which, I I I urge everyone to read the excerpts from uh I think it's Virginia Grey um
  121. her her she's postumously published a book about uh her uh experiences with Jeffrey Epste, and it is it's it's beautiful, right? Yeah, I read it. You sent it. It's very upsetting. Uh but it's it's so
  122. plainly said and and I think it links to the way men some men think about women,
  123. right? like it was sort of she was making the bigger point that it wasn't just the sickness of Jeffrey Epstein,
  124. but that there were more people who who act like this or feel like it's their privilege to talk about people and to um
  125. but everything rang true in that first exchange when she was a kid with her and Galain Gileain Maxwell and him and if he
  126. if after reading that if Trump lets her out he really is culpable. I just don't know how else you could read anything close to that and not think that. I don't know. And there's been story after
  127. story. The two things that struck me were reading that article cuz I I' I'd heard
  128. most of it from other sources before before the two things that struck me were one there is supposedly there is research
  129. showing that pedophiles target kids who have an absent or what they perceive as a weak uh male role
  130. model. Yeah. that they sum up the level of male involvement in that person's life and
  131. prey on people. And you can imagine uh children of single parents from low-inccome homes uh are just more
  132. likely to be victims, which is obviously very upsetting. The other thing that really struck me here, Cara, that I didn't know about, like her dad
  133. introduced her at Mara Lago. Yeah. To a Trump. Like I mean folks at what point at what point is there there's just so much evidence right
  134. around Epstein and Mara Lago and Trump. It's like wait they met this whole thing
  135. started at Mara Lago. Yeah. Yeah it did. You didn't know that because that's why Trump said he kicked
  136. uh Epstein out because he he poached he was stealing employees. Not because he was not because he was a convicted
  137. pedophile but because he was stealing his employees. remember he had that sentence where it looked like he owned her like he took one of my things like I
  138. know anyway the whole thing you must read it cuz it's very so plainly written and everything rings true I have to say
  139. especially about the that encounter the way he talked to her the way they tried to pull it and Galain Maxwell I mean
  140. Epstein is dead and don't rest in peace but boy she's a monster the the same in the same manner like grotesque and should never be let out of prison and should be thrown thrown into a deeper
  141. prison. As far as I'm concerned, it's already happened. The fix is already in. Yeah. He sent his personal lawyer down to
  142. interview her. That never happens. And then what do you know? She's transferred to a lower uh a more pleasant prison.
  143. The fix is already a pardon. He cannot give her a pardon. Cara, every time we've said that, we
  144. have found out that in fact he can. Like the feels like the third rail. Anyway, it's already been
  145. the wheels are the wheels are already in motion. All of a sudden, she's at a a more amendable, more comfortable prison.
  146. Yeah. Total violation of all decorum around justice where a lawyer went down to interview her. And now uh this is the
  147. fix is in. I think it's already I think it's already happened. Well, I'll tell you I'll tell you one thing. If she does get out, people
  148. should like OJ, she should lead a restless life where she never gets a moment's piece. I have to say what she
  149. did to these young girls is repulsive and in she's a monster. She's an She's I never think say the word evil about
  150. people, but she's evil and so was he. Anyway, I I recommend you reading it. And it's sad. The Virginia um committed
  151. suicide, by the way, before this book came out. She was in a terrible car accident, wasn't she? Or was
  152. she It's kind of unclear what happened, but ultimately it sounds her life sounds she was a vulnerable young woman who had
  153. a history of um sexual abuse, and she was a perfect mark for these two terrible predators. Anyway, um speaking of which, California Governor Gavin Newsome vetoed a bill this week would
  154. have banned miners from using AI chatbots. His reason the bill's restrictions were too broad. I would agree. He did sign another AI safety
  155. bill requiring chatbots that tell users their AI and reminding miners every 3 hours to take breaks. OpenAI called the
  156. bill a meaningful move forward for AI safety standards. Those CEO Sam Alton also just revealed that OpenAI will
  157. allow verified youth adults to access erotica on chat GBT in December. Um it's I'm not sure if these are related, but they feel like they are. Um the first bill I I know it was pushed by a lot of
  158. different groups, but it was broad because it seemed like it was attacking older people, too. And it felt like um
  159. we have to really specifically carve out minors here um in a way. Um I think it's
  160. harder to try to ban regular people from having older people, excuse me, from having um relationships with chaps, as
  161. weird as they may be. and how even if they lead to bad outcomes that many of them have. Um I I think we I don't know
  162. what to say about the the erotica. Do do you what do you think about what is and isn't getting regulated and and the
  163. erotica thing? Um Sam Alman later said open was not the elected moral police of the world. I I didn't think they were
  164. but okay. What do what do you think? Look I don't you know Oh god. So, he's trying really hard not to make a joke. Well, no. No, I'm not. I wrote I'm
  165. writing this book on masculinity. And I think one of the things that kills masculinity is an overindulgence in porn because I think key to success
  166. Yeah. You talk about and one of and one of the important things and one of the wonderful things about being a man is that we're more
  167. risk aggressive. Now, sometimes that results in reckless behavior, but sometimes it also results in valor and
  168. and wonderful things can happen when you apply for a job you're not qualified for. When you start a business that
  169. makes no sense and ends up being crazy genius, when you approach a woman and take uh the risk of rejection, it can
  170. lead to wonderful places. The problem with porn I find among young men is that an overconumption of porn reduces their mojo to take risks and establish relationships that might lead to
  171. romantic relationships. And that is we have demonized and pathized sexual desire among young men. And the reality
  172. is it's like fire. It can lead to bad places. It can lead to objectifying women. It can lead to inappropriate
  173. behavior. But for the most part, it's the fire that goes into an engine that creates a better you or desire for
  174. better you. I want to look better. I want to look. I want to work out. I want to smell nice. I want to groom. I want
  175. to have a plan. I want to dress well. I want to take risks. I want to demonstrate kindness.
  176. So, the idea of a combination of erotic content with the character AI and synthetic relationship capabilities of these companies, I think, is a [ __ ] disaster. Because the first time a
  177. 14-year-old male gets shunned by a 14-year-old girl, which is part of growing up because women have a much finer filter for mating opportunities because the downside of sex is so much
  178. greater. I mean, if you want if you're a dude and you want to have women in your life and
  179. you want romantic opportunities, that involves one thing, rejection and hopefully resilience. And what I worry
  180. about is the first signs of rejection. a 14-year-old, a 15-year-old, 16-year-old
  181. uh boy starts turning to this awesome synthetic AI that looks like the hottest girl you've ever met who will tease you just enough and then Yeah. and then start showing you private parts
  182. and then let you engage in a series of erotic synthetic experiences that are low friction, low risk, and quite frankly just reduce the fire. You you
  183. can I just you use a word there which again that the people of Sila use all the time which is seamless frictionless
  184. they don't like friction like and the problem is I I've done a bunch of interviews about this lately and what's
  185. interesting is um the friction part like and it goes the other way women would like men more attentive more they could
  186. make their own characters right it's not going to be and they are just you know and then you have you know
  187. a frictionless relationship which I think is useless on some I mean it can be entertaining for a second. But once
  188. you get used to that, anyone in real life is incredibly problematic, right, for you because you're used to this sort of seamless, frictionless life. Sex is friction, of
  189. course, you know, physically. Um, but it really does um you can't The thing is, you can't really stop them from doing it, right? He's right. He's not the moral police. No, I don't, by the way, that's kind of a straw man. No one
  190. thought Open AI was the world's police. Moral police. fine, he can say that. Um,
  191. but uh, but more to the point, it just makes this ease of of easing us into these relationships of course will help his bottom line because this is the kind of thing you stay on there. Even early
  192. chat, if you remember, early chat groups were incredibly addictive just between and among different people. Especially I
  193. had a chapter in my AOL book called the house the house that uh online porn built cuz that's where it really got
  194. going is online porn early in early internet phase. This is just a quantum leap I think.
  195. Well, there's basically three ways to make money on the internet. There's ads, there's e-commerce, and there's porn,
  196. right? And the problem or one of the issues with porn is that there's very little peer-review research because the
  197. majority of academics don't want to be known as the porn professor. Yeah. And so, but just happening for you, Scott. Go ahead.
  198. Yeah. There you go. Um, I'm not going to touch that one. So, don't touch anything. Go ahead.
  199. Look, 68 million search queries related to pornography. We, you know, get this. A quarter of all searches are related to
  200. pornography. Yeah. Every day. a quarter of the searches, which gives you a sense of how big this business is.
  201. One U analyst found that porn generates roughly 10% of the comments on Reddit. 13% of X is not safe for work content.
  202. Tumblr, which was a porn site and they they and I said it was a porn site. They spent 1.1 billion. Marissa Mayor spent $ 1.1 billion for a porn site. And then the I forgot his name.
  203. the venture capitalist with a weird haircut from Union Square Ventures got angry at me and said Tumblr's amazing da
  204. da da after he had sold all his stock and then they announced under pressure they were doing away with porn and in 60
  205. days their traffic dropped by 30%. And then that $ 1.1 billion that $1.1 billion acquisition it was sold for I think $3 million 7 years later. Yeah, porn is enormous online and when you
  206. have when you have young men being pathized getting mixed signals around what the what's usually what used to be
  207. considered romantic is now creepy and they have access to 20 I mean I just to personalize this I barely graduated from UCLA barely I had graduated with a 2.27 27 GPA. And one of the reasons I went to
  208. 60 70% of my classes, not 10%, and didn't fail out, is I wanted to go on to UCLA and see my buddies and see friends and quite frankly be around a
  209. disproportionate amount of ridiculously hot women who I might get to know and at some point might have a relationship
  210. with. It was very motivating. And if I had had on demand synthetic lifelike porn,
  211. Yeah. I mean, how many men, what percentage of men are just not going to engage?
  212. You know what? They're just going to be, this is not an insult, but I could see you falling way down that rabbit hole. You're you're a lot shy also than people
  213. realize. And you're you you know, I think having difficult things happen to you is hard for someone like like you, but then you do it and it makes you a better per. You know what I mean? You
  214. have that's the whole that's the whole shooting match. the best things in our life. The best things in our life,
  215. whether it's getting a great job, whether it's finding a romantic partner who you're just crazy about, whether
  216. it's getting the opportunity to have your own sex, whether it's having the opportunity to give birth to a child,
  217. whether it's having the opportunity to create a loving household that's economically secure. All of those things involve one thing. They're really
  218. [ __ ] hard. with a ton of rejection, a ton of friction, a ton of dealing with the messiest, most difficult thing in history, other people. And these synthetic relationships are just
  219. constantly reinforcing, constantly making it easier. And if you're going to have I used to sneak into my father's
  220. garage and look at his old Playboys. If all of a sudden that thing comes to that woman comes to life and starts
  221. understanding me and talking about me and teasing me and doing sexual acts on demand. Yeah. This is just headed nowhere good.
  222. You know, nowhere. Interestingly, I had a synthetic version of me for this thing
  223. made and it disturbed me in every way because it got better by the second. It was that was what was disturbing to me. It's not quite there yet. Um, and I'm going to leave it to you in my will, but
  224. um, but the it is to give me a hard time. I know. Um, it's really um, let me text me late at night. You should apologize. It's going to It's a 3D, my friend. Text me at 2 in the morning.
  225. Text you're going to see the bo the moving body of Swisser. Um you you the thing is you you you would you you and people like you would
  226. move into this so quickly. And the key is that OpenAI, let me say besides all the other statements Sam made, this is
  227. for money. They want to this they've got to find revenue streams. And this is this is the the motherload of them. This
  228. is what it is. That's why they're they're not elect they were not elected the moral police, but they were elected to have to make money on this stuff. And
  229. this is this is a killer app and it will bleed to our children. It will bleed. They will not be able to keep children
  230. safe in this. Anyway, let me just add one other thing. Newsome is also signed a bill mandating health label warnings.
  231. Speaking of which, like the R thing or something on a cigarette. This comes as Instagram just announced new protections
  232. for teens limiting what they can see based on PG movies. The platform says it will hide uh content with strong
  233. language, risky stunts, and marijuana use from teen users. Oh no, not the not not the demon weed. Restrictions will
  234. also apply to AI bots. The updates follow recent reports questioning whether Instagram's existing teen account safeguards actually work. So
  235. they decried the people who said they don't these reports, but then they of course do something. They The point I
  236. want to make here is they don't think of it first. They should think of it first before these reports come out. And
  237. nothing's going to be perfect, by the way. I don't expect perfection, but they really are so sloppy in how they do do
  238. this. And then they're going to act like a PG-13 rating is the same thing because this is
  239. immersive. This isn't a movie theater down the street. This is something much different. Um, that's very hard to keep
  240. your teens out of, right? I mean, Scott, you this is what your book's about, right? This is this is one of these
  241. weigh stations that young men are going to go through, young teenagers, and it's not they're not coming out good on the
  242. other side of this because we slap a label on it. But I don't mind there being a label.
  243. When I was I think I was 13, I was with my best buddy Adam Markman and we lived in walking distance from Westwood
  244. Village, which by the way is a shadow of itself right now. But we used to we used to have friends who were ushers at all
  245. the theaters, the National, the man, the Breuan, the Westwood Village Theater, and we'd go and we'd try and get eye
  246. contact with one of our friends who was an usher. And he'd like leave a door open, we'd sneak in and and watch movies. And one day we took a wrong
  247. turn. And at the age of 13, we we stumbled into fell into William Blatty's The Exorcist. I could not in the morning, I would have
  248. to put on my socks in the corner to make sure that the devil wasn't coming for I
  249. I couldn't I slept on the floor at the foot of my mother's bed for two weeks. Stunning voice. No. 13-year-old Max Vonida, Linda Blair's cinematic
  250. peak, obviously. Ellen Buren, a hugely underrated actress. I love her. Um, anyways,
  251. a 13-year-old should not see The Exorcist. No, the movies had it right. There's certain
  252. content and I believe technologies that young people should not be exposed to as
  253. their brain is wired. And one of those things we've decided is pornography. and Sam Alman saying we shouldn't be the
  254. morality police. No, no, actually you should. You should have standards. And that is no one under the age of 18
  255. should in any way be allowed to engage with a synthetic relationship. And two, you need to agegate pornography.
  256. Yeah, everybody else does this. Why are you different? And because you can do it
  257. better or because there's more money involved? Do it better. And it's harder because it's so pernit. It's not like a movie
  258. theater. You have to, like you said, you physically went to Westwood, went into the movie, and listen, every parent has
  259. an example of this. Like my movie that I shouldn't have seen was Tales from the Crypt, right? I shouldn't have snuck
  260. into that movie, and I did. And and uh and like one and for Alex, he snuck around the corner while Louis and I were watching Ted. And I that that wasn't quite that, but it was just dirty. And I
  261. wish he had been older, and I wish I'd been a better parent in that regard. And with Louie going to sausage party with
  262. him, mistake, right? But yeah. Oh man, I didn't think the food was gonna have sex. But anyway, it was he literally in the middle right as I started to do that, I have to say, Louie
  263. turned to me and said, "Good parenting." And I go, I want to kill myself. It's like so bad. And we were like, should we
  264. leave? And he goes, no, let's just sit here quietly, not look. Anyway, well, you know, you know that there
  265. actually there's a sequel coming out to The Exorcist, but it's it's a different twist. This time it's the devil trying
  266. to get the priest out of the child. That's good. That isn't good. So, tell me what you
  267. think with what's going to briefly um uh uh what do you think's going to happen?
  268. I know what's going to happen. Uh, Governor Nuome is trying to thread the needle between being responsible and responding to parents concerns, but at
  269. the same time, he's running for president. And the last [ __ ] thing he wants right now, Yeah. is for the most
  270. successful companies that have been responsible for California surpassing Japan in terms of the size of its
  271. economy, that have spent 70% of the gains in the S&P, which will be a fantastic talking point for him in a
  272. debate. The last thing he can do is piss off these guys enough such that they start moving to Texas. So he's he's caught
  273. between what a leader is supposed to do and that is protect people from a tragedy to the commons but at the same
  274. time acknowledging that the thing that the thing that Governor Nent has going for him right now is the most the people
  275. with the most options in the world the companies with the most options in the world creating the most value all choose to hang out and headquarter in one place
  276. and that's California they do so it is very difficult for him he can't have Sam Alman go because of ownorous
  277. regulation at the hands of our governor or we're considering relocating to, you know, Nashville or Austin. So, he has to
  278. fi walk a very fine line here. But the again, it's a lot of blah blah, a lot of hand movement. It's the illusion of
  279. complexity is being weaponized. Again, no one under the age of 18, there should be age gating. No one under the age of
  280. 16 should be on a social media platform. No one under the age of 18 should be subjected to pornographic content. No
  281. one under the age of 18 should in any way be able to engage in a synthetic relationship. They could figure out all this [ __ ] I think he's on safe ground with that. I think there's so much bipartisan. I
  282. think the the company's gonna have to give up on having everything. You think they could do that? They should do that. They should could and will eventually
  283. have to like I don't think it will go. I think they will not on this one. They don't get what they want. And I think news that bill he vetoed was far too broad. I I when I saw it, I was like,
  284. "No, this is going to they just I was like, can't you just stop at what we actually need? like we don't need to
  285. protect everybody, we need to protect kids. Like that's what drove me crazy about that bill. I thought he would veto
  286. it. Um and he did. All right, we have to we have to go on though. But we'll see what happens. One more go ahead.
  287. One more footnote just on The Exorcist. I actually still with you. After I saw The Exorcist,
  288. you can hear it coming. You can feel it coming. Okay. But what happened was I was
  289. uh we couldn't, you know, my mom and I didn't have much money and we couldn't pay for our exorcist. So, uh, I got
  290. repossessed. That's good bad credit humor. You know, honestly, we should watch The Ashes together. Oh, god. All right. I can't I I don't watch scary movies. I
  291. can't handle scary movies. I don't either. Oh, though I watched The Accountant too uh uh recently. I liked a lot.
  292. You know, now after watching Wizard of the Oz growing up, whenever I climax, I scream, "Surrender, Dorothy. Oh my god.
  293. Surrender." I feel so bad for your wife. I just want to say that as many times as I can.
  294. Okay, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, Meta caves to Fam Bondi and the DOJ. Another hypocrisy.
  295. Support for Pivot comes from Quint. Now that you've entered the sweatpants season, here's something you need to
  296. know. Quinc's warm, durable, and comfy clothes are here to carry you through the season. Quint has the kind of fall
  297. staples that I actually want to wear on repeat. Think $50 Mongolian cashmere premier denim that fits like a dream and
  298. luxe outwear you wear year after year. These are the pieces that'll turn into your fall uniform. And because Quint
  299. partners directly with top tier factories and cuts out the middleman, they deliver luxury quality pieces at
  300. half the price of similar brands. I've talked about Quint before, but you need to hear from me again because I really
  301. like it. I'm wearing Quint's clothes right now. I'm wearing a sports bra and soft pants that are very comfortable.
  302. They're actually great texture. They wear well, they're comfortable. They wash well. Um, and I I wear them every
  303. day. Find your fall staples at Quint. Go to quint.com/pivot for free shipping on your order and 365day returns. Now
  304. available in Canada, too. That's quinc.com/pivot to get free shipping and 365day returns.
  305. quint.com/pivot. Support for the show comes from Framer. If you run a business, you probably need a website. And if you need a website, you probably want a good one. Now, most
  306. design tools are paywalled, but not Framer. With Framer, you get a fullfeatured professional design
  307. experience completely free. Framer already built the fastest way to publish beautiful productionready websites. And
  308. it's now redefining how we design for the web. With the recent launch of design pages, a free canvas-based design
  309. tool, Framer is more than a site builder. It's a true all-in-one design platform. From social assets to campaign
  310. visuals to vectors and icons, all the way to a live site, Framer is where ideas go live start to finish. Framer
  311. even helps you design more than websites. Create social access, campaign visuals, icons, and even site resources
  312. all in one place. Ready to design, iterate, and publish allin-one tool? Start creating for free at
  313. framer.com/design and use the code pivot for a free month of Framer Pro. That's framer.com/design
  314. and use promo code pivot. framer.com/design promo code pivot. Rules and restrictions
  315. may apply. Scott, we're back. Meta has taken down a Facebook page that was sharing information about ICE agents in Chicago after quote outreach from the Justice Department. As Attorney General Pam
  316. Bondi put it, Meta said the page was quote removed for violating our policies against coordinated harm. This follows
  317. Apple and Google ice remov removing ice tracking apps. As we discussed last week, remember Republicans were slamming
  318. tech companies for bowing to government pressure during the last administration, even taking the case to the Supreme Court. He also, you know, and and
  319. complained about and Mark Zuckerberg has been vocal in the last year about social media censorship going far under uh
  320. going too far under Biden. Let's listen to what he told Joe Rogan back in January. The government is not allowed to censor
  321. this stuff. So it at some level I do think that you know having people in the administration calling up the guys on our team and yelling at them and cursing and threatening repercussions if we
  322. don't take down things that are true is like it's pretty bad. It sounds illegal.
  323. Oh my god, he's such a hypocrite. Like literally, no one cursed and threatened him. And also he's not it's impossible
  324. to threaten him. And secondly, what is Pam nicer about it? It's the same thing and it's the same thing Republicans
  325. complained about and then it's the same thing they're doing. Every accusation is a confession with these people at every
  326. moment of the time. I mean, and and they cave to these Republicans and of course,
  327. you know, possibly cave to the Democrats because they're not yelling quite enough or not nice enough to them. I don't
  328. know. What did you think? This was just gh of course of course I'm sensitive or empathetic to the
  329. notion that if the government I think our tech platform should cooperate with the government and but but at the same time I I find of of all
  330. the ugliness I think I'm the thing that used to bother me the most was just the out of
  331. control corruption around this crypto stuff. Uh I think that has been bested by the fact that we have a secret police
  332. essentially terrorizing uh Americans because it's not only it's not only the the the terror and the trauma these people have to go through. What it says is that America is devoting
  333. its energy to uh fascism which is believing that the enemy is within. And it's just a false flag. It's just it we're not that divided, but we have the
  334. most powerful companies at the behest of the president dividing us. Well, talk about the irony thing that
  335. because you mentioned that the Scott Bessant that they're going to investigate use it to investigate um people. You made a joke at the top, but
  336. it's in this wheelhouse. Correct. It's this is an autotocracy. Reward your Putin has nothing on Trump. Reward your allies. Carve up TikTok. give it to your
  337. your Republican donors. Give somebody a tip that you're about to announce ridiculous tariffs again last Friday on
  338. China. And this person goes out, buys uh several hundred million notionally in in
  339. in puts against the crypto market. And by the way, closes out the trade at $120 million gain later that day. Again,
  340. unless somebody knew that what was coming here, this was the luckiest trade in history. reward your allies and
  341. punish your enemies. And at some point, you and me are going to end up on some list and the IRS is going to come for
  342. us. Yeah. And when the IRS comes for you, even if you've done nothing wrong, if they're
  343. aggressive enough, you're just going to have to pay a lot of money. It's going to send a chill and you're going to
  344. decide, oh, maybe on our podcast we shouldn't speak. We shouldn't be so negative on Trump or whatever.
  345. This is you don't weaponize. Americans pay for these institutions. The IRS is there to make sure that people pay their taxes. By the way, if you want to solve or go a long way to
  346. solving the deficit, you would increase funding to the IRS cuz supposedly about $780 billion a year is called the tax
  347. gap, which means taxes that are owed that go unpaid. Because the Republicans, and this is very deaf, they have said
  348. rather than the the the biggest tax cut in history, is the defunding of the IRS because wealthy people have exceptionally complicated tax returns. And to audit a wealthy person takes
  349. professionals and time and resources, which the IRS no longer has. So the tax rates are just symbolic because very very wealthy people with complicated tax returns can be so aggressive now on
  350. their taxes because they are in fact confident that the IRS doesn't have the resources to come for them. And now he's
  351. saying I'll weaponize it against my enemies, right? And the IRS will such a waste.
  352. I mean it happened at the DOJ. It's going to Why wouldn't it happen at the IRS? It's happened to the DOJ. The FBI should be investigating like the
  353. there's been a lot of stories about how the FBI is like we're not doing real crimes. we're just doing what Trump thinks are crimes or immigration or all
  354. the resources are going to Same thing here with the IRS. Instead of collecting taxes we are lawfully owed, this is what
  355. they're going to spend their time doing because they they're going to know where their bread is buttered. The other part is that these laws against
  356. officials, executive officials, including the president, were passed after Nixon tried to do this. So, he's
  357. trying to break those up and they are very explicit, very um a lot of I'm just going to say Scott Bessant, you better lawyer up if Democratic because what you're doing here is suggesting uh using
  358. the IRS as as a tool of retribution. There are very clear laws that they're going to they may run over them right
  359. now, but they're not going to outrun these things. Um and and so I don't believe they will. And so not just Trump is also liable here for this if if if
  360. Democrats the problem is if Democrats get in power, they're going to spend all their time rounding up the criminals,
  361. right? And what what how does that help our country in any way? And at some point they'll have to let some of these
  362. I do think there needs I don't know. I do think there needs to be something along the lines of like a
  363. Nuremberg trial. There needs to be I think the only way we move past this is with some sort of reckoning. And I
  364. actually believe the Democrats should be outlining the specific laws, the specific hearings, the specific
  365. subpoenas that they are going to pursue because to just sort of say, well, it's time to move on
  366. and come together, there needs to be moral clarity around what's going on here because just the DOJ being
  367. weaponized is the most serious of all of it. But in terms of IRS, what that means is a tax increase for lower middle-
  368. inome homes and all Democrats. Because if you're a famous Republican donor, you're telling your tax people right now, just go so far, so aggressive.
  369. Don't pay this. Claim claim a $200 million deduction on your plane even though it cost 60
  370. million. Well, that's not true. Does just go for it. And by the way, I don't think I'll
  371. be audited. Now, what does that mean? the government has to collect at least5 trillion dollars a year to just fund
  372. their current commitments, they're going to have to get that money from somewhere. So, if really wealthy people or people in the president's dead, which
  373. happen to be billionaire Republicans who are paying a disproportionate I mean, they're a key part of the tax code.
  374. There's this notion that the rich don't pay taxes. No, the rich the top probably the top 10% pay about 80% of federal
  375. taxes. Are they as a percentage of their wealth paying their fair share? I think that's up for real debate. But in terms
  376. of a gross dollar amount, because they make so much more money than anyone, they're a huge part of the tax base. And
  377. if you decide to start letting them off the hook, you're going to have to get other people to pay disproportionately
  378. more. So him weaponizing the IRS is not only unjust, it's effectively a tax increase for non-democratic billionaires and it's a tax decrease for for
  379. Republican billionaires. Right. And people just don't connect the dots here. Yeah. No, I you know, you know what dot
  380. you connected? the ideas around. Um, he wouldn't be able to do what he's doing without the AI boom. I thought that was
  381. really smart. I was like, Amanda even said, she goes, I hadn't thought of that. Sometimes Scott comes out with the most obvious connections. That's the
  382. same. Pure probability and luck at some point. I'm just saying it's a similar connection. It's like that's what's happening here. But let me tell you, you
  383. know, it's it's going to come back to bite you. I really feel it will and probably should. Um, speaking of someone
  384. that needs to be bitten, Salesforce CEO Mark Beni off appears to be sort of walking back his recent comments in New
  385. York Times where he called for President Trump to send National Guard troops to San Francisco. Benoff tried to clarify
  386. his remarks in a post on X, saying, "Safety is quote, first and foremost the responsibility of our city and state
  387. leaders." He also pointed out correctly that crime in San Francisco is down 30%. Still he told the times that if the city
  388. needs to refund the police even though San Francisco never actually defunded its police force and it has been doing
  389. that. Um I got to say uh you know e I have a lot to say about this. There was a thing I sent you from Gary Tan who
  390. irritates me on the on the regular but he said the same thing. This is it's all moving in the right direction. There's
  391. all kinds of great statistics of what's happening in San Francisco. And for Mark to weigh in like this uh and then saying
  392. we have to be nice to him because he gives a lot of money away. Like you give the money away and shut up, Mark. I'm sorry. If you want to be charitable like
  393. McKenzie Bezos, keep your mouth shut about it. You don't need to be thanked and you don't get a pass over saying
  394. something like this to bring in police, the National Guard to San Francisco. He never is there. I And I know a little
  395. bit about what happened in here is he probably he went some he was in downtown San Francisco for 2 seconds, was in a
  396. bad part of it, saw some homeless, and then compared it to Washington. He was in a very nice part of Washington and
  397. it's like see what happens when the National Guard comes in. But what he doesn't know is Washington was like that before he got there and he was in a bad
  398. part of San Francisco. There's no question San Francisco had a real downturn. But it is on the upturn from
  399. the work for people like London Breed and now Daniel Lur um who's the mayor. They're trying really hard and for San
  400. Francisco's biggest booster to do a heel turn like this because he wants to be part of the Trump crime family. I I just
  401. And by the way, all of those tech bros who are with Trump make fun of him relentlessly, which is he should know
  402. this. Um, and I know he needs to make money and he wants to get in on the gimmies and he wants to be at those
  403. dinners, but Mark, this is I couldn't it's it's not really shocking, but it's also gross is what it is. I don't know what else to say. You may have a
  404. different opinion, but I don't think you this person who's been one of San Francisco's biggest border, this should
  405. be the thing he said. And the last thing from what I understand is he did a more problematic interview with another
  406. group. Um, and he also attacked Mike Morates, the San Francisco standard, which I think is doing a great job in
  407. San Francisco reporting. Um, and and Mike Morates is another venture capitalist who owns who has created that
  408. publication, which is an as I said, an excellent publication. But, um, you know, I think that he had a difficult
  409. interview with them and then he turned to the New York Times and even his apparently his PR person was like jaw-dropping that he did this. I I like
  410. Mark. I I I was sh I was s I wasn't surprised by it, but it's really incredibly unhelpful and for you to act like a victim and then demand feelalty because you give money away. I'd rather
  411. you not give the money away and keep your mouth shut. I don't know what else to say. What do you think?
  412. I think you have more I mean, you know Mark better than me and you know San Francisco better than me. Um, but the
  413. way I see it is simply put, I think Mark's a good guy who's very civic-minded. I think he gives money
  414. away because he's genuinely a philanthropic person and recognizes his blessings. And he said something really [ __ ]
  415. stupid. I mean, and if I were advising him, and I'm not. And actually, I you know, I may text him. Just say, "I said something stupid. I apologize." and maybe add a little context because I
  416. don't think it's I I think it's it's a shame because I do think Mark has made a real effort
  417. to acknowledge his blessings and be really civic-minded. I've heard a lot of people say that when they can't find
  418. resources anywhere, they call Mark and Mark is an automatic yes and he goes out of his way. I I just I I just think he's a good man. He said something stupid
  419. here that is not accurate. And when you get that rich, you can get into a bubble and maybe had a bad experience in San
  420. Francisco. There are a lot of areas, my understanding is in San Francisco that feel like a war zone. Well, the Tenderloin has been bad for
  421. decades. But go ahead. Go ahead. You know this you you you're going to forget more about the city than I'm I'm
  422. ever going to go. In 1999, I I left the board of my company, got divorced, and said to my wife, ex-wife,
  423. you can have our friends. I never want to come back here again. Um, probably more information than people wanted.
  424. Uh, and I can't stand San Francisco is my least favorite city. I just I've just never I've never really enjoyed it.
  425. Anyway, but but he probably had a bad experience. He's probably trying to pose a little bit for the Trump lights and get in on some of that AI sweet, you know, whatever it might be. But it
  426. uh the first thing I thought when I saw it was I thought it was sad because I do think Mark has spent a lot of time
  427. trying to be the good billionaire. I know. And I think a lot of it is genuine. I don't think it's I don't think it's
  428. doing it to try and to try and get business or deflect or be righteous or tell nonprofits how to behave. I genuinely believe he is one of the good guys. And I hated to see this because
  429. the reality is when you get it's very easy to enter in your own bubble and and say stupid things and he could fix this.
  430. Very simple. It's interesting that he won't stupid. I apologize. He has changed a little bit. I have to say I think one of the things I did a
  431. really famous interview where he said he compared Facebook to cigarette companies, right? And he was, you know,
  432. and he was one of the few when when they had that Trump Tower thing, he's he was like, "Can you believe this shit?" um
  433. when when all the tech billionaires went and now I think he's seen um you know they're all sort of pigs at the trough and he's decided to oink. I just don't know what else it is like and that's so
  434. and maybe he's had a change of heart and he's become more conservative. I don't know but you can't do ohana and then say
  435. let's bring in the troops when San Francisco's trying really hard to fix itself and is on the upswing. It's such
  436. and it's getting better, right? Yes, you said it's so ill. It's noticeably better. And if Gary Tan is who's the biggest
  437. complainer about San Francisco, there's a whole sort of rightish group and I wouldn't say right because it's San
  438. Francisco, but they are pretty conservative. Um, you know, is applauding the efforts. And by the way,
  439. everyone's moving back. Mark, just so you know, Elon's back in California. You know, the whole gang of them that
  440. complained is all locating in in San Francisco or California. I just I I it's like so it I thought he went out on a real limb when he could compare and he was the earliest person and almost like
  441. a class trader, right? Saying Facebook was like cigarette companies. He was right and he took the [ __ ] for that.
  442. He was early and it wasn't he wasn't um virtue signaling because it wasn't a good thing
  443. to say. It didn't work out well for him to do that. But this was I just think he wanted
  444. attention. The other thing that drove me crazy from that interview, and I was was shocked by it. He owns Time magazine for
  445. people who don't know. And by the way, that photo of Trump looks like he has a vagina on his neck, but that's neither here nor there. Um, is that he said, "I
  446. haven't really been reading the news lately about the ICE stuff." And like he he owns a major I don't think it's as
  447. big as it used to be, but he owns a major news publication pretending like, "Well, I don't really know about the
  448. other things. That stuff, give me a [ __ ] break. you're a brilliant guy. Stop it. Like, you know what? You've
  449. decided it's okay or you're going to ignore it. But to say, I really wasn't paying attention. What is there other
  450. things happening here like the IRS or the ICE stuff or anything else? And I I don't It's sort of like I don't know. It
  451. just was just I think he's done a great job with time. Um at least it's better. Yeah. Or it survived. It wouldn't have survived. It's economically unviable unless you have a I mean like most
  452. unfortunate media companies unless it's owned by a benign billionaire it goes away or it becomes all about cost
  453. cutting or sensationalism to try and get clicks. I don't mind go away. I have to tell you
  454. on some things I think let him go. Yeah, let him die. I think he's done a perfectly good job. But uh I have to say at various points
  455. he said you should come work for me. Honestly, Mark, I'm glad I didn't at this point. This isn't Please say what
  456. Scott said. say you're sorry and you know stop acting like a victim and I know you want that sweet AI money but
  457. honestly ohana man ohana you know he says that all the time all this ohana well this isn't ohana just so you know all right Scott let's go on a quick break we come back we'll talk about news
  458. outlets pushing back on the defense department's idiotic new regulations support for the show comes from Built Rewards nobody wants to pay rent but if you have to Built makes it worth It
  459. built is revolutionizing how millions think about paying rent by rewarding their members with points and exclusive benefits around their neighborhood every
  460. single month by paying rent through Built. They say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed towards hundreds of hotels and airlines, a
  461. future rent payment, your next lift ride, and more. But your home isn't just where you sleep. It's your community.
  462. And Built wants to make your entire neighborhood more rewarding. So with Built, you can dine out at your favorite
  463. local restaurants and earn additional points. Get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios and enjoy exclusive experiences just for built members every
  464. month. And when you're ready to travel, they say built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the
  465. world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by going to
  466. joinbuilt.com/pivot. That's jbt.com/pivot. Make sure to use our URL so they know we sent you.
  467. Scott, we're back with more news. News organizations, including Fox News, have declined to sign the Defense Department's new press policy,
  468. denouncing the regulations in a joint statement. The policy prohibits journalists from gaining information the defense department doesn't make
  469. available for them. It also revokes Pentagon press credentials for those who don't agree. By sign by the signing
  470. deadline, only O one America News had agreed to the policy. Uh they're kind of a organ of the Trump administration, so that makes sense. Um, you know, I mean,
  471. Pete Hegsth was trying to say, well, it's like the way the White House is, but I I don't think this is the worst
  472. thing for these reporters. They walked out. They can get they can find these other people. They don't have to wander around. It's it's a it's easier if
  473. you're wandering around the Pentagon, I guess. But, uh, I think these outlets did the right thing by just saying, "No,
  474. we're not signing this thing." And I think this is really Pete Headst is usually has mangled and bungled this
  475. entire thing. What are your thoughts? I thought it was a nice moment for the press. They all came together and they
  476. said, "We're not going to put up with this." And um it I think that Secretary Hexat does not have the confidence or management skills or ability to read the room or the judgment to oversee the most
  477. lethal successful organization in history. Uh and this is just another example of this. This didn't need to
  478. happen. He he's he's created more drama. He's handled this poorly in an effort to
  479. control the press. He's created a bunch of bad press for the Pentagon and the administration. This is, you know, this
  480. is it's blown up in his face. He's his inability to his belief that he could muscle around journalists backfired. And again, the whole point of
  481. this was to create a sanitized stream of information out of the Pentagon that would only be complimentary or frame it in a certain way. And if it wasn't if it
  482. wasn't for journalists, I mean, we'd probably still be in Vietnam. I mean, it's just the the the
  483. typically the Secretary of Defense comes from a civilian background because they've decided that generals have a
  484. habit, and not all generals, but generals have a habit of looking for military solutions. And what you need is
  485. a a secretary of defense that understands the private sector and also is quite frankly just more rooted in a
  486. civilian mindset or a geopolitical mindset. And instead we hired a major who was a TV host to head the secretary, you know, to become the new secretary of war. And this individual just doesn't
  487. have good judgment. So in an attempt to sanitize, politicize, and create a stream of pre-approved press, they've made it worse. They've created a stream of really negative press saying this is
  488. yet another example of an authoritarian government trying to control the narrative here. And it it kudos to
  489. everyone NBC, ABC, CBS, CNN, and Fox all issued a joint statement declining to agree to the new policy. Weird. Why this? He's also uh lie testing all the employees, too. He's
  490. such a parent. Like, guy, get get off your whatever substances you're using cuz it's making you freaky, you know? I
  491. don't know. I mean, fortunately, this this authoritarian move was handled so like Trump issuing a cryptocoin that increases his net worth by $5 billion
  492. the Friday night before inauguration was kind of genius. They the timing here was
  493. so elegant. You know, I've always said this. It's like it's like we're this is a mafia family, but unfortunately
  494. unfortunately you have Michael running the corruption and you have Fredo running the government. Hexath is Fredo. Yeah, he's the person running his crypto scams, the
  495. person running his tour around the Middle East to get to get buildings and golf courses and 747s.
  496. Who is Sunny? Sorry. Oh, that's a really interesting statement. Just I love James Khan.
  497. Yeah. Um, who's Sunny? I love Brian Piccolo. And who is Sunny? Let's think. Who's like
  498. the big who says idiotic? Bessid thinks he's Sunny, but he's not. Remember, I'm going
  499. to beat everyone up. Can I just say I just he seems like and I'm going to bring back a word from our youth. He's such a dork. Like, he's such a dork. Um,
  500. the other thing is, um, let me just say a word very quickly and then we do about access journalism. I was asked by I was
  501. on Katie Drummond's podcast from Wired. I think she's doing an astonishing job at Wired really reinvigorating that
  502. brand. Um, and she asked about access and do I regret and I have to say I really think that I you get better stories not having
  503. access actually if you if you do really good reporting and you know being at the Wall Street Journal and a little bit at
  504. the Times and the Washington Post, they always bring it to you first, right? and then you sort of agree to release it as
  505. if you got a scoop, but it isn't cuz they hand they hand delivered it to you. Um, I have to say I got a lot better
  506. after I just said [ __ ] access. Like I don't care if they talk to me or not. And I I would say I did too much of that
  507. trading and every reporter does too much of that access stuff. Like I'll give you this if you give me this. And I'm so
  508. happy that they don't want to talk to me now because I can do whatever I want and I still find out more stuff because one
  509. of the things that Hegs doesn't understand is reporting has moved on and there are so many sources. And in the
  510. old days you'd have to either meet someone or get a phone call which was real traceable, right? And so it was
  511. really hard. Now there's so many ways to get to sources and so many ways for them to get to you and to publish on their
  512. own. It's a whole different game. So, as usual, Hegath who is living in the 80s with the way he dresses and does the,
  513. you know, party on G um is is really um way behind in understanding how now they
  514. will double down on finding [ __ ] about him about and and reporting because it's all there. It's not they're not going to
  515. make it up, but he's even people who work for him are like this one spokesperson who had a falling out with
  516. him is like what a [ __ ] idiot. He doesn't understand the modern media age. That's my That's my access thing. No
  517. access is Yeah. I think though, but I think you I I empathize with journalists who are
  518. trying to I mean it you guys have to walk a a fine line and that is you want to get good interviews and people aren't going to come on your show if they think they're just going to be ambushed.
  519. Yeah. So I I understand the temptation for access journalism. You're at a point where quite frankly you no longer need
  520. to engage in access journalism. So you have the luxury of I think people listen to you when you
  521. speak. You have a big platform. People are a little bit scared of you. People see you as tough but fair.
  522. But I can understand playing into the notion of accent. I do a little I mean I get it. You're an up and
  523. cominging journalist. You don't want to be you don't want everyone to go, "No, I'm not going on her show. She's she's not, you know, not not nice or trying to
  524. make Especially TV ones, by the way. They have a harder time because they need the physical person, right? So
  525. yeah, it's hard. It's hard. Access journalism is incredibly hard and it probably
  526. should go away. Anyway, um uh one more quick break, Scott, and we'll be back for predictions. Support for the show comes from Mint Mobile. If you're still overpaying for
  527. your wireless, it's time to start becoming more comfortable with saying no. Because at Mint Mobile, their favorite word is no. They mean no owner
  528. contracts, no monthly bills, no overages, no hidden fees, no BS. So when they say no, they really mean it.
  529. MinMobile is letting you ditch overpriced wireless with plans starting at just $15 a month. All plans come with
  530. high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network without the jaw-dropping
  531. monthly bills or unexpected overages. Plus, you can use your own phone with any Minmobile plan and bring your phone
  532. number along with all your existing contacts. Ready to say yes to saying no? Make the switch at mintmobile.com/pivot. That's mintmobile.com/pivot. Upfront payment of $45 required,
  533. equivalent to $15 per month. Limited time new customer offer for first three months only. Speeds may slow above 35
  534. gigabytes on unlimited plan. Taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. Okay, Scott. Uh, we're here for predictions, but I can I just make a brief one? Kim Kardashian just launched
  535. an interesting new product for scams. A thong adorned with fake pubic hair. It's already selling out. I predict Scott
  536. Galloway probably bought 10 or 12 of them. This this song, what what is this fake business?
  537. The Skims business is huge. FYI, Kim Kardashian is a great entrepreneur. She works with great entrepreneurs. Skiims
  538. is this under because it's underwear, I guess, and a bunch of other stuff. But the thong is adorned with fake pubic
  539. hair. Um uh I I just feel like I wish I could get one for you. That's all I have
  540. to say. Yeah. No, I'm not I'm not grabbing that one. Um your prediction please. Uh so my prediction is that you're about
  541. to see the greatest. So reality TV was huge. Um kind of probably the biggest trend in TV through the through the odds. I don't know what was bigger than that. Original scripted comedies. I don't know. Uh the biggest trend in
  542. television over the next uh streaming media and broadcast television over the next two
  543. years is going to be podcast repurposed as TV shows. Oh, I know where you're going.
  544. And if you look at recently Netflix's deal with um Spotify and podcasts, they've basically said, "Okay, I mean, how did Netflix win the world?" Explain the deal for people who don't
  545. know. So yeah, Spotify and Netflix are partnering to bring podcasts to Netflix. The
  546. partnership will bring video versions of 16 different Spotify exclusive podcast to Netflix. And this is essentially a
  547. shift following Spotify's large investment in the podcast space. They spent billions uh for purchasing studios
  548. like Parkcast, the Ringer and Gimup Media and signing exclusive deals with people ranging from Joe Rogan to Alex
  549. Cooper. And many of these didn't pan out to be profitable. And Spotify learned that the real value of podcasts isn't just in audio, it's in video. And they're not strong in video. And YouTube is what this really I mean, so YouTube
  550. revealed that over a billion people every month watch and listen to podcasts on YouTube. I think about 18% of our
  551. listens and 25% of PropG listens are on a TV and it's people streaming it off of YouTube. YouTube is the biggest
  552. distribution platform for podcast. Netflix has correctly identified that their competition is not Disney Plus or
  553. Hulu. They've beaten them or Paramount Plus. That that just doesn't matter. Their competition is YouTube. It
  554. commands about 11 or 12% of video listenership. And Netflix is at 8. And YouTube is big, really big. And podcasting, it's kind of the biggest,
  555. it's the biggest distribution platform for what we're doing now. In addition, Netflix, their strategy and how they won
  556. is through an arbitrage. In this instance, it was a geographic arbitrage where they said, "We're not going to produce stuff. We're going to spend more
  557. money than anyone else, but for spending X, we're going to get 1.2x cuz we're going to produce Squid Games in Soul
  558. Korea and we're going to present, you know, produce money heist in Madrid." The next arbitrage that you're going to
  559. see is effectively podcasts are television with a lower cost means of production. And that is I think this amazing special effects going on here, but go ahead.
  560. Well, if you look at what's happened and the guy that sort of pioneered this for me, the first thing I did when I arrived
  561. in London, literally when I moved here three and a half years ago, is I got off the plane and I went to Shorttoritch and I was on this podcast that was supposed
  562. to be this up and cominging kid named Steven Bartlett, who I think is the next Joe Rogan, and he's this super
  563. attractive, really great inter interviewer, 31, 32. And I walked into his podcast studio and there were 12 people in like a six camera shoot. He said, "This is TV. This is and he gets
  564. millions of views on and Chris Williams has a good TV game. Basically the people turnurning in and out of podcasts is
  565. primarily the fulcrum of that churn right now is your video game. And now what is the problem with streaming media
  566. and what is the problem with cable news? Um their audiences on cable news are declining and streaming media it's a capital war. So all roads lead to the same place and that is they need a way
  567. to create content for a lower cost. And effectively what you have with podcasts, the best podcasts can create 22 20, you
  568. know, 21 minutes or 42 minutes of content for a 30 or 60 minute slot on TV, but they can produce it for 10 to
  569. 15% of the cost of the hair, the makeup, the unions, the theater. I mean, it's just the I did the analysis here. Comcast gets somewhere between two and $300,000 in revenue per employee. pivot
  570. right now this year will get easily over a million dollars per employee because our means of production are so much less expensive that things are so much more profitable. Well, applying our own makeup and having
  571. a shitty background is really good business is what now you have a good you always have a good background. Can I ask
  572. you a specific question? What I thought was interesting is all these ideas of Netflix moving in and I know you talked
  573. to them for a second um moving into podcasting. This isn't really moving into it. It's taking it two things. is
  574. taking advantage of the current environment and and playing into your strength which is distribution one and
  575. two they're requiring people not to be on YouTube which is a big shift. So obviously they're declaring that YouTube
  576. their enemy their only enemy but um that's exactly right because I bet if we did that something
  577. like that they wouldn't require us not to go on CNN or not they don't care right so so talk about if that's a good trade
  578. for people not to go on YouTube because to me YouTube is television and this is sort of early territory and then the
  579. idea that um they're just dipping they're not really going to produce podcasts the way they produce I don't
  580. know um K-pop demon hunters or whatever it happens to be. They will soon they're going to learn
  581. they they haveund they control other than the Google query box. It's probably the most valuable real estate in the world is that home screen on Netflix. 150 million people will watch what they
  582. put on that home screen. So within 24 months they're dipping their toe. They're going to learn about it. I bet
  583. within 24 to 36 months Netflix has three of the 10 biggest podcasts in the world and they'll be owned and operated by
  584. Netflix and event you're exactly right. Netflix has said, "Our competitor here is YouTube, so we'll partner with
  585. Spotify, but you can't be on YouTube." But this is what's going to happen on with Cara Swisser. Some really talented
  586. person at CNN will take the two or three hours of content you have every week, take the best 41 minutes and run it on
  587. on an hour on CNN where quite frankly they don't know what to do with that hour. And by the way, it's absolutely
  588. it's it's negligible incremental cost to you, negligible incremental cost to them, and you split the revenue.
  589. Yeah. So, you're going to see you're going to see that the of the 50 biggest podcasts within 12 months.
  590. Yeah. 12 to 20 of them will be playing on TV because what is the problem with cable
  591. news? Doesn't have a good It is a revenue problem, but the bigger problem is the expense side
  592. and the content. It's the same cont. It's not different. It doesn't. It's like the same airless studio.
  593. It's not that interesting and it's really [ __ ] expensive. When I haul my ass up to Yeah. Beyond Stephanie Rules show and we love
  594. her. You look at the the the She does a great job, but the cost of that show, the unions, the makeup, the sound guy,
  595. the security staff, the the build I mean it just the means of production are so goddamn expensive.
  596. Whereas if they say, "Okay, we're going to take 41 minutes of on and we're going to run it after Fared on Sunday or
  597. whatever." And by the way, yeah, even if it even if we only make half as much revenue, we're it's going to be a
  598. lot more profitable. You know what? I haven't gotten that call. They're already producing it.
  599. I have not. Oh, you will. You watch. Anyways, my prediction, by the way, I'm not working for the but that's another
  600. issue. But go ahead. But podcasts are effectively becoming TV shows with a strong audio overlay and
  601. more importantly a lower means of cost of production. Netflix is dipping their toe in. They're going to realize that
  602. the next arbitrage is to take content, repurpose it at a very low incremental cost, and put it on their distribution platform. And everyone else is going to start doing this. You're going to see
  603. MSNBC take the best political podcasts, carve them up, more graphics, a little bit better hair and makeup, a little bit better production quality, and they're going to think, "Okay, for an hour of reasonably good content, it costs us
  604. another 10 or 20 grand, not another 150 grand. We don't need to sell to make as much money here. When they call, you let me know. So anyways, will you let me know when the prediction is of the top 100
  605. podcasts, 12 to 15 of them are going to be playing on cable news and on streaming media within the next 12 to
  606. four months. Hey guys, of cable media, let's do it. Um, I went to the MSNBC live event. I
  607. thought it was quite good. It was quite It was well done. I heard it was great. It was great and it was funny. They they're I gave I the person who runs it,
  608. Rebecca Cutler, who I have a lot of um respect for. She's great and is a big listener of Pivot. Um I sent her some
  609. thoughts of it. I I went to support Stephanie Rachel and Saki Jen Saki and um I thought it was good. It had really
  610. it was a it was a good directional move for them and it was fun and it probably didn't cost them that much and they did
  611. a super fan dinner. I thought it was really smart. It was super It was a marketing event but you know they we let
  612. me tell you there's a lot of crossover fans of MSNBC and Pivot. I took a lot of selfies. Um but um I went with George
  613. Han and it was we had a good time. It was really it was well done. You could see how it could go in even better directions at a much lower cost. Anyway,
  614. we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever is on your mind. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for
  615. the show or call 8551 pivot. Elsewhere in the Karen Scott universe, as you know, Scott Andreed Kla Harris for On
  616. with Cara Swisser. Uh let's listen to a clip. Have you yourself felt uh with Leticia James being targeted, there's
  617. many others. Have you felt that you could be targeted, worried about being indicted? Sure. Of course.
  618. For the people that are watching this on radio. Yeah. See what I just did there? Of course, I just I raised my hand. Okay. Can we just talk about that for a
  619. moment? And this is I think Vice President Harris will make an outstanding Supreme Court justice. I thought her debate performance was one of the great
  620. performances in political history. I voted for I give money to her campaign. That answer embodies why she should not run for president and why she is not president. She had an opportunity there
  621. that was a layup to talk about a move towards authoritarianism, how dangerous the chill is, how she is
  622. committed to being a leader and speaking up despite the risk to her professional career. Instead, she just said, "Of
  623. course." Yeah, that perfectly embodied why she does not capture the imagination or the passion
  624. required to be the president of the United States. Let me be fair. She did talk about it a lot during the interview, right? So
  625. maybe, did she? Yeah, she did. And the second part is she really did predict. She did say all this stuff that was
  626. going to happen step by step and she was astonishingly accurate um and precient uh because she understood it as a
  627. prosecutor what these people do which these you know mobster turn autocrats do. Um I would you know it's interesting I
  628. got a lot of feedback from Republicanleaning people like who liked it like I really liked it because there was a positive negatives and most all of them agreed that her campaign was excellent for most of it not all of it.
  629. Um but uh but I she was a little salty I have to say and I did think it really compared to um Buddha Judge who had a very different vibe right um so it'll be
  630. I'm going to be interesting all of these people as you have done a number of them um and so I'm going to be interested to
  631. see compare and contrast all of them but you're right that was an opportunity but I think she didn't want to get to be
  632. righteous lady I think she didn't want to go full righteous lady there but uh uh and wanted to seem brave I guess
  633. Do you get the sense? I mean, you you know her and she likes you and you like Well, I don't know if you
  634. like her. You're I think you're I think you're supportive and kind to her. Um do you think she's she's Do you think
  635. she wants to run? I couldn't tell from the thing. I thought I would know. Um it it maybe I I
  636. she probably will. She has the highest name recognition. Let's be clear. She Everyone knows who she is and the others they don't know as well, right? That's
  637. just the way things are. So, so she and Newsome are the best known people, but watching Newsome trot right by her in
  638. the numbers cuz he's trotten and so is Buddha Judge. I I don't part of me feels like she I don't know her that well
  639. enough to say, but I felt like I don't know if she really wants it, right? Does that make sense? Like she certainly I don't know. I think the I think she
  640. ran a great campaign and she was hindered a lot by the Biden stuff and what she couldn't do. And I know you said she should have said something, but
  641. boy would have that have been a move by someone who's already cautious. But um I don't know. I couldn't I don't
  642. afterwards I didn't I couldn't say. I couldn't say. But you're right. She'd be a great Supreme Court justice also. But
  643. we'll see if we get the chance to put her in course. Um I I I think maybe she isn't going to run. But I'm going to
  644. make a prediction. I don't know. She'll be mad if I But I got the sense that maybe she's still on the fence about it
  645. and that's it. Anyway, we'll see. I I'm I I don't know. I don't know. Anyway, speaking of people who are running, I
  646. had Rahm Emanuel on our He's funny on Raging Moderates. He's actually very good.
  647. He's very good. He's very smart. Very enthusiastic. Very smart. He's doing the work. He's writing opeds. He's going on all the podcasts. He's
  648. No, he's Yeah, he's very smart. Very practical. Yeah. He has a lot of non-fans in Chicago, though. And even he knows this.
  649. But speaking of which, we're going on tour. We're going to be going to Toronto. Sold out. New York. Almost sold
  650. out. DC. I think it's very close to being sold out. Chicago is lagging a little bit. Although we've sold a lot of tickets when we're in a very big theater
  651. compared to the others, but Chicago, let's [ __ ] keep up. Come on, Chicago. Um, it's an extra large venue for you
  652. guys cuz you're, you know, you're the city of big shoulders. Anyway, uh, come see us there and please stay away from
  653. scalpers and third party sellers. We don't want people to take advantage of you just to come and see us. Um, I'm getting a lot of inquiries from people
  654. who want to go to the soldout cities and I'm unable to help. We're not getting very many cops. They're like, "No, you
  655. can have two or something like that." Um, anyway, we're very excited. Are you excited for our tour?
  656. Yeah, I am. Seven cities in seven. And your book is, let me just say, let me give a plug. Your book is coming out
  657. that week, too. So, let's get it on the top of the New York Times bestseller lists. Okay. The number one. Let's give
  658. it number one. I appreciate that. We want to make that. It's a big important topic and everyone is interested in it. Republicans,
  659. Democrats, TBA, whatever you happen to be. Um, I'm going to get a copy each for both of my
  660. sons and uh and Saul would have one, but he doesn't read. Um, okay. That's Speaking of Chicago, I mean, just real quick, speaking of Chicago, my wife likes to talk on the phone during sex
  661. and last night she called me from Chicago. Uh, that's pretty good. Does that work? What do you mean? See, now I'm thinking about the mechanics of that.
  662. That's bad on a lot of levels. Put me in the Republican young Republican chat. I'm ready.
  663. Anyway, there you go. That's the show. Thanks for listening to Pivot and be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel. We'll be back
  664. next week. Scott, read us out. Today's show was produced by Larara Neon, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin.
  665. Erdand Tat engineered this episode. Jim M edited the video. Thanks also to Drew Burroughs, Madera, and Dan Shalon.
  666. Micho, Vox Media's executive producer podcast. Make sure to follow Pivot on your favorite podcast platform. Thank
  667. you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine nymag.com/pod.
  668. We'll be back later in the week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.

Brief Summary

The episode discusses leaked texts from young Republicans, OpenAI's erotica policy, and the future of podcasts in media.

Key points

  • Narcissism and Self-Image. Scott shares his struggles with self-image and aging, humorously reflecting on beauty standards.
  • Young Republicans' Controversial Texts. Leaked texts reveal shocking racist and sexist jokes among young Republican leaders, prompting outrage.
  • OpenAI's New Erotica Access. OpenAI plans to allow verified young adults to access erotica, stirring debate on morality.
  • The Dangers of Synthetic Relationships. Synthetic relationships may seem appealing, but they can lead to harmful consequences for young people.
  • Age Restrictions on Technology. There should be strict age restrictions on synthetic relationships and pornography to protect youth.
  • Weaponizing the IRS. The discussion centers around the implications of using the IRS as a political tool.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes