Pollster: Trump's Approval Ratings At "Five-Alarm Fire" Level | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara is joined by Echelon Insights pollster Kristen Soltis Anderson to unpack Trump’s expletive-filled Iran ultimatum, and what his latest numbers say about the MAGA base and the midterms. Then, they dig into who might be on the chopping block amid a potential cabinet shake-up. Plus, OpenAI’s podcast deal, the battle over prediction market regulation, and how “Silicon Sampling” could reshape the polling game.

00:00 Intro 01:31 Trump’s Iran Ultimatums 8:50 Trump’s Approval Ratings 22:24 Cabinet Shake-up? 29:04 Prediction Markets vs. Polls 46:23 OpenAI Acquires Tech Podcast 56:19 Grok Subscription Mandate 1:00:17 Wins and Fails

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin

Video Producer: Rich Shibley

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. His brand is firing. His brand is getting rid of incompetence. And now he has he keeps them. And you're like, "Oh
  2. my god, you're keeping the incompetence." Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York
  3. Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisser. Scott is off, so I brought in a brilliant co-host
  4. again, as are everyone who's not Scott. uh Kristen Sulttus Anderson, pollster and co-founder of Echelon Insights and
  5. contributing opinion writer for the New York Times and someone I really like a lot who's super smart. Nice to see you.
  6. >> Well, thanks for having me, Cara. >> Yeah. So, um welcome. What's going on? What's going on? The world of polling is
  7. insane right now. Correct. >> It's it is as insane as it can be considering that there is not an
  8. election that is imminent. uh you know like the world gets polling world gets crazy in the immediate leadup to an
  9. election because somebody's got a new survey coming out every day in some interesting swing state when it is
  10. election season but right now it's a little bit of the doldrums for that and so what is instead kind of crazy is all
  11. of the changes around how is AI going to change our industry and those sorts of things.
  12. >> We're going to get to that. We're going to talk about the predictions industry.
  13. We're going to play a little bit of Scott who loves it. I don't love it quite so much and I know you hasn't
  14. thought. So, it's really important to be talking about it because what we're interested in is accurate information
  15. and it's very hard to get it. Anyway, uh there's so much going on. Let's get right to the news because you've been
  16. doing tons of stuff in the times and elsewhere and we've talked a little bit about but we of course have to start
  17. with Donald Trump has once again issued an ultimatum to Iran. I think it's the 27th one posting on True Social on
  18. Easter Sunday. Quote, and let me just read this correctly. Open the [ __ ] straight you crazy bastards or you'll be
  19. living in hell. which sounds like a line from I don't even think movies would write those lines anymore. Um, if Iran
  20. doesn't comply, Trump is threatening to target the country's power plants and bridges. Iran says it will retaliate
  21. crushingly and extensively if civilian infrastructure targets are hit. So, they're just coming back with the same
  22. dialogue. This all comes after a successful rescue of two US airmen whose jet was shot down uh over Iran on
  23. Friday. It's not great, but the jets were shot down. We're taping this before Trump's press conference on Iran and
  24. these military rescues. So Kristen, most polls show the majority of Americans are
  25. opposed to this war, right? Pretty significantly. You recently did some polling with Trump's MAGA base. Talk a
  26. little bit about what's happening here uh in the polling and the thinking around it.
  27. >> Yeah. So normally historically when the US gets into conflict uh overseas there's normally a little bit of a rally
  28. around the flag effect um because normally we are getting involved in response to some kind of provocation um
  29. whether it was after 9/11 etc. Um in this case there was not really groundwork laid to make the case to the
  30. American people for why we needed to do this. And so, you know, in my polling when you say, "Would it be legitimate to
  31. engage in military activity against the Iranian government if they were developing a nuclear weapon, like
  32. twothirds of Americans say yes to to a bunch of those different kinds of things, but it's clear that that case
  33. wasn't really made well to the public because then when you say now, do you support or oppose what we're doing in
  34. Iran?" Most don't don't support it. Um, or they have some real serious questions. In fact, it is the MAGA base
  35. that is the most supportive of what we're doing. Um, there's so much interesting discourse around how Donald
  36. Trump reshaped the Republican party and there's this view that there is the old Republican party that like longs for the
  37. day of Ronald Reagan and says, you know, we love when the United States projects
  38. its power overseas and that Donald Trump has, you know, reashioned the Republican
  39. party in his own image away from that. No more forever wars. America first and all of that, but actually when you ask
  40. voters who identify themselves as like Trump supporters first before being Republican supporters, they are the most
  41. likely to sort of say if Donald Trump says it's a good idea, I'm kind of willing to give him the benefit of the
  42. doubt on this. Even though they backed him for America first and no foreign wars. Not everybody. Obviously, Marjorie
  43. Taylor Green put out a pretty big long well a lot of things that she put out about his health and his mental state
  44. and stuff like that, but um why is that? Why is the shift? Is just whatever he says goes or they don't really care what
  45. the words are or the policies. >> There are some people who are part of Donald Trump's coalition who are pretty,
  46. you know, they don't want the US to be involved in military activity overseas. They're very outspoken
  47. >> and they're quite outspoken about it, but those are different from MAGA voters. And I think there's a it's like
  48. very easy to kind of conflate like the MAGA movement equals everybody who voted for Donald Trump and like that's not
  49. true. Um there are a lot of people who in fact in some of the polling that I've seen it is the type of voter who is not
  50. a Republican and is pretty isolationist is among the most likely to have like come joined the Republican coalition
  51. recently. So Donald Trump does have a potential political problem with some people who really liked him and feel
  52. betrayed by what he's doing. But the core MAGA faithful and the Republican party as reconstituted by Donald Trump
  53. at the moment is reserving judgment and saying, you know what, I think he's probably on the right track. Let's see
  54. how this plays out. And how many people is that? What is the amount? Because majority of he's lost in the numbers are
  55. pretty staggering when you look at any poll. almost every one of them including Fox polls, all kinds of polls.
  56. >> Yeah. So, the I sort of estimate that the MAGA movement is about a quarter to
  57. a third depending on I mean it's a it's a pretty fluid section of the Republican
  58. party, but it's not half the country. And I think the big political risk Donald Trump faces is like it didn't
  59. have to be something where he was losing a majority of Americans. He could have,
  60. I think, communicated at least somewhat effectively about, hey, this is a government that's been declaring death
  61. to America for decades, and here are these specific things that they are doing that put us at risk. Here's why
  62. I'm going to do this. Here's what I'm going to take out. And I don't think it had to be a situation where he was
  63. losing half the public right from the get-go. Um but because of that lack of clarity in communication that has not
  64. really been followed by a ton of clarity in communication like the numbers are getting worse not better right okay so
  65. what talk about that for a second the clarity and communication because a lot of it is marketing you're talking about
  66. marketing like we're going to market this more to you why why was it not there and what impact how how because
  67. most people do give pes the benefit of the doubt something was up although he had previously bombed them and said he
  68. obliterated them so why the need to obliterate them again. I mean, I I even had Tom Tillis saying that, like, oh, we
  69. obliterated, then we obliterated, and now I guess we're obliterating. He was sort of articulating that lack of
  70. clarity. Yeah. Well, I I don't know that I would just say that it is marketing because I think for something like this,
  71. I mean, it to me the bar does feel higher than trying to sell somebody soda or potato chips or sneakers. I know
  72. that's not what you're saying, but I I think that the >> it's not just can you put out a snazzy
  73. video that makes it look like we're winning at a video game and you win because that's that's obviously part of
  74. the strategy and and yet the numbers are are what they are. That I think it is just that the the American people simply
  75. want to know why is this in our interest? And if you can give a reasonably good answer to why something
  76. is in our interest, we tend as a people to sort of give the commander-in-chief, maybe not today with Donald Trump as
  77. such a polarizing figure, but we tend to say, "Okay, if you think that this is in
  78. our best interest, like I'll give you a couple weeks to see how this plays out."
  79. And especially if the costs are not significantly high, people will give a little bit more of that runway. one, you
  80. know, I mean, thank goodness that they have gotten these pilots back because that's that's the kind of thing where
  81. it's it is I can't wait to hear the like thrilling story of how this was done, but a combination of if military losses
  82. begin to pile up in a very significant way or the domestic impacts of the straight of Hormuz, gas prices, all of
  83. that, you know, you can run out of that goodwill much more quickly. But right now, he didn't start with the the
  84. reservoir of goodwill that as a president you would want. Some of that's because he's Donald Trump and there's
  85. just some people who aren't going to like anything he does. But he also starts with people who will like
  86. anything he does. Uh who do sort of give him that benefit of the doubt even if they would not give a president Marco
  87. Rubio or President JD Vance that same leeway. And it does not seem like he has taken this moment. And his numbers have
  88. not gone up at all. They're going down. They're going down with everybody. Correct. So let's talk about that
  89. because the the numbers really are decline. They keep declining, which is really usually doesn't happen,
  90. especially for the midterms. President Trump's approval rating is just at 35% for his handling of the presidency
  91. overall and 31% for his handling of the economy, according to recent CNN polling. However, the news isn't great
  92. on either side. About a quarter of the country holds negative views of both parties. That's something not a fresh
  93. thing. Talk about when you look at this information as it is. You know, one of the things about Donald Trump is he's
  94. unprecedented. He's unprecedented in the decline and he's still standing kind of
  95. stuff. He keeps taking the punches here from a polling and and and you can feel it. I have a lot of MAGA not MAGA Trump
  96. adjacent relatives and they really don't like him like suddenly. Um and they never would express that before. There's
  97. I think two things that are that are ominous for Republicans. The first is with everything that's going on in
  98. foreign policy, um, foreign policy is not most voters number one issue, but it is the background music. It is the thing
  99. that tells you what the commander-in-chief's values are. It says a lot about what his temperament is. is
  100. I mean we already this is what he's interested in like not daycare not >> this is well covered territory with
  101. Donald Trump in some ways but it just sort of focuses the mind a little on like what is it that this person is all
  102. about you you frankly saw something like this with Biden when you saw his job approval as we withdrew from Afghanistan
  103. and as that went terribly that was the moment when his job approval went underwater and never recovered. It's not
  104. because most voters said what we do in Afghanistan is my number one issue, but it just it like communicates something
  105. about the level of competence and priority setting and decision-m within the Oval Office that like carries over
  106. and bleeds over into how people think on a whole variety of issues. Um, that's risk number one. Risk number two on the
  107. economy. Um, I I don't want to take credit for this, but this was the my friends at the Central Air podcast were
  108. talking about this that essentially Donald Trump had really good numbers in his first term on the economy. Even
  109. among voters who didn't like him overall, thought he was crude, thought he was crass, thought he was a jerk, all
  110. of that. They still thought, not all of them, but a small subset thought, "Yeah,
  111. but at least he's good on the economy." And when COVID happened, he still got kind of a pass. Like people sort of
  112. understood >> not his fault. Yeah, like he did not create this virus. For all his faults,
  113. he's this is this this was not on him. Um >> for all the bleach infected in for this time around, there's really no
  114. one else he can blame for the state of the economy. And he has tried to say, I'm just cleaning up Biden's mess. But
  115. you kind of run out of runway on that eventually where voters say like I'm t like Biden is so irrelevant to me. I'm
  116. tired of hearing about him. Just tell me what you're doing. What are you going to
  117. do? I I I don't I don't care what happened in 2023, 2024. Um the fact that his numbers on the economy
  118. in that CNN poll had 31% job approval, that is atrocious. That is a five alarm fire level number because one, it's way
  119. below like the norm for job approval these days hovers around 40%. You start getting into the 30s and that's scary
  120. land. you get into the low30s and that is like terminal. Um, and it for it to be on the economy which you know there
  121. have been other issues where he is job approval has fluctuated big time and people said oh I don't trust him on this
  122. X Y or Z. The economy was always a thing. Oh, he's the apprentice guy. Oh, he's the business guy. And so for his
  123. job approval to be that low on the economy, if that does not turn around, that suggests to me a very troubling
  124. midterm for Republicans with that. recently on how Gen Z voters are feeling about the economy. What did you find
  125. there? >> Give us some. >> So Gen Z voters have uh the worst view of the economy and even in just the last
  126. month it has plummeted precipitously. So when I say, you know, on the foreign policy stuff that Donald Trump mostly
  127. has the MAGA movement, there is a divide within the Republican party and it is older voters versus Gen Z. And so it is
  128. Gen Z Republicans in addition to Gen Zers who are not Republicans who are increasingly saying like this economy
  129. isn't working for me. And whether it's a combination of they are approaching graduation and the job market's not what
  130. they want, whether they feel like the affordability crisis is keeping home ownership and you know a whole variety
  131. of sort of life aspirations out of reach um or just a sense that there's not as much opportunity um for them to build
  132. the kind of career they want. I did some focus groups for the New York Times uh very recently where we talked to Gen Z
  133. white collar job seekers and it was I mean it was heart it was like unsurprising but also just heartbreaking
  134. to hear these young people talk about what it is like to try to get a job in a moment
  135. when they for some of them they went to college because they were told you need this credential now they've got debt and
  136. they still send out a 100 applications and they get five people to call them back of which three then proceed to
  137. ghost them and the other one the other two are AI. Yeah, exactly. >> Um and so it was just it it felt it
  138. there was a bleakness to it that was was disputing because normally when I talk to Gen Z folks like there's very much a
  139. yeah everything's terrible but like our generation is going to fix it. And it it
  140. almost feels like right now, do people feel like they have any sense of control or ability to shape the future or is it
  141. just like bigger, more powerful stuff at play that they won't be able to put their heads down?
  142. >> And they blame Trump for this, correct? Or >> in our focus group, I in our focus
  143. group, it was actually a more Demle leaning group. I don't know chicken or the egg. Is that because that's more of
  144. who was looking for jobs or what have you? Um, and we really didn't talk too much about Trump himself. Um,
  145. >> right. But it's a feeling and he's standing at the top. Right. That's my less that they say I can't get a job and
  146. it's Donald Trump's fault and it's more I can't get a job. It feels like society
  147. has been moving in a bad direction for a while and I don't know like who's sending the lifeboats like who's coming
  148. to rescue us? I don't know that anybody's in the prime position. When you think about that his outbursts, how
  149. much do they matter anymore? like the one this weekend. Of course, once again, and I don't mean to say the word pearl
  150. clutching, but everyone's like, "Oh, can you believe he said it?" I'm like, "Yes,
  151. he seems cognitively disabled to me. I don't I'm not a doctor, but he's as crazy as ever, and he's not. That's not
  152. changed." Does that matter when he does these sort of outbursts or are they just
  153. noise now with him with voters? >> Well, there's this weird disconnect where if you ask voters what they think
  154. about things like that, they tell you they don't like them. And yet I if if market signals are to be believed, more
  155. politicians seem to be leaning into that kind of behavior, a sort of like if you
  156. can't beat them, join them type approach. So like I would think if you if you just take people at their word,
  157. they want candidates who compromise and candidates who behave in a manner that is befitting the office and all of those
  158. different things. and then who shows up and votes in a primary like puts people in who have un unbelievable flaws in in
  159. any number of ways. So I think you're right and I don't think it's pearl clutching or or if it is like I'm I'm
  160. I'm pearl clutching a little bit. Not that I'm surprised but that I'm disappointed
  161. uh that we now have this >> horseness where >> like the president of the United States
  162. is tweeting fbombs. I don't love that. That's like maybe that's just me as a small C conservative like I'm I'm not
  163. interested. No thank you. >> Um >> but the reality is that voters say they don't want it and then this is who gets
  164. elected. And whether it's they're voting for him in spite of it or because of it.
  165. Like I think there's some people it's because of it. They like that he doesn't sound like somebody straight out of
  166. central casting. Um, >> yeah. >> Yeah. >> But I do wonder if there will be a backlash at some point. If Americans
  167. start to want straight out of Central casting sound like the old man at the my mom's uh senior living facility who you
  168. really need you go around to get off the elevator for. Um and and initially you're like and then you're like shut
  169. the [ __ ] up daddy grandpa. Anyway, um it's a really interesting thing because I think just like with Iran or anything
  170. else it's a background noise that's disconcerting right a direct thing. It's not soothing. It's
  171. not This is not America does not feel like the spa music is on. Let's put it that way. Especially with these young
  172. voters that you're seeing it. If you had to pick one polling thing that you went,
  173. "Oh my goodness sakes, one upside or downside. What is there something that stuck out from you recently in your
  174. polling?" Well, I think it is about Gen Z and the economy and it is when we've been asking people, do you think the
  175. economy is um headed in the right direction or the wrong direction? We've been asking them this for years. People
  176. generally have been saying it's been headed in the wrong direction and you can break it out by generation. And for
  177. the most part, this has not been something where like older voters think everything is great and younger voters
  178. think it's terrible. Like everybody's kind of been aligned about where things are at. But in just the last month in
  179. our March data, the Gen Z respondents, I mean, it fell off a cliff in terms of their feelings about the economy. And
  180. the reason why that sticks out is one, it's a it's breaking of a big trend that we'd had for a long time of kind of
  181. everybody feels like the economy is not doing great. Um, but just for to see them get so much more depressed in just
  182. a month was was really jarring. But number two, think about the kind of coalition that Republicans put together
  183. that have enabled them to have sort of better thanex expected elections. It's in part because they they tried to
  184. repair the damage that had been done with younger voters. And if you are presiding over an economy where Jenz is
  185. feeling like this, like that's it. The only thing you have going for you is the fact that Jenz finds Democrats to be
  186. uninspiring at the moment. Um, that's not a great thing to hang your hat on. So to me it's it is that Jenzi economic
  187. number more so than anything specific about foreign >> it's an opportunity for Democrats
  188. presumably correct is an opportunity >> it is it is an opportunity for Democrats
  189. but I think the thing that Democrats are getting wrong is like that they they know that affordability is the thing on
  190. everybody's minds and so they know to like mouth the words yes we care about cost of living and that may be enough if
  191. things are bad enough you can just say I'm not the other guy and that that could be adequate but I still think
  192. think that voters also in the surveys that I see harbor some skepticism about what Democrats would do if given the
  193. reigns again. Like, okay, we don't love what Trump's doing, but we still don't love the way Biden handled this either.
  194. So, what's your plan? Is your plan to open up the spigot of money and subsidize everything to pretend like it
  195. goes away, but that drives inflation? Like, we don't want that either. >> Run the deficit.
  196. >> Yeah. I don't I don't think that fresh ideas that actually solve people's problems. Incredible. Well, that's what
  197. they're supposed to do. Okay, Kristen, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about a potential
  198. cabinet shakeup and who might be the next to go. Support for this show comes from Vanta. If you're a business owner,
  199. you might have noticed that risk and regulation are on the rise. Customers now want proof of security before they
  200. commit, and earning that trust is critical to closing deals. But the process can be expensive, complex, and
  201. time inensive. Vanta says that's the challenge they're here to solve. Vanta automates your compliance process to
  202. bring compliance, risk, and customer trust together in one AI powered platform. So whether you're prepping for
  203. a sock 2 or running an enterprise GRC program, Vant keeps you secure and keeps your deals moving. Vant automates the
  204. process of achieving and maintaining compliance with over 35 security and privacy frameworks. This helps companies
  205. get compliant fast and remain compliant, opening doors to major growth opportunities and freeing up valuable
  206. time. Vantis says companies like Ramp and Writers spend 82% less time on audits with Vanta. That's not just
  207. faster compliance, it's more time to scale. So, if you're tired of sifting through old audits and spreadsheets, you
  208. can get a system that's always working in the background, keeping you compliant, reducing risk, and helping
  209. your business scale fast and with confidence, you can get started at vanta.com/pivot.
  210. That's van.com/pivot. vanta.com/pivot. This episode is sponsored by Better Health. Tax day is just around the
  211. corner. I don't need to tell you that. You might already feel anxious about it and about finances in general, but that
  212. is a very common feeling. A recent study showed 88% of Americans were feeling some form of financial stress at the
  213. start of 2026. Money worries go beyond our bank accounts and they affect everyone at some point in life. It can
  214. take a serious toll on mental health. From anxiety and depression to sleep disruption and relationship stress, even
  215. if you can't immediately change your finances, one thing you can start doing today is improving your mental state
  216. around them. That's where a therapist can help. BetterHelp matches you with a licensed therapist who fits your needs
  217. and preferences. They've served over 6 million people globally with over 12 years of experience. And even though
  218. they typically get it right the first time, if you aren't happy with your match, you can switch therapists
  219. whenever you want. When life feels overwhelming, therapy can help. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/pivot.
  220. That's betterhp.com/pivot. Christine, we're back. Pam Bondi and Christy No may have just been the
  221. beginning. A Trump cabinet shakeup is reportedly in the works, though the president is denying it, which means
  222. it's happening. The White House official told Reuters to expect a targeted churn
  223. rather than a big uh dramatic reset, which this feels like a corporation. Some of the names potentially on the
  224. chopping block. Director of National Intelligence Telsey Gabbard, FBI Director Cash Patel, Commerce Secretary
  225. Howard Lutnik, uh, Labor Secretary Lori uh, Derimer. As for Bondi's replacement,
  226. her deputy and Trump's former attorney Todd Blanch is currently serving as acting AG and he's already trying to
  227. distance the DOJ from the Epstein files, telling Fox last week that all the files
  228. have been released. talk a little bit about what's happening here in terms of um this and does this create more of a a
  229. voter dissatisfaction or is it I mean this happens in every administration where there's a shakeup kind of thing.
  230. It's not a and the last Trump administration was was like a manic episode of of the apprentice of course
  231. and people went in and out quite a lot. This is this is these people have had some staying power and they're 100% less
  232. competent. So talk a little bit about that. I think a shakeup can be a very good thing, especially if like let's
  233. take Christy. This is a great example of an issue immigration was an issue where
  234. Republicans and Donald Trump had a massive advantage that they haven't always had, but there was a real
  235. willingness to like America had moved to the right on these issues and said do what you got to do to get the border
  236. secure. and the way in which this was handled culminating in I mean embarrassment is
  237. is probably too light a way to frame it but the events of the last couple of months in terms of of ICE specifically
  238. >> um >> just this week with with a service member's wife being grabbed off a base
  239. >> I I just feel like for Donald Trump you you can't your political coalition can't
  240. survive if you don't have people coming to you going well at least he knows what
  241. to do about the border at least he knows how to handle this issue It's kind of a
  242. core piece of glue that holds different pieces of his coalition together. And if
  243. you lose that, what do you have? So by being able to sort of say, okay, I'm cutting this person. This person has
  244. been an embarrassment to me and look, my numbers on this issue have fallen. It is good that he is at least not
  245. taking the position of like I'm just going to I'm going to circle the wagons and we're going to say that everything's
  246. fine and it's just the liberal media that's being mean. So I think to some level these shakeups are what Donald
  247. Trump's voters expect from him, especially those folks who are not diehard Republicans, but instead
  248. gravitated to him for some combination of the economy and immigration and vibes that like being able to show yes, I want
  249. new people running the show. I have been unsatisfied with what they've been doing.
  250. >> Well, his brand started with that. You're fine. >> Exactly. Exactly. So, I don't know what
  251. that means about who would be next. I mean, I think about some of the names that were on your list, and some of them
  252. have done more that has publicly brought strife to the White House than others. And I think that's probably the thing
  253. that is animating this more. Like, I don't know to what extent his decision to to bid farewell to Christine Gnome.
  254. Was it about how ICE was handling the issue of immigration or was it how she handled hearings and some of these
  255. embarrassing stories about like you know the the planes and god knows what else?
  256. >> Um yeah >> but so that that's sort of how I >> honestly husband's the coolest thing
  257. about her but go ahead. All of which is to say I think if you want to know like where the change would
  258. come next I think the most important criteria is likely who who is reflecting well on this White House not who has you
  259. know something that's like got the beltway in a stir but it's not really reflecting badly on him
  260. >> right so it has to be who who does break through of these cabinet members with
  261. the voters the ones that you're polling >> so I honestly think that if you asked
  262. voters which member of the cabinet is the most supportive of tariffs. I do not think very many would be able to name
  263. Howard Lutnik. Um so that again I'm I am not a Trump Kremlinologist but to me it
  264. does not seem as though there's anything on the outside that would be driving that in quite the same way as say cash
  265. Patel at the FBI drinking with the hockey team or you know any number of cases that the FBI has been handling and
  266. questions about the effectiveness of of that. Um, so again, don't know which way
  267. he would go first, but to me that seems to be the most important variable or most obvious.
  268. >> Are you looking like an idiot publicly to a wide range of people? In other words, like a lot of people as opposed
  269. to say the labor secretary who's just seems naughty uh in a really bad way kind of thing because we've had naughty
  270. cabinet members for ever from what I can glean and stuff. But it but it doesn't break through with voters. more like
  271. Cash Patel drink down in the beer is a real bad visual for example. >> Well, and you know how Donald Trump
  272. feels about visuals like that. That's really really really important. The public image, do you look the part? Um
  273. and if you begin to fail on those dimensions, that's often when it's it's time for he's looking for somebody
  274. different. >> So is that is that a good thing? As you say, a shakeup isn't a bad thing, right?
  275. It shows you're you know you know look busy, Jesus is coming kind of thing like that kind of thing.
  276. >> Well, yeah. I think es especially because of what you said about his brand as the apprentice guy. I think the idea
  277. that you I mean remember like think about what he did with Doge when he first came into office. He just went
  278. through and slashed and burned. So we're going to fire a whole bunch of people. I
  279. mean that is >> his brand >> which which it should not just be isolated to lower runs if you're really
  280. going to live through uh you know live up to it and and press through with it. Um, it it it almost uniquely is a
  281. probably a good thing for Trump in a way that it might not even be for other administrations,
  282. >> right? No, his brand is firing. His brand is getting rid of incompetence and now he has he keeps them and you're
  283. like, "Oh my god, you're keeping the incompetence that I would agree having watched all those shows."
  284. >> And then the last question is for all of this, whether it's court appointments or
  285. cabinet appointments, what do you think the United States Senate is likely to look like after November? And how likely
  286. is it that you think you will be able to get someone confirmed through a Senate that potentially has more Democrats in
  287. it than it does today? I mean, those are things that I think are probably also weighing on the minds of the Susie Wilds
  288. of the world who are are keeping track of that. >> Yeah, the incompetence might have to
  289. stay. So, one of the things that's interesting uh also happening is the federal government is suing multiple
  290. states over attempts to ban betting on Kouchy and other platforms. Now, let's be clear. Donald Trump's children are
  291. part of this um or on the boards or advisers to both Poly Market and Kelshi. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission
  292. is arguing that it has the sole authority that that's what they're using to regulate these predictions markets.
  293. Meanwhile, Poly Market is apologizing after users were allowed to bet on the fate of the US pilots whose jet was
  294. downed in Iran. Pretty losome, saying it did not meet their integrity standards.
  295. Incredible. Both Poly Market and Calier are now rolling out campaigns to attract
  296. female users framing prediction markets as another way to be a hashgirl boss which by the way girl boss is over kids
  297. boys. We've been talking a lot about these markets here on Pivot and you and I have talked about it and so I want to
  298. play something Scott said a few weeks ago and get your thoughts. Let's listen. >> The speculative markets, speculation
  299. markets or prediction markets have essentially put pollsters and to a certain extent investment banking
  300. analysts out of work because guess what? They're much >> kind of I I would push back on that. I
  301. just met with a bunch of pollsters on this topic, but go ahead. >> In my opinion, they're done. They if you
  302. look at if you look at if you look at the prediction markets record versus pollsters in the last election, the
  303. prediction markets kicked their ass. >> All right, Pollster, what's your response? I I was trying to defend you
  304. there. Um, talk about about what's happening with them and your thoughts on it and what you like and don't like
  305. about them and and um just so you know, uh there's another possible nail in the coffin for polling. There's now
  306. something called silicon sampling that uses AI models to simulate simulate survey responses, not real people. Um,
  307. talk a little bit what's happening here in the polling market. >> Sure. So, I have a lot of thoughts on
  308. both of these. First, to Scott's point, I I do not think that prediction markets
  309. are going to put polling out of business. One, because 99% of what pollsters do is not polling that tries
  310. to track who is going to win an election. Like I know that's the most public thing that people see from our
  311. industry, but 99% of it is message testing, strategy, model building, the sorts of things for which being within
  312. margin of error, meaning your result is within three points in either direction.
  313. Like that's that's okay. That's sort of understood. >> Give me an example. Just make it up.
  314. Just like you pull what? >> So I I can tell you about the polling we've done on I've done some polling on
  315. prediction markets. um where you know I'm asking to what extent are people using them? What are they using them
  316. for? And those are the kinds of things that are valuable for somebody who might be trying to decide do I invest in one
  317. of these companies like if I'm going to regulate them, what sort of regulatory approach should I take? Uh it's the sort
  318. of thing where like I'll give you an example. In our poll, we found about onethird of people either bet on
  319. prediction markets, that's not a majority of them, or like use the data like they either they tune into it just
  320. for entertainment purposes or what have you. So, if my poll shows 36% of people fall into that category, the real
  321. number, assuming that I've done my survey right, the real number could be a few points off in either direction, and
  322. that's not the end of the world. It still means my analysis is still useful directionally. It's telling us something
  323. interesting about thing where things are going. I think this focus so exclusively
  324. on polling as a like crystal ball to tell me if an election is going to get won won by candidate A or candidate B
  325. just sort of misunderstands our industry. But the second thing is what is causing these prediction markets to
  326. give the predictions they are. So, think about there was a a a man um I think he
  327. was based in France who placed a huge bet in the last election that Donald Trump was going to win and afterwards,
  328. you know, he he makes this like six figure sum off of his bet and that's all great. And they ask him, you know, how'd
  329. you do it? And he said, "Oh, I commissioned a poll." Um the polls are still an input to what these prediction
  330. markets are doing. In a world without polls, your prediction market is running on vibes and fundraising numbers, which
  331. are fine, but polls are an extremely they are a loadbearing pillar in what people think about what's going to
  332. happen in an election. >> So So predictions would be a trailing indicator or what how do you look at
  333. that? >> Yes. So I I think that in general, well, I I think when it comes to election
  334. results, they don't have to be a trailing indicator, but I think that polls are an input. There are they are
  335. not the only input. So other things can change, right? My poll can say that so and so is going to win the primary in
  336. Texas, but all of a sudden some new news story could break that shows that Ken Paxton or John Cornin did something, you
  337. know, that could upend the race. Who knows? >> It's usually Paxton >> and then the prediction market would be
  338. the leading indicator ahead of when the poll is going to capture that. Um, but you still need the poll involved. And
  339. that's also what I think about this whole synthetic respondents, AI respondents. You know, nowadays you're
  340. seeing more people. >> Yeah. And and there were some attempts to do this in the 2024 election that I
  341. think were actually less accurate than >> Explain what people what it is. You use
  342. AI model. Explain for people who don't understand. >> Yeah. So, if you've ever used one of
  343. these models, whether it's your chat GPT or your Claude, and you can like train Claude or Chat GPT or whoever to kind of
  344. learn a certain persona, imagine that you've then trained a thousand different personas that kind of look like a real
  345. voter. Okay, I've trained one persona to be a 40-year-old woman living in Orlando, Florida, and she's a moderate
  346. Republican. And now I've got another bot that is trained to be a conservative Democrat, and he lives in rural
  347. Pennsylvania. And and then basically, you just ask those thousand AI personalities to tell you, are you
  348. voting for a Republican or a Democrat? And then you take those results and you say, "Hey, look, I did a poll. I did a
  349. poll of a thousand AI people who represent real voters, >> right? >> Um, >> and I just think presenting that as a
  350. poll is disingenuous. I think you can present it as a modeled estimate. Like I think there's lots of things you can
  351. present it as. >> Do you use model that like use AI? How do you use it in >> post? So we the way we use AI, you can
  352. use AI to help you know with programming tasks. It's enormously helpful. You can
  353. use AI to help you analyze data when it comes back. Like the old school way of analyzing polling data is you do a
  354. survey and you get back cross tabs that is this like 500page PDF with a ton of numbers on each page and you as the
  355. pollster are sifting through looking for stuff that's that's meaningful. The fact
  356. that you can feed that in and have AI tell you, hey, here are the top 10 most interesting things in that poll. Eight
  357. out of 10 are going to be pretty good. one out of the 10 will be right but not really that important and then one will
  358. be like completely wrong and so you still have to as the pollster exercise your judgment go through go through your
  359. own data uh and know but like there are useful applications of AI in polling but
  360. ultimately if you think about those synthetic personas what's training that synthetic 40-year-old suburban mom who
  361. lives in Orlando on how she ought to respond a poll it's probably a poll that was done to so all of this whether it's
  362. prediction markets or these synthetic AI samples all of them at their root have real polling as an input and it's like a
  363. game of telephone and they're just like the next piece in the line and you can add other useful inputs that might give
  364. them some advantages but they're still not a replacement for polling they are just a different application of polling
  365. >> so what when you say that when the federal government is saying commodity I think futures trading should be
  366. regulating them. They're not regulating them. Is it fair? Is it sort of like It reminds me a little bit of your like
  367. commerce people, retail people who are offline having to fight with online. They had distinct advantages here. They
  368. can they can do whatever these people to grow large. What do you imagine? How who
  369. should be states are rushing in because they have long long regulated gambling. Every state does has its different
  370. gambling laws and that's not something the federal government ever did. So is it like gambling from your perspective
  371. or how should they be regulated when you think about it given presumably you're not that regulated but you you have a
  372. set of standards that you're working around. I I think the big challenge is how do you balance the value that a
  373. prediction market can provide to society beyond it's just entertainment, right? like what is the what is the value
  374. beyond entertainment of I'm betting on who's going to win the Super Bowl like and so we have to decide do we think
  375. that's an acceptable form of entertainment but the the the promise of prediction markets is theoretically that
  376. you can also surface new information about things that have not yet happened that might be valuable for the public to
  377. know the question is then like when does that cross into insider trading like for
  378. me I feel I've never bet on a prediction market because I would feel uncomfortable about like I come out of
  379. the field with a survey. I then know what's happening in the Texas primary and therefore I can know hm I think
  380. candidate X Y or Z is probably up and if I really trust my data why don't I put a
  381. couple thousand bucks on on this bet and I just don't feel right about that. I it
  382. something about it feels like insider trading and I think that's where it's and I don't know what the
  383. >> you're just having more insight, right? That's kind of an interesting example.
  384. You have some in is that insider or is that was your own data? >> I I don't I think you're right that
  385. that's not insider trading in the way that but it is like it is non-public information that I would be using to
  386. benefit. It's not the same as being an insider at a company where there are very specialized strict rules around
  387. that. But I think it's that that muddying of the waters, right? And so you've been seeing this too with some of
  388. these markets that have had bets around things like will the United States do military operation X and all of the
  389. sudden right before it happens, you see somebody bets like $300,000 sitting next
  390. to Trump in the White House and they just heard it, right? >> And like and so I do think that that
  391. that's that raises some real questions. If we're going to have rules around insider trading, when does that start to
  392. bleed over into what is or is not allowable conduct in terms of prediction markets?
  393. >> Have they hurt themselves? You know, but sometimes it's not insider. Like, it
  394. sounds crazy, but when Warner Brothers was $7 and that all the bidding started, I'm like, these rich people will pay
  395. anything. And so, I bought 10 shares cuz I was like, and it was only 10 cuz I was
  396. like, I think they're dumb, stupid money, so they're going to overpay. And I just and I took myself out for a nice
  397. dinner because I was right. And that was information I had, but anyone could have
  398. figured it out. Dumb, stupid money, for example. And thank you for the dinner, Allison's. I appreciate it. When you
  399. have these things doing this, when they're putting in this sort of they kind of fud muddy the line. There's also
  400. these betting on heinous things, right, which makes it feel like gambling. And then attracting female users is a
  401. problem. They've got a bad reputation from the get-go, including attracting the attention of regulators, right? Like
  402. in terms of their bad behaviors. Yeah. So, when when I look at the polling I've done on this, and again, in disclosure,
  403. I did polling uh for um an organiz It's all it's all publicly available, but sort of an entity that like I think
  404. invests in uh some of these prediction markets. And in general, just a lot of people don't know that much about them.
  405. like they're pretty split on whether it's good or bad, but everybody's got an attit an an attitude about it. Everybody
  406. has like an opinion of some sort. But when we ask about prediction markets, like half of Americans have no idea how
  407. they feel about it. Um, most have not heard anything in the news about a prediction market in the last 12 months.
  408. So, there is a real risk and real opportunity for that industry. And it's why they're trying to get out ahead of
  409. it and say, "Hey, right now, like in my data, it showed it too. if it's if you are male, if you are under the age of
  410. 50, if you are higher educated, higher income, like you are the most likely to know about prediction markets and be
  411. interested in them and think they're a good thing. Um, and so they're trying to say, okay, we've got to tell our story
  412. or someone else is going to tell our story. And that's why you're seeing efforts to try to expand beyond.
  413. >> So they've got an opportunity despite all the bad the bad press. But it seems
  414. like the bad press keeps piling on this US pilots jet thing. I thought, "Oh my god, I think
  415. >> this is the for, you know, for any for a platform that has control over what markets can be made and and not made,
  416. you know, having that judgment of what where's the upside? is is the upside in ma max maximizing the sorts of things
  417. people can bet on and not restricting it too tightly knowing that we're going to
  418. have a couple of these that are like cringe cringeworthy versus more tightly regulating it sort of playing it safer
  419. >> you have higher upside in terms of your favorability but >> you then as a platform are in that role
  420. that you will recall the social media companies did not want to be in when it came to like deciding where's the
  421. boundaries of political speech How do you decide what constitutes a market that is out of bounds? Like you don't
  422. want to be business >> did better by looking safer, right? Like right now from the polling, do you think
  423. that doing what anything goes is a particularly good way to do it? >> No. And I I think there there is a
  424. significant difference between people's comfort level with prediction markets as
  425. a sort of adjacent to the sorts of betting and chance things that they know. But it's it's slightly better than
  426. just chance because you can use your own judgment to say, "Okay, I think X, Y, and Z is going to happen." You can use
  427. your own smarts toward it accordingly. I think that's why it could have a slightly better it it could wind up with
  428. people liking it more than they like something like sports betting where you're just like I hope this team wins.
  429. I like them. Um but there are real downsides if you have people creating these horrible or unsavory markets where
  430. it feels like you've just turned something very serious into [ __ ] fighting. >> That's what it feels like for like in a
  431. [ __ ] fighting mode. Like I don't mind a little bit of a boxing match, but I don't really want to watch animals rip
  432. each other apart, right? Either like some people do, but it sort of feels it has that sort of stink to it. Um, let me
  433. last question. You know, Scott is absolutely saying your your business is finished. Um, you're out of work because
  434. of them. How give one more answer to Scott Galley, please. the political polling industry is going to be fine
  435. because when we are in moments of deep uncertainty, that is the moment when people,
  436. companies, trade associations, you name it, people are the most hungry to know what the heck is everybody thinking,
  437. where is this all headed? And with the understanding that polling is not the only or perfect way to get a read on
  438. that, but is a as I described it like a loadbearing pillar. It's a really important input. I mean, when the world
  439. is in a moment of turmoil or dramatic change, that is when people want this data more than ever. And where something
  440. that is >> trained on polling data, but kind of off and not quite there >> is not going to be
  441. as as much as real polling is imperfect, it's still the real thing. >> Yeah. I always am like I always Scott,
  442. I'm always like, "What's in there? Who's doing it? Who's doing the bedding? I don't know who they are, right? Like it
  443. could be a bunch of It probably is a bunch of white bro millennials. That's who and I don't that's their opinion,
  444. not everybody's opinion. That's my thing. And especially if there's not a lot of women in there, there's not a lot
  445. of different economic groups. You don't get a really particularly good sample. That's my feeling. When when we get
  446. closer to the election, the safest and healthiest way to consume polling data is just take it and throw it in the
  447. average. Don't panic about anyone individual poll. Everything's going to be all right. No, thank you.
  448. >> Well, I don't know about the last part. >> I don't know about the last part. Anyway, uh you you crazy bastards. You
  449. know, like I say, every accusation is a confession. Uh anyway, uh let's go on a quick break. When we come back, Open AI
  450. gets into podcasts. >> Support for the show comes from Upwork. Hiring can be a double-edged sword. On
  451. one hand, there's the promise of growing your team so everyone can share the load
  452. and get more work done. On the other hand, it can be such a headache. Here's an idea. Upwork. You don't have to do it
  453. all yourself. Upwork can make it easier to bring the right freelancers right when you need them. You can browse
  454. profiles, review past work, and get help scoping the role so you can hire with confidence and get started quickly.
  455. Seriously, you can connect with the right freelancer in just a few hours. Especially when you sign up with
  456. Business Plus. Their AI powered short listing pairs you with the top 1% of talent in under 6 hours. No endless
  457. searching required. Upwork also cuts down operational hassle by handling things like contracts and payments in
  458. one place, so you can spend more time running your business. Visit upwork.com right now and post your job for free.
  459. That's upwork.com to connect with top talent ready to help grow your business. That's upw.com.
  460. upwork.com. Christian, we're back with more news. You just sort of talked about this, the
  461. idea of where you get your narrative and information from. It has to be good and
  462. wide. So, OpenA has acquired the tech news podcast TBPN. The online talk show focuses by the minute analysis of tech
  463. news and interviews with top tech leaders. TPBN averages 70,000 viewers per episode across everything. And let
  464. me just say they are tiny compared to Pivot and other things. Tiny, tiny, tiny. That said, it's become popular
  465. among a certain group of Silicon Valley power players who go on it because they want to be licked up and down all day.
  466. Um, oh, I'm sorry, boys. Is that Did I say that too wrong? Okay. Sometimes you're spiky and fun, but really it's
  467. pretty much a up to me PR. Um, OpenAI says the show will stay editorially independent, which we do not believe.
  468. Um, talk about this idea of buying narratives when you when you're thinking about it because, you know, a lot of
  469. people want to, you know, you do polling so you have better narratives and craft
  470. messages. That's one of the things you do for people is tell them how to craft their messages. talk a little bit about
  471. this effort and you know that's in the backdrop of um of many company many tech companies trying to buy into uh into uh
  472. various things like Paramount etc. So what this reminds me of is there's actually a a piece out in today's which
  473. I guess the day we're taping this uh New York Times David Pluff who I think is very like still one of the smartest
  474. minds on the Democratic >> love this piece please. Uh it was it was yeah this piece is essentially saying
  475. that everything is content creation now that if you are running for office, >> if you are engaged in politics, the most
  476. important thing you need to be doing is creating content. That if you are relying on anybody else to get your
  477. message out but you, you are foolish. um and that you need to essentially have a
  478. studio within your campaign headquarters where you are just non-stop producing content because everything now is is
  479. that uh I think that's really smart. Um you know I think about that in terms of like look at the media properties in the
  480. political space that are really like thriving and doing exciting stuff now the like the pucks and the punch bowls
  481. and all of that. I mean they're very focused on like we are constantly creating content. We're finding a
  482. million new channels to do it. Sometimes it's in person events, sometimes it's digital, but it it is a like always on
  483. kind of approach. And I think companies realizing this uh is probably smart. Although there's a there's a a flip side
  484. to this, which is, >> you know, we've we've been going through a moment in the last few years where it
  485. feels like, you know, everybody everybody's got a new podcast, Cara. You know, everybody's like, "Ah, I'm going
  486. to create content. If you build it, they will come." And that's not true at all.
  487. Lots of people can build podcasts that or you know create content that sort of goes out into the ether to die. Yeah.
  488. And especially if it doesn't feel authentic, if it feels driven by a corporate narrative, it it starts to
  489. lose some of what might make content >> great otherwise. So like I imagine there
  490. are a bunch of candidates who could take pluff at at his word and start doing what he says and would produce terrible
  491. content. >> Yes. Good and genuine. Yeah, you're right 100%. Yeah. So he that was a
  492. really interesting piece and I really I like David and it was absolutely true. Although it's kind of like no [ __ ]
  493. Sherlock. I was like what? You're kidding. The content's important. >> No, but see you you and I think like oh
  494. yeah no kidding. But it it is truly this idea that politics is now about being always on media messaging non-stop. That
  495. is actually something that is >> not which is important to a lot of people. Trump has proven that for many
  496. years. Obviously, now it's getting the the show's getting a little old in the tooth right now and kind of crazy, but
  497. that's all right. It's a little like network at the very end. Um, when Howard had some problems. Um, but you know, you
  498. see AOC did it from the get-go, was very genuine to herself and she's obviously talking her own book, but it's very
  499. effective. Same thing with Mom Donnie who's been very good and he's continuing to govern that way. If you notice all
  500. his really interesting and they're good, they're good. They're fun and they're they're creative. Um you don't have to
  501. agree with them to not say, "Wow, look at that. That's really well done." Um especially during snowstorm, he did a
  502. couple of good ones that were just sort of it wasn't political. It was just here's how we're doing it and they were
  503. funny and quirky. His whole thing, there was one he did the smile where he has that weird smile and they made his whole
  504. staff made fun of his smile and I thought that was it was based on the movie Smile which was a horror movie
  505. which was funny. It's just he's very on top of things and so are a lot of by the
  506. way Republicans. Some Republicans do a good job at it. Not not as many, but Trump certainly absolutely for many
  507. years has done a really good job. I think the problem with these things is people don't realize tech has tried this
  508. a dozen times. Many years ago, Yahoo tried to do a news product and that didn't work because they weren't doing
  509. any original reporting or anything else. They were just mouththing stuff. Um, uh,
  510. Andre Hordes famously had a blog and called me and said they were going to beat me at my own game. And I'm like,
  511. good [ __ ] luck. First of all, media is hard and it doesn't make money. Sorry. Like you're you're entering a
  512. really like like what are you doing? And it well didn't work. They've tried a number of times that that particular
  513. group and you know it's always sort of failed. AOL did it a little bit like around the edges tried to you know to
  514. create some and it just doesn't happen. So I think one of the things is I get that you feel more comfortable in these
  515. settings where people are a little bit like your giant brain is so smart. Tell me how that works. And I think that has
  516. value by the way you know it's startup people are always interested in how did I do that right how did you do that and
  517. they don't want any push back they just want to hear your techniques whatever even if it's PR but eventually it's not
  518. truthful right of like the real struggles companies have and when you have a little friction with a reporter
  519. it does create really interesting conversations and the only person I would look to would be Apple Steve Jobs
  520. he kept coming back to be interviewed by me even though I know I irritated him right? Because it was an interesting
  521. conversation and it would help him. It clarified things. Um, we were fair with him at the same time. I don't think we
  522. ever pulled any ridiculous, stupid, snarky moves. Um, but in a lot of ways, I feel responsible for this kind of
  523. nonsense because they just don't want to talk to anyone they consider difficult and would prefer to be. And I don't
  524. think that is the best outcome editorially. I just don't I just don't think it becomes I think there'll be a
  525. backlash and they'll start talking to actual reporters that are fair. That's my feeling, but I don't know. Maybe I'm
  526. open. I don't really want to talk to them anymore anyway. So, it doesn't matter in some level, but I don't know.
  527. We'll see. It's a small amount of money to pay for possible good PR in a new fresh way.
  528. >> Is it a small amount of money? I feel like the reporting was that it was not a
  529. small amount of money. Yeah, but for them it's a small amount of money and they've said that essentially on the
  530. show is like that was a lot of money. We're taking it and running and that will be the end of it I suspect. But
  531. it's glad it's glad they have people telling them they're great. That's really good because they need that
  532. because you know money doesn't seem to make them happy. >> Um in any case, we'll see. Do you see a
  533. lot of Are you impressed by a lot of political um outfits? Give me give me things that you think are have done it
  534. well in the political space. >> I will cross party. >> Well, yeah. So, I'll I'll cross party
  535. lines and say that I I think that AOC is somebody who an example that I always give um of something that she did that
  536. has just like lodged in my brain and I wish every politician would understand that this is the way the world works is
  537. she appeared on um a skincare influencers platform. This was like two or three years ago. This wasn't this
  538. isn't terribly recent, but she went on to talk about uh sunscreen regulation. Like right now, if you try to buy
  539. sunscreen in the US, there are sunscreens that are better elsewhere in the world, but you cannot get them here.
  540. They're not FDA approved. Um they're not dangerous. Everything's fine with them.
  541. They just for whatever reason, you can't get them here. And so she went on this skincare influencer show to talk a
  542. little bit about that specific issue. And like, isn't it crazy that you can't get these good sunscreens here? which is
  543. not an issue that is obviously right left coded or if anything it's almost more rightcoded. It's like hey the
  544. government is regulating away your right to have this really good sunscreen. Um but she went somewhere where people who
  545. are not necessarily going to tune in and watch her on MSNBC or MS now whatever we're calling it. Um you know that
  546. that's not the audience she's going after. She's going after people who might be much more loosely attached to
  547. the political process, but she's getting herself in front of them on an issue that they care about with some
  548. credibility and that opens the door then to say, "Hey, come follow me." Like, you
  549. may not follow members of Congress because that may seem lame and horrible, but I am not as lame and horrible as the
  550. rest of them, so please follow me. And you build that audience. And I think most politicians if you were like go on
  551. a skincare influ I mean they're you wouldn't want that for most of them but just whatever the equivalent of that is
  552. like you want to talk about emissions regulations like go on a car podcast I just I think that most people in
  553. Washington are not thinking in that gear and that is where the future is going to
  554. be won. It's not >> and also corporations too participating. I think Wendy's does a good job. I think
  555. King Arthur Baking, you can you can name a dozen of them. Sometimes they can spin
  556. out of control, but often it's a really interesting >> uh way to sort of genuinely explain
  557. yourself to people in a as long as it's not cringe, right? In some fashion over advertising.
  558. >> I 100% I I mean, if you're not out there, if you're not telling your story, someone else is. So, it's important to
  559. go out there. It's important to be in places where it's not just it's important to be in I think nonobvious
  560. places, but I also like the tension is then you don't want to do stuff that's forced and feels cringeworthy. Um but
  561. just letting letting the other side own the airspace or letting your opponents own the airspace is is not really as
  562. much of a viable option. Yeah. very quickly. Um, obviously banks and advisers working on the SpaceX IPO
  563. dealer being required to buy subscriptions to Grock Musk's terrible AI chatbot. Um, they they're going to do
  564. it anyway because they'll do anything it takes. They'll take sure we'll buy your
  565. shitty product for if you'll give us the banks. Um, he's also asked them to advertise on X was less insistent on
  566. that request. Obviously, they're going to all do it. Uh, that I'm not surprised by. But I'm just curious, have you done
  567. any polling on Elon now post, you know, he's now going to be very wealthy again.
  568. once again more wealthy than he was before. How where is his polling? Have you done much on on where he sits
  569. because he's about to enter the political spectrum again quite significantly it looks like. I mean, I
  570. still think that he has residual favorability from Republicans who I think have by and large forgotten his
  571. well I was going to say the very big public falling out that he had with Trump that got very ugly very uh
  572. quickly. Um that that all but seems to have been kind of memory hold at this point. Um but but there is still that
  573. lingering negativity from Democrats. It may not be as acute. I mean, I I have not heard reports of like protests
  574. outside Tesla dealerships in the way that you had about a year ago. So, it feels like the temperature has turned
  575. down, but it is not as though anybody has like converted back to liking him or not liking him. Wherever you were a year
  576. ago, you're probably still in about the same place. So, when when you're a Republican getting money from him, it's
  577. worth it. Correct. Now, or is it a bad thing? Because he lost in Wisconsin. He lost a lot of his presence tends to
  578. be a problem for some people. I think he is not as much of a potent lightning rod
  579. as he was a year ago when we were in the midst of Doge being in the news every single day, some new agency getting shut
  580. down or somebody getting fired or or something happening that was causing >> causing some stir. you know, him showing
  581. up in the White House, him in the White House with one of his kids, you know, like those we're that's not happening
  582. anymore. And so I think him having less him be he is less of a lightning rod today than he was a year ago. So I I
  583. think that would probably lessen any, you know, downside to having him, but he shouldn't act up again. Correct. Create
  584. a >> as last time I was on your show, I said like less chainsaw, more Mars. And I
  585. stick to it. I think to the extent that he has spent the last year doing less chainsaw and more Mars, I don't think
  586. that it's necessarily won back anybody from the left, >> but I do think that the temperature has
  587. been turned down around him to where he's a little less >> more Mars. That's what you got to do.
  588. Build your [ __ ] rockets, I've said that over and I think you were absolutely right back then. All right,
  589. Kristen, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails. Support for the show comes from Delete
  590. Me. Delete Me makes it easy, quick, and safe to remove your personal data online
  591. at a time when surveillance and data breaches are common enough to make everyone vulnerable. You don't have to
  592. be a public figure to be at risk of having your personal information stolen by bad actors. The terrifying reality is
  593. that we're all susceptible and the impact of identity theft can be devastating. Delete Me can help you
  594. protect your personal privacy or the privacy of your business from doxing attacks before sensitive information can
  595. be exploited. I have used Delete Me for a while. I think it's really important to be aware of what's out there about
  596. you is really surprising. Even someone like me who spends a lot of time protecting their privacy. How much
  597. information is out there, how much of it is bad, and how much is being compiled together. You really have to fight hard
  598. to keep your privacy. And Delete Me is an excellent tool. Last year, the New York Times wire cutter named Delete Meir
  599. their top pick for data removal services. Not a surprise. So, what are you waiting for? Take control of your
  600. data and keep your private life private by signing up for Delete Me now at a special discount for our listeners. Get
  601. 20% off your DeleteMe plan when you go to joindeleteme.com/pivot and use the promo code pivot at
  602. checkout. The only way to get 20% off is to go to joindeme.com/pivot and enter the code pivot at checkout.
  603. That's joined me.com/pivot code pivot. Okay, Kristen, let's hear some wins and fails. You go first. All
  604. right. Well, we're going to talk space. Um, and this is a mine is a win and a fail combined. A win is that as you and
  605. I are recording probably right about uh now, Americans are flying around the backside of the moon. That feels like
  606. the biggest possible win. The fact that these that the rocket took off and it was fine and it wound up working is
  607. unbelievable. But the fail is the toilets do not seem to be staying in operation on this. This is a subject of
  608. great interest to my daughters. Uh they are they are like really really really trying to keep up on the what is the
  609. status of >> the toilets on this uh Artemis. I think Orion might actually be the name of like
  610. the part that they are in. But uh so it's both a win and a fail. >> I think NASA has shined itself up a
  611. little bit. It's always it's been sucked away by Bezos and Musk, but I think NASA
  612. feels kind of cool. I think their social media is excellent. I think Victor Victor the pilot is such a hunk like
  613. like all of them are are and and all the the whole team are amazing. I think >> they have a great inspirational message.
  614. I mean just every time you hear them talk and it doesn't feel like hyper media trained either. Again to what we
  615. were talking about earlier with like it just feels like you found genuinely incredible people and are sending them
  616. to do an incredible thing on behalf of humanity. >> Yeah, I agree. I think they they just
  617. are doing flawless speaking of social media. Flawless social media. I I haven't seen one thing that I' The
  618. pictures are beautiful. The the the enthusiasm again, it doesn't feel cooked in some fashion. The fail is the
  619. continued sort of um I know you, like you said, I'm not clutching my pearls, but come on. I
  620. think people are sick of this and I think there's going to be a significant backlash to politicians that look, I
  621. think there's a real opportunity for people to be funny and nice and, you know, sort of more open-minded rather
  622. than dunking dunking dunking. I I just have this I think what Trump is doing is is a step too far. And he I can't even
  623. believe I'm saying that cuz I I'm never that person who goes, "Oh, you're kidding. Can you believe what he said?"
  624. I always believe what he says cuz I think he's like that. Um but I do think people are tiring of it. And I think
  625. even though they're sloughing it off, they're not sloughing it there. You know, gh that's him. I think there's
  626. more. It's like I'm tired of hearing this now. And I think there's a real opportunity for politicians to make
  627. people feel better. like I know in political life in general and not but and also not um do it in a stupid way
  628. where you just pretend it's not happening like that kind of thing. So I do think that's been a real fail and I
  629. do think it's pro it's a bigger problem than people think. That's one. My win is
  630. the Netflix documentary Dynasty the Murdoch. Um it's about the Murdoch Empire. I found out stuff about Ruben
  631. Murdoch that was fascinating. I thought it was incredibly Liz Garbas directed it. I thought it was a terrific
  632. documentary. I learned a lot about this very I thought it was very fair to the family at the same time. Um sad to
  633. watch, you know, this kind of fall apart and I'm endlessly fascinated by Rupert Murdoch, but and you know, he's getting
  634. he's getting on in years and everything, but I do think it was a really interesting documentary. Um and not just
  635. cuz I'm it although I think I'm spectacular in it. No, I'm kidding. No, the people who are mostly who've done
  636. all the reporting at the times um did an amazing job and so I recommend it. I recommend watching it. It's he's he's a
  637. unique political figure as you know, but I learned a lot from the documentary. I
  638. Have you seen it? >> I have not. >> I will say the last movie that I watched that referenced Rubert Murdoch was I
  639. rewatched The Devil Wears Prada from 2006 in preparation for, you know, the the rebirth, the two too devil, too
  640. furious that's coming up. Uh, and he he is mentioned there's a there's a scene where uh it's it's when Meyer Street's
  641. character Miranda Priestley is sort of her her husband is divorcing her and she says like Rupert Murdoch should cut me a
  642. check for all the papers that I've sold for him like assuming that like she fuels you know all these gossip gossip
  643. rag headlines and so any I haven't seen the movie you were talking about but I did see Devil War's product.
  644. >> Yeah, it's it's a sing it's a series a couple of episodes. It's really good. Uh, I I shouldn't say this, but I'm I'm
  645. in the Devil's Produ just briefly. >> Shh. >> Oh, tell. >> Yeah, it's like I'm sure it's blinking.
  646. You'll see it, but uh they did a lot of uh it was reported already and it the reports were true.
  647. >> I'm I don't know if they've cut me, but I I'm there. I get to play myself a lot,
  648. Kristen, besides uh in uh on billboards in Times Square. Uh but I actually, for some reason, I'm the go-to person now.
  649. If they have AI in the plot, they bring in carousel. It's like Wolf Blitzer. >> So, there is I have I have one funny
  650. story about this. Um, you know that movie Edge of Tomorrow or it used to be called like or like Lived, Die I Repeat
  651. is what they rebranded. I'm obsessed with this movie. >> Blunt and Tom Cruz. Fantastic movie.
  652. >> At the beginning there's a scene where it's Jake Tapper interviewing and it's a
  653. panel where it's like Olivier Knox from >> I think he was at the post at that time.
  654. Um, Kiki Mlan, Democratic strategist, and then Tom Cruz is in the middle. But like that scene never happened. They
  655. edited him in and they edited Tom Cruz on top of Ross Stout. >> Ah, perfect. I like it. I'm there for
  656. it. >> So, cuz I was I was watching the movie and I was like, was like, who is the
  657. Republican that was on set that day that got edited out to be Tom Cruz? Was it me? I don't think so.
  658. >> Oh, yeah. That would be harder. Wow. Okay. Good to know. I love that movie. Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send
  659. us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. and go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for
  660. this show or call 855-51 pivot. Okay, that's the show. Again, thank you for joining me today, Kristen. Everyone
  661. should watch her bowling. She also appears on in on CNN and she's does wonderful stories in the pieces in the
  662. New York Times which I learn a lot from just she lets the voters speak and actually it's really interesting to hear
  663. them because it's a little more um complex and that's why it's great and that's important to understand the
  664. complexity of all this. Anyway, uh, thanks for listening to Pivot. Be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube
  665. channel. We'll be back on Friday. Thank you, Kristen. Thank you, Karen. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York
  666. Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com/pod. We'll be back later this week for
  667. another breakdown of all things tech and business. Sam Alman, Pivot's not for sale. Sorry, so sorry.

Brief Summary

Kristen Sulttus Anderson discusses polling trends, Trump's foreign policy, and Gen Z's economic concerns in this episode of Pivot.

Key points

  • Trump's Ultimatum to Iran. Trump threatens Iran with dire consequences if they don't comply with his demands.
  • Polling Insights on Military Action. Polling reveals a divide in American support for military action against Iran.
  • Gen Z's Economic Despair. Gen Z voters express bleak views on the economy and job market.
  • Gen Z's Economic Despair. Recent polling shows Gen Z's feelings about the economy have drastically declined.
  • Trump's Cabinet Shakeup. A potential cabinet shakeup is reportedly in the works, despite presidential denials.
  • The Role of AI in Polling. AI can help analyze polling data, but it can't replace real polling.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes