OpenAI May Delay Its IPO. Scott Galloway: "Anthropic Is Eating Their Lunch" | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara and Scott discuss Comcast splitting itself up, and spinning off NBCUniversal and Sky. Then, OpenAI reportedly considers delaying its IPO, but is that the smart money move? Plus, Pete Buttigieg opens up about his family being targeted, and Trump does his best to hold up Congress's housing bill.

00:00 Intro 00:28 Comcast Splits 13:31 OpenAI Weighs Delaying IPO 22:22 Buttigieg Targeted 29:40 Housing Bill Future 33:52 Wins and Fails

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin Todd Wiseman

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The internet doesn't have a speech problem. It has an accountability problem. And our fetishization for free
  2. speech and anonymity has resulted in a total lack of accountability. We've got a lot to get to today, so
  3. let's dig in. We we there's so much news. Scott even participated in the group chat. He was like, there's so much
  4. news. But actually, his selections were correct. But because the first one is something I think I was a little was I
  5. surprised Comcast is spinning off NBC Universal and Sky into a separate publicly traded company. The new NBC
  6. Universal will include NBC, the Universal Film Studio, theme parks and Sky. This is the the satellite service
  7. they have in in the in Europe. Comcast keeps Exfinity Internet and Wireless. So it's back to square one. I guess the
  8. market liked it. Comcast shares jumped 21% in pre-market trading Monday morning. It's not a total clean bait.
  9. Comcast will hold a roughly 20% stake in the new NBC Universal. I think they still have a big stake in MS now, too.
  10. Um, and the deal is expected to close with in about a year. There's a catch, though. Analysts say, well, the spin-off
  11. gives NBC Universal more freedom to do deals. It leaves Comcast broadband business more exposed at a time when
  12. cable is already under pressure. So, talk about this. The people they're putting in place are very good
  13. executives. Um, but does NBC now now remerge with MS now or what in the You need to explain this to me. I really
  14. didn't quite understand why they're doing it now. Uh, what the troubles they're seeking. I know they had looked
  15. at uh buying Warner at one point. Um, so could Netflix buy NBC Universal? Um, what what there's a lot there. There's a
  16. lot at those studios. So thoughts. >> So this is why companies conglomerate. The board who decides to see his
  17. compensation hires a firm called Towers Parent- because compensation is the hardest part and one of the most
  18. important things that a board does. And because boards don't want to do any work, they pay this firm, Towers Parent,
  19. $200 or $300,000, and they come in with a survey. And the survey says on a scale
  20. of 0 to 100, 50 being the average compensation, and they look at the industry and the size of the business.
  21. And so if you're running a bank that does 10 billion a year in business and 50% might be three million a year. But
  22. if you're running a bank that does 80 mill 80 billion in business or whatever, then the average compensation is 20
  23. million. So the incentives and also the ego and the also the testosterone and the and the and the penis and the
  24. midlife crisis all lead >> incentives for the CEO to get bigger and bigger and bigger. And sometimes there
  25. are real synergies around different businesses, but almost always not. Typically what happens is you end up
  26. with a Frankenstein. And so the market, it gets to a point where the you have these Frankensteines of businesses that
  27. had no synergy. And what the market >> can I change the metan has a tendency to do is it looks at the
  28. shittiest business because it says there's no synergy here. And it says, "Okay, New York Times, you own 17% of
  29. the Boston Red Sox and the seventh tallest building in America." >> This is previously.
  30. >> This is how much the building is worth. This is how much the Boston Red Sox are
  31. worth. But instead, we're going to look at your shittiest business, your regional newspapers, which traded four
  32. to five times, and we're going to assign that multiple to the entire business because they don't give you any credit
  33. for the for the stuff that's working really well. So the dispositions the disposition of assets becomes accretive
  34. to shareholders and in this case you have a media business that's strong and growing while the connectivity business
  35. is shrinking and what they do is shareholders assign the multiple on the connectivity business to the strong and
  36. growing business. Last quarter the media division get this reported a 40% increase in revenue to nearly 12 billion
  37. for the quarter. Theme parks grew 24%. Media >> grew 61% and studios grew 21% and over
  38. the same business over the same period >> the connectivity division shrunk revenues 3%.
  39. >> So what you have >> connectivity that's not as >> that's right residential connectivity
  40. shrunk about 4% while business connectivity grew 6%. So what happens is if you split these things apart, you
  41. have one company, the connectivity business, which is a mature business that's in structural decline but still
  42. spends off a ton of cash. And then you have a growth business when it becomes a pure play growth business gets a much
  43. higher multiple and the result is a stock that was up 25% based on these two companies.
  44. >> Two companies. So what happens to each of them? Is there like look you have MS
  45. they they split off MS now and now it's trying to create its own little new division and doing well for what it is
  46. right it actually has seen some growth under uh those executives and then you have the media business that has by the
  47. way there's some fine executives at the media part like >> Don Donna Langley it's a very smart
  48. group of people whenever I meet them I'm always so impressed um but they weren't
  49. able to participate in the Warner thing for example and I know it was frustrating because they were actually
  50. the natural owner for that. You know, I was like, >> of all the things I was like, Paramount,
  51. they're a bunch of incompetence. Netflix is going to is too big and going to get
  52. in trouble. Comcast was the perfect buyer for that, you know, in terms of quality people and the theme parks and
  53. everything else. Um, so what what happens here? And the other thing just just for as a sidlight the other two
  54. things. Could Netflix come in and do something here? I think it's too much. Um Disney CFO has signaled they intend
  55. to keep the linear and streaming businesses together for now. They don't they don't own a cable division and not
  56. split it off. So they're keeping those together, the studios and the streaming and everything else. So, is the strategy
  57. seems like it's the same strategy if they're going to hold on to uh NBC, Universal, Film Studio, theme parks, and
  58. Sky, right? So, they're So, that's a little connectivity, I guess. But thoughts on that? What what what happens
  59. to each of these parts? What happens to the cable parts? And then what happens to the I mean could like Elon come in
  60. and buy the cable parts for Starlink or there were rumors of him buying one of the uh the phone service businesses.
  61. >> Well well I mean it's scary but with a $2 trillion market cap there's very little he couldn't buy right now. Um so
  62. Versant their stock is down 21% since the spin-off. I don't know what happens. Okay, first
  63. off, Disney for the time being is holding on to its cable assets. That means they no one's offered the price
  64. they want. It it will make sense for them to shed that business because the parks, the IRL business, the parks is an
  65. unbelievable business. So, this is all a long-winded way of saying I'm not sure what they're going to do, but they have
  66. simplified and created pure plays because here's the bottom line. If you put yourself in the shoes of an
  67. investor, they don't need the Roberts family to diversify for them. CEOs love diversification. Why? Okay, my
  68. connectivity business is down, but my parks were up 24%. In other words, >> right? Yeah,
  69. >> they sleep better at night because they can grow six, eight, 10% a year and not
  70. worry that, oh [ __ ] I got a problem at MSNBC. Whereas, this is the thing though,
  71. investors, I don't need you to diversify for me. I can buy Versant stock if I think it's really cheap. I can buy the
  72. parks business stock if I think it's a grower and I want growth. But CEO's incentive and compensation and quite
  73. frankly wanting to sleep at night and be bigger and better leads to an elomeration or a conglomeration that
  74. eventually the stock market throws up on. And that's what's happened here. And you know what the next really there's a
  75. stock right now that if it broke up it would triple. You know what that company is?
  76. >> What is >> I'll give you a hint. I went to their dinner last Sunday night. >> I don't know. What is it? Maybe you've
  77. mentioned it before. >> I'll give you another hint. The um VR but only Subscale.
  78. >> Oh, Snapchat. >> If Snap spun their spectacles group, the stock would triple or quadruple.
  79. >> Oh, interesting. Yeah, >> that is the most that is the greatest unlock spectacles though.
  80. >> Well, that's the problem. It's a single It's a dual class shareholder and Evan
  81. controls the company. >> Yeah, he loves them spectacles. Do you realize that? I think Meta gets about
  82. $400 in market cap per user. Uh, Snap gets 17. >> Wow. Yeah, you're right. He should get
  83. rid of the spectacles. >> If they spun and did a deal with Shia or something. If they spun the Spectacles
  84. group and it was just a pure play social media platform, rocket ship. >> Get this. Do you know how much the stock
  85. >> I like that idea. >> Do you know how much the stock is off the last 5 years? >> A lot. A lot. Yeah.
  86. >> 93%. >> Yeah. It's crazy. >> 93%. Oh, I like that little >> pure play 500 million people a day
  87. social media network that has the most attractive user base for advertisers in history that is people under the age of
  88. 25 >> is still inventive. >> You get rid of this weeping sore called the spectacles unit that is subscale
  89. >> rocket ship. >> What happens to each of these? So what there's there's Versent obviously um
  90. Warner is his own little nightmare although there's rumors that CNN will get spun off um with Rob Bont and the
  91. California attorney general. But what happens to each of these divisions? >> Well, I think I think the media parks
  92. business has real synergy because if you put out a Harry Potter film, you can have a Harry Potter ride, right?
  93. >> Yeah. Right. Right. Exactly. >> The connectivity business should be indeed. >> Yes, they do indeed.
  94. >> They just get focused. Now, in terms of Versa and the cable assets, those are
  95. declining businesses, but those can be amazing businesses. You go yellow pages, and that was this is the weakest flex in
  96. the world. I was on the board of the world's largest yellow pages company, and all we did was just go around the
  97. world >> and buy other yellow pages companies and basically hold on to the salespeople,
  98. get rid of everybody else and their cash machines. >> And that's what you're going to see. It
  99. doesn't make CN CNN should go into Versant and ABC should sell their [ __ ] They need to consolidate the backend on
  100. these these cable properties and that's what they'll do and they'll still be good businesses. They'll just be in
  101. decline. >> Yeah, that's absolutely right. They could buy they could be the largest uh
  102. small player, right? The like it it'll do well. It'll do well for a long time. >> Well, they're hugely profitable
  103. businesses. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It'll be interesting. I wonder if they'll bring Versant back.
  104. Will they? Why would you Why would you want them? >> No, I don't think so. Again, the story
  105. has to be clean, right? I I mean, Alphabets learned their lesson. They're going to spin Whimo. Whimo is already
  106. spent. I guess it's an independent company. >> Why didn't Sky stay with the cable
  107. business? >> That's a correct question. I don't know. >> That was the one that stuck in my head.
  108. So, it'll be interesting. Yeah, because they do. You're right. Theme Parks, the film studio, NBC. I'm not sure where
  109. that fits in exact. A broadcast network. >> I guess it just Why not? Probably doesn't cost that much. It's a good
  110. >> Comcast and Hurst are the most underrated management teams in media. >> I would agree. They're just very smart
  111. people who consistently do the right thing for shareholders. They're aggressive. They're smart and they're
  112. totally under the radar. Like they they don't want they don't want their their CEOs getting in trouble or making
  113. earnings doing >> they also couldn't play in the Warner thing. I remember I went to the Wicked
  114. premiere and I ran into a bunch of them and they were like, "We are the obvious right owner." I was like, "Oh, I know
  115. but you're not getting it cuz Richie Rich over there and the crazies at Netflix can't you can't beat them,
  116. right? You can't beat either of those companies, but I think this does give them a cleaner shot at buying stuff up.
  117. You know, there's all kinds of things for sale like Lionsgate. There's a man there's all manner of stuff for sale in
  118. Hollywood. So, we'll see what happens. You're going to see a lot of M&A, as Scott Galloway says. Uh, anyway,
  119. interesting move by Brian Roberts, who I really like a lot. I have to say he's a
  120. classy guy. Everyone over there is classy. They're a classy gang. They're very competent.
  121. >> They're from Philadelphia, which means they've killed people. That's all I know.
  122. I'm sorry. Anyone who's anyone any family that is self-made billionaires in Philadelphia, there's definitely people
  123. buried in the foundation of a building of that sky tower. >> You know why I have a good feeling for
  124. Brian Roberts is because I was working for Murdoch and then I went over to Comcast and it was such a pleasure. Let
  125. me just tell you it was I went it was such a different personality. Although Rupert was more fun at a party. Anyway,
  126. let's go on a quick break. When we come back, why Open AI might delay its IPO. We're all tech this week.
  127. >> Support for the show comes from Upwork. A big life hack is finally admitting to
  128. yourself that you need help and that you can't do everything yourself. Thankfully, Upwork makes it easy to
  129. bring in the right freelancer when you need them, so you can stay focused on what you do best. Upwork is a one-stop
  130. platform to find, hire, and pay expert freelancers across web and software development, data, and analytics,
  131. business operations, and more. Upwork also helps grow your business by giving you fast access to specialized talent
  132. across 125 plus categories. So you can fill skill gaps, launch projects faster, and scale support up or down without
  133. committing to full-time headcount. Thousands of growing businesses already trust Upwork to hire flexible,
  134. highquality freelance talent for everything from one-off projects to ongoing support. You can browse
  135. profiles, review past work, and get help scoping the roles so you can hire with confidence and get started quickly. It's
  136. free to sign up, and posting a job is easy. Visit upwork.com/pivot right now and post your job for free.
  137. That's upwork.com/pivot to connect with top talent ready to help your business grow. That's
  138. upw.com/pivot. upwork.com/pivot. >> Scott, we're back. Open is reportedly considering delaying its IPO until next
  139. year. According to the New York Times, the company has been planning to go public as soon as the third or fourth
  140. quarter this year. Valuation appears to be one of the sticking points. Sam Alman
  141. is reportedly holding out for a $1 trillion when they all want this. The company was valued at $850 billion back
  142. in March, 850 billion. There's also some hesitation in light of SpaceX IPO, which
  143. is sort of bumpy, which has been trending downward after the sky-high debut, though it's doing a little better
  144. as we record. News of the possible delay led to a a tech selloff, stock selloff with shares of Oracle, Core Weave, and
  145. Soft Bank all falling. Um, and there's a possibility that Anthropic is breathing
  146. down their neck that they may delay, too. There was some chatter about that. So, is it important for them to wait? As
  147. you talked about, the money is getting sucked out of the system. And their financials leaked a few weeks ago with
  148. losses increasing nearly 8x in 2025 and spending hitting $34 billion. It's not the greatest story in the world. And of
  149. course, they've got Enthropic right in front of them. Not breathing down their neck right in front of them. They're
  150. riding behind it. I think this is not systemic or I think this is uh an individual thing and that is I I believe
  151. the anthropic is still going to get out. This is what I call the great flipping and that is
  152. >> flipping. Is that a word you made up? Is that a vulgar word you made up? >> Flipping. Yeah, there you go.
  153. >> There you go. In the Lincoln bedroom tonight. >> Sound like a sex act, doesn't it?
  154. >> There you go. >> Flipping. What would that be? >> Well, I feel as if I need to use my safe
  155. word right now. >> Mhm. >> Maybe. Anyways, the the great flipping >> I laugh at that every time. You've said
  156. it hundreds of times to me and I laugh every time. Go ahead. >> Um, so Q4 of 2025, OpenAI is the
  157. dominant leader. Right now, Anthropic is the We've never seen Avis overtake Herz
  158. this fast. This isn't even Pepsi overtaking Coke. It's like RCA one morning is the market leader.
  159. >> RCA. >> And I think Anthropic gets out. But I think open AI if they were going to have
  160. to show their wares or open their cupboards there was just going to be evidence everywhere that Anthropic is
  161. eating their lunch. And I talked to a lot of CEOs about AI and the comp a company I'm an investor in section talks
  162. it does all this helps companies upscale around AI. what they're seeing is the following is quote unquote blame the
  163. model and everyone's blaming open AI and swapping them out for anthropic believing they're going to get a much
  164. greater ROI. So I think that basically if when we look back on the great draw down that
  165. will be AI valuations that is I think going to happen in the next 12 months. This will be seen as a real crack that
  166. that it kind of was a signal of what's to come. >> Is it smart to wait? You talked about
  167. the sort of lack of cap. There's not enough money here essentially. >> I don't I I if they could get out, they
  168. would. I I think what I think what this says is the CFO talked to the banker and
  169. the banker said, "Okay, there's no wallpapering over this. Your business has lost a ton of momentum." And then
  170. you combine it with the second thing that is different than Anthropic. Alman has taken the Amazon and Netflix fake it
  171. until you make it, spend more money than anyone else and your stock will go up. He's taken that to an extreme that is
  172. too much and that is if you look at how much money they are burning. I think with the S1's and they would be they
  173. would be side by side immediately. Everyone would be comparing Anthropic and Open AAI's financials against each
  174. other. >> Yeah. >> And I think what you would see is the following. Not only has OpenAI massively
  175. lost momentum against Anthropic, it is also operating much more promiscuously with cash. And that is despite
  176. Anthropic's massive investments and massive losses, it's projecting that it'll break even by 2030. And Sam
  177. Alman's whole thing is, oh no, I'm committing to a trillion dollars in capex because the future there's only
  178. one winner. And I think the market I I think the S1 side by side would show a company that is losing momentum and is
  179. spending way too much money and losing too much money. And I think the bankers have come back and said
  180. >> they don't want the comparison. >> Well, this is what's going to happen in the next 6 months. This is going to be
  181. the great exit from cost. This is going to be the great reduction in spending and capex
  182. commitments by open AI. they are going to massively decrease their expenditure and capex commitments
  183. because I think >> Oracle, it hits a lot of them. It hits all of them, right? >> Still an amazing company. It's still
  184. growing really fast. But the the amount of money they were committing to in terms of capex has gotten out of
  185. control. And then you couple that with a reversal in momentum. I think Goldman and JP Morgan and the CFO have said to
  186. Sam, uh, this is going to be hard. So, so then what do they do if is it is it if Anthropic gets out at over a
  187. trillion, they've got to meet that, right? Speaking of dick measuring contests, they kind of want that number.
  188. Can they actually get out then in 2027? >> Oh, I think I think this is a cost story
  189. and that is I think they're just going to have to reduce their >> clean up. They got to clean it up.
  190. >> Yeah. Because Okay, say they get out at 700 and not a trillion, that's still pretty good. I mean,
  191. >> yeah, >> at some point at some point they're going to need to raise capital in the
  192. public markets, I think. >> Or maybe could they raise in the private markets? The weird thing is I wonder if
  193. TBG and the private equity firms that got a 16 or 17% pick, which is really or guaranteed return, which is really
  194. unusual in the private markets. I wonder if they would still do that deal today because the reversal in fortunes here
  195. has been like nothing I've ever seen in business without a scandal. And so >> weird question, does it get bought?
  196. >> There's so few players that could buy it. I mean, it's a handful of companies
  197. that could afford to buy it. It's one of the big tech companies or SpaceX. That's
  198. it. There's maybe five. >> There was all this online plotting that Elon did sort of bought made sure the
  199. SpaceX IPO was too big and then failed a little bit to stop them. Just so you know, there was a conspiracy.
  200. >> Well, if the next round see rather than do a down round, uh what Altman did was
  201. he he he offered >> he guaranteed it. Yeah, he offered these these terms that typically you don't
  202. agree to, I a guaranteed return because he wanted the headline number to be whatever it was 850 billion or whatever.
  203. >> Yeah. >> But at some point if they start running into a cash crunch, which I don't think
  204. they will. The bottom line, I think the second half of 2026 is about Sam Alman rationalizing the expense side of the
  205. business and their capex uh commitments because it's still growing like crazy. >> Drop it goes out, doesn't delay, goes
  206. out. If I were Dario, I'd want to be like, I'm on top, [ __ ] I'm going public. >> Yeah. Yeah. Right away. Yeah. They've
  207. got to It's a momentum story for them. Absolutely. >> And they have a great story. I think the
  208. S1 is going to look really good for Anthropic. >> Yeah. In comparison. I mean, what's
  209. really interesting is how kind of pissy the open people are about the story Daario gets over and over again. I mean,
  210. he can be imperious himself and, you know, a little bit self-righteous, which is interesting, but uh I think he's got
  211. the better story. He does. And a lot of this is narrative and it actually be good for anthropic for not to have them
  212. there. Although, you know, looking better than open AI is a good thing for them, right? Presumably,
  213. >> this is the CFO and JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs said, uh, you don't want these numbers public right now.
  214. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yep. Absolutely. And by the way, the perception to the ones that did
  215. go public wasn't great. Um, all right. We'll see what happens. Interesting story. very interesting developing
  216. story, but it will impact companies like Oracle and other ones. You saw that draw
  217. just a a small draw down of their shares uh because they have so many commitments
  218. all around the board. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll discuss Pete Buddha Judge
  219. getting targeted. >> Support for the show comes from ODO. There's an endless supply of software
  220. out there that promises to streamline your workflow. That may be true for a specific aspect of your business, but if
  221. you need one app for accounting, one for inventory management, and another for sales, how streamlined can your workflow
  222. actually be if you have to be the middleman between them? ODO says they're the answer you're looking for. The only
  223. business software you'll ever need can be your one-stop shop for CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR,
  224. and more. Plus, it's super customizable and easy to use out of the box. And the best part, they say not only can they
  225. replace multiple applications, but they say they'll do it for a fraction of the cost. Whether you're just starting out
  226. or already well on your way to scaling, ODO wants to help you put the clutter aside so that you can do what you set
  227. out to do when you started your company. Thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you try ODO for free
  228. at odo.com. That's odo.com. >> Uh Scott, we're back. I want to talk about a story that came out over the
  229. weekend about Pete Buddha Judge's family. Buddha Judge says police showed up at his house after an anonymous tip
  230. claimed his four-year-old twins were at risk. CPS investigated the claim and the
  231. Michigan State Police later confirmed the report was completely fabricated. Uh while the incident was being
  232. investigated, Buddha Judge was not allowed to be alone with his four-year-old children for 24 hours, and
  233. they were interviewed by authorities without either parent present. The incident happened during Pride Month,
  234. right after the family posted of Father's Day uh photos online. Uh I was I this was terrifying to someone like
  235. myself. This was like it was just some tip that was called in about another tip of something Pete allegedly. It was all
  236. nonsense from but they had to because their authorities and he's a well-known person. They had to actually investigate
  237. which is their job. I think they felt sick to do it but uh turned out to be all false. Uh it's a it's a version of
  238. swatting but more nefarious >> swarming >> swarming or whatever. uh and you know
  239. he's polling well for the 2028 presidential run. This is just I can't imagine I know I know them pretty well.
  240. I know especially Chaston uh uh you know this is the fear they have as gay parents and something I've discussed
  241. with them. You know this is the fear this is this sort of weird feeling people have about gay parenting that is
  242. just it's I don't even want to call it gay parenting just parenting um but that they get stuck with. Um they are
  243. wonderful parents and these kids are lovely. Uh and for them to have to go through this just sent a chill when I
  244. read his piece and he's not someone who usually is particularly dramatic but he was furious about what happened as he
  245. should have been. Any any thoughts on this? >> I don't think this is a gay thing. I
  246. think this is stochastic terrorism. I I know a couple I know a couple a straight
  247. couple in the Midwest and Child Protective Services showed up at their door one day and said, "We need we're
  248. from Child Protective Services. we need to speak to your children. They had no idea what was going on. Uh, by the way,
  249. the whole neighborhood found out about it. There's no way you recover from that. No, no matter how innocent you are
  250. proven, that's on your Wikipedia page. >> If you're ever on trial for anything, the prosecutor can ask, "Weren't Child
  251. Protective Services called to your house?" And when I go through TSA, I immediately feel guilty. I immediately
  252. like, "Oh, where's that joint in my p? I've done something wrong." when they when you see your suitcase go to the go
  253. to the part of the the the part where they they investigate it, you immediately feel guilty. How does a
  254. four-year-old not remember that strangers who you're supposed to speak to who have the authority to separate
  255. you from your parents start asking these types of questions? How do you not somewhere in your brain think are mommy
  256. and daddy not good people? >> Right? How do you 100% >> how do the parents, the community, their
  257. reputation and the kids >> ever recover from that? >> Yeah. >> Ever. >> I agree.
  258. >> And this is the problem. This is a result of the fetishization and anonymity being linked to
  259. shareholder value. And that is democracy depends upon disagreement but also accountability.
  260. And when the loudest voices face no consequences, the most thoughtful ones log off in
  261. fear. And what happens here is the following. Child protective services, their heart is in the right place.
  262. They're trying to encourage people to to to bubble up real instances of child abuse.
  263. >> Yeah. Because they usually miss a lot of them, right? You know, that's >> that's right. But here's the problem,
  264. and here's what needs to be done. The fix isn't to end anonymity. It's smarter than that. The solution is verified yet
  265. anonymous credentiing and that is online. There should be a digital stamp that proves you are a unique human being
  266. without revealing which human you are. When you call child protective services and as it ended up so the family I was
  267. referencing, you know what it ended up? Two months later they found out one of their daughters was in a beef with
  268. another girl in the same high school. And the girl, the rival girl called. >> Wow.
  269. >> This happens all over. But here's the problem. The family faces no consequence.
  270. So if you call child protective services, we're going to guarantee your anonymity,
  271. but after investigation, if we find out there's no evidence, guess what? >> We're going to investigate you.
  272. >> I agree. I was I was like, who are these people who did this? And you know, swatting is bad. Swatting is dangerous
  273. because there's guns involved like with kids and everything else. And to me, it's so heinous the idea of it. U
  274. swatting is when you call in that there's some terrible thing happening at the house and then you know SWAT teams
  275. come in as they should when cuz they never know, right? And so this is such an abuse of a system that's already
  276. broken, right? It's already a problematic system. They don't catch enough child abuse and sometimes kids
  277. don't get checked on. And you read those stories over and over again. But in this
  278. case, what what sick [ __ ] would think of this thing? Like what sick [ __ ] would
  279. make this stuff up? That to me, and I would like to find them. And you know what I do to them, but I think the
  280. authorities really need to have a system. And the thing is, you don't want to discourage people from telling on
  281. real issues of abuse, right? That's the thing. It's a it's just I I was so upset
  282. by this. But the bigger issue is the following. That same architecture, anonymous, consequence-free,
  283. u infinitely scalable uh online platforms. They let bots flood elections, radicalize millions, and make
  284. public service a target sport. And the bottom line is this is where the right gets it wrong and the left gets it
  285. wrong. The internet doesn't have a speech problem. It has an accountability problem. And our fetishization for free
  286. speech and anonymity has resulted in a total lack of accountability. If you believe the kids across the street are
  287. being abused and child protective services shows up and they find out, oh, you misunderstood the situation, you're
  288. still not liable. You didn't do anything wrong. Your your reasons were valid. But
  289. if it finds out you're just a homophobic [ __ ] weirdo or your your daughter has
  290. had a beef with the other with with another girl in the high school, >> there should be consequences.
  291. >> There's consequences >> there. I think Pete was talking about that. I know they're worried about this
  292. these issues as gay parents as we all are because I was always worried about I've been it's just sticks in the back
  293. of your mind. If it prevents him from running, which is really I hope it doesn't. That's what I hope it doesn't.
  294. I mean, because let me just say, they're wonderful parents. They're wonderful people and they're wonderful parents.
  295. >> Yeah. But what do you say to the kids? And there's these strange people in suits saying, "We need you to go stay."
  296. >> Yeah. The whole thing is >> like, what do you say to your kids? Like a fouryear-old, what do you say to them?
  297. >> I wouldn't even I don't even want to think about it. It was so upsetting. Anyway, uh Pete uh and and Chest, we're
  298. so sorry. This is just this is disgusting and this is not how you behave towards people who are decent,
  299. great parents. And uh whoever did this, I hope they find you and I hope you have
  300. some sort of reckoning. As of this recording, by the way, we're going to move on. House Speaker Mike Johnson says
  301. he's sending the landmark housing bill to the White House days after Trump abruptly canled the signing ceremony for
  302. that bill. Interesting move. The bill, which passed both houses of Congress with overwhelming bipartisan support,
  303. aims to and also would be a win for Trump, aims to bring down housing costs, expand home ownership, and boost
  304. construction. But Trump says he won't sign it into law until Congress passes his Save America Act, which would
  305. require a photo ID to vote and effectively end mail-in voting. By the way, the Supreme Court just upheld a
  306. Mississippi law for late arriving mail-in ballots, a blow to the Trump administration's efforts to queer the
  307. election, which is what they're trying to do. Uh, and the housing bill can still become law even if Trump doesn't
  308. sign it. So, it's technical. If he doesn't sign it, it can become law. if he vetos it, I believe they have the
  309. votes to overcome his veto. So, they're kind of putting him in a position. Uh, under the Constitution, the president
  310. doesn't sign a bill within 10 days, it becomes law without his signature. And again, Congress can override this one.
  311. And so, it was interesting that Johnson did this. He obviously knows it's a good
  312. thing for to have this on the Republican record or at least take credit for it, even though it's kind of bipartisan. Uh,
  313. thoughts on that? Housing is one of the biggest problems in America. Whether it's I was reading this morning that
  314. Finland took an opposite route. Instead of focusing on mental health or veterans
  315. affairs for the homeless, they just focus on housing. They're like, just build cheap housing and get people in
  316. housing. And it ends up that housing is a weird form of birth control that every
  317. 10% increase in housing prices, birth rates go down 1%. It reduces people coupling. It reduces birth rates. It
  318. reduces self-esteem. you know, housing, affordable housing is really important. And what we have here
  319. is again the incumbents once they've owned homes make it more and more difficult for new permits. It's gone way
  320. too far. Uh Congress, to their credit, recognized it. This bill attempts to get rid of NIMI legislation and proposed
  321. Yimi legislation, credits, more credits, more federal sponsorship for communities
  322. that have more housing. This is I actually thought the bill itself when you read it is pretty weak sauce but
  323. it's a very strong symbolic >> movement in the right direction. And in addition,
  324. >> when does the last time Congress voted 358 to 32 on anything, >> right? Right.
  325. >> So this makes all sorts of sense. Trump getting in the way of this was just stupid. And again, it's veto proof. So I
  326. I think this is a win. >> What does he do? What does he do? Sign? He's got to sign it and take credit,
  327. right? >> Yeah, I think so. I I >> He should. But he's going to He's still going to try everything possible. This
  328. Save Act that's not going to pass, President Trump. It's not It's not happening.
  329. >> So why does he keep doing this? >> Oh [ __ ] I I mean, you're asking me to get into this guy's brain. I would have
  330. thought he would, if I were advising him, I would say, "Oh my god, put on >> put on a put put on a tool belt like
  331. you're on a construction site and and run around and take credit for this thing. take credit for
  332. >> housing. This is this is a big big issue for Americans, >> right? You know, instead he's obsessed
  333. with, you know, now he wants to build a golf course and put trees in front of the White House. He's just obsessed with
  334. all these weird obsessive things around the DC area to preserve his legacy, which seems more interest to him. He
  335. went and visited. It was pouring rain yesterday and he was out at Hannes Point where he wants to put in a a golf course
  336. of some sort. Uh there is a golf course there, but he wants to improve it. Um, and then putting maple trees around
  337. Lafayette Square, all this stuff. And then of course touting his really loser, uh, American State Fair, whatever, that
  338. was nobody went to. Um, he just seems all obsessed with that kind of stuff and not something that is, even if it's
  339. symbolically, even symbolically, it's important to to I don't get this. This is this guy. I
  340. think he's terrified that things are going to go very badly after November. And so it seems to he's going to self
  341. soothe with maple trees. >> There you go. Self >> soo. >> Self soo. Right. But he should take
  342. credit for this one and he won't. Um all right, Scott, we'll be uh we're going to
  343. have one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails. Okay, Scott, we're going to do some wins and fails. I think
  344. I shall go first. There were so many failed choices. The grift watch of the Trump mining deal in Kazakhstan with Don
  345. and Eric Stand profit along with uh Lutnik's Lutnik family. Um the what's happening in Venezuela is really
  346. depressing watching them try to find people. So many people have died. But I'm going to be a little personal here.
  347. There's two people who died this week uh who I know very well and were very impactful on my life. One was uh Malik
  348. uh one of the very early tech bloggers. Uh someone who had worked very like me in regular media. Um but then sort of
  349. spun off and started doing a really fascinating kind of bloggy and yet fully reported uh attitude uh attitudinal
  350. stuff back way back in the day an excellent reporter. He also did events. He did parties and I really I got a lot
  351. of inspiration from M who was one of the most jolly fellows. Uh I just really enjoyed we thought a lot about a lot of
  352. things but what an amazing impact he had on early tech journalism when it was a lot more help you know a lot more
  353. hopeful in a lot of ways but he actually did call people on things very early very wonderful guy um he had uh you know
  354. he had shifted to becoming a venture capitalist I didn't go that direction um but just a really wonderful and he's
  355. getting much deserved um praise from all of us who are around then and He struggled with heart issues for a long
  356. long time and uh was uh just a really wonderful guy. The other one was my assistant. I don't have an assistant but
  357. I did for many years. Ed Dailyaly also died. Um another he had also had health problems with around diabetes and
  358. everything else and just a tremendous important part of the growth of my businesses in the beginning of them and
  359. worked for me for a long time was an invaluable help and you know the kind of person you don't hear about. thought he
  360. wasn't a reporter, but did so much stuff to really build the businesses Walt and
  361. I built. Um, and just was a wonderful guy and was wonderful to my kids. Uh, especi Louis and Alex took them on
  362. camping trips with his partner Mark and just just a one one of these hardworking
  363. really wonderful people who who helped so many people and uh just really sad. I'm sorry he Louie just went to see him
  364. recently. So, I'm glad that happened. but really big impact on my life and uh just a tremendously huge-hearted person.
  365. Uh so that is my fail. Um although I I I also my heart goes out the people in Venezuela and everything else. Um and my
  366. win is the Supreme Court just rejected Trump's attempt to get $5 million verdict in the Eene Carol sexual abuse
  367. case toss out. This is the end of the road for him. Now I think he's gonna I just texted Robbie Kaplan. Let me see if
  368. she wrote back. but uh who is the lawyer in the case. Um we'll see where it goes.
  369. Uh on the smaller verdict, he has to pay the 5 million. There is the 80 I think 85 million $80 million verdict that is
  370. still being disputed. Uh but he has to give her the 5 million. Um and which I just kind of love. Uh and now he is very
  371. firmly what he is accused of he did. Um and he can't take it any further. Uh and
  372. we'll see on the second part of which is a defam had defamation related to this case. Um, anyway, good for Eugene Carol
  373. and pay up Donald Trump you for what you did to her. And I just felt that it was
  374. like today is the day that the Supreme Court kicks Trump in the teeth a little bit after giving him a lot of wins on
  375. immigration. Uh, which were that the Haitian particularly the Haitian ruling was really terrible for really
  376. hardworking people in this country. Um, in any case, uh, congratulations to Eugene Carol.
  377. >> Nice. So, uh, okay. So, my fail is uh I can't get over well, you could argue it's a win for uh
  378. broadcast news, but there were two really illuminating interviews uh this weekend. The first was John Carl from
  379. ABC News interviewed Senator Todd Young and uh along with Senator Mark Kelly. >> I saw that.
  380. >> And they talked about how President Trump accused Mark Kelly of sedition. Senator Kelly flew combat missions and
  381. also flew the space shuttle at 20,000 [ __ ] miles an hour. I mean, there are few things more patriotic or than than
  382. the actions of Senator Mark Kelly. And uh and they asked I I appreciate John Carl calling Senator Todd Young out in
  383. front and say how come you didn't do you agree with this? And of course, Senator
  384. Todd Young broke into song about he texted Senator Kelly to make sure he was all
  385. right, but he didn't say a [ __ ] word. >> He didn't. >> And at some point, I'm waiting for
  386. people before they are, you know, lose their primary. At NYU, we have we have a second year,
  387. which is really a waste of money. It's such that we can charge the kids 140,000, not 70. And we teach all these
  388. electives like sustainability and leadership and ethics. Let me save you $7,000 on the leadership course of any
  389. major university. Do the right thing even when it's hard. There you just save $7,000. And we bring
  390. in a formally important person to talk about what a [ __ ] amazing person they are and how the world was against them,
  391. but they did the right thing. And we call it a leadership course. Thank you for your $7,000 in student debt.
  392. There is such a lack of leadership on the most obvious issues. And I don't understand the calculus from a senator
  393. who I believe is a probably a good man and respects his fellow colleague coming out and saying it is wrong to accuse
  394. Senator Kelly, an American hero and patriot of sedition. That is just beyond the line. And in the same time,
  395. um, Ryan Nobles, who was an outstanding standin for Kristen Welker, who I also think is wonderful. on Meet the Press
  396. basically kind of got in the face of Senator Roger Marshall and asked him to site a single example of where voter
  397. fraud has influenced an election. >> He did a great job >> and I thought he I watched it. I'm like
  398. go and and of course this guy just went into blather and and >> doctors need to be trusted by I was like
  399. what in the [ __ ] are you talking about? pilots need to be and it's like but there's no problem here planes crash
  400. there there is no >> no one has ever been able to provide evidence that a single election has been
  401. influenced much less decided by voter fraud >> this guy's been all over the TV the Dr.
  402. Roger from Ganzas, the senator, and he's doing the same song and dance everywhere. I don't know why. Maybe he's
  403. in a tough fight. I don't know. It's weird. He does this a lot. He's just done this a lot.
  404. >> Well, I understand that the only way you can do good is to get elected. But at
  405. some point, they've got to recognize that, you know, this guy is coming is becoming a lame tradan, as you would
  406. say. And at some point, they're going to show something resembling leadership. And I can't I can't swear the calculus
  407. of a senator coming out and saying Senator Kelly is an American hero >> here. Exactly. I don't get it. It's the
  408. same thing when they when Fox News was broadcasting from that American States thing which looks like a like the fire
  409. festival and they're like look at all the people and I'm like there's nobody behind you. Like how do they do that?
  410. Peter Ducey, how did you manage to do that? Oh, everyone's having fun here and there's 26 people there. And it was so
  411. weird. I don't get it. Like when are they going to give? when are they going to give? When do you think they're going
  412. to give on? Same thing with this guy. It's like, you know, don't believe your lion eyes kind of thing. I don't know.
  413. >> Anyways, I guess it's sort of a win for for uh ABC and NBC News. And these these
  414. programs still matter despite the declining audiences. They do are still really relevant. And specifically, it
  415. just strikes me at some point senators who are elected to six-year terms at some point are going to begin to
  416. understand that, >> okay, with the definition of quoteunquote leadership. My my win is
  417. that Bill Maher was awarded the um um >> Mark Twain Award, >> the Mark Twain Award, and I thought it
  418. was really fitting that it was at the Kennedy Center. Uh, but look, I have said this. Something I don't like about
  419. myself is I have been way too influenced by comments in social media, which I think are so [ __ ] corrosive because
  420. they start influencing me to say this type of thing and not this type of thing. And I've tried really hard in the
  421. last couple years to say, "I'm going to say what I mean, mean what I say, and I don't care what the comments are." There
  422. are very few posts that get as much blowback as when I say the following and I mean it. Bill Maher is a hero of mine.
  423. And I think if you were to take every political pundit and have at zero say I don't know who the craziest right-wing
  424. person is and on 100 be the craziest left-wing person. If I had to identify someone who was exactly at 50, it would
  425. be Bill Maher. And evidence that he is a centrist is that everyone appears to hate the guy publicly. And then every
  426. podcast I go on, the hosts when I follow up and say, "Is there anything I can do
  427. to help you?" They ask me, "Can I can I introduce him to someone at Bill Maher?"
  428. >> Oh, interesting. >> The guy has been in the business for 33 years. He is fearless. He is funny. His
  429. contribution isn't defending the idea that people uh who disagree should be allowed in the same room. is that the
  430. weirdest thing is that it's so remarkable. And today that is remarkable. And he he didn't build an
  431. audience by telling people what they wanted to hear. He built one by telling everyone something they didn't want to
  432. hear. He literally pisses off everybody. >> Yeah. Which is why he gets a blow. I
  433. mean, he does he does seek out like his earlier stuff on Islam and stuff like that. So he he is who he is. And I do
  434. I'm always fascinated by how much I get blowback on your behalf, which is interesting. um or why are you on that
  435. show when I go on? I I it's a really interesting discussion and I don't I don't lump him in with all the others
  436. who I do find somewhat heinous in that regard and I agree. I think he deserve that. I think he's very funny. I think
  437. he I don't always agree with him. That's for sure. Um but it really is >> that's the point.
  438. >> Yeah. I I don't find it um I don't know. He attracts an unusual amount of eye. He
  439. really does. >> We'll get push back on this. I when I say he's a role model mine there are few
  440. like when I gradu I was trying to think when I graduated from college when I got
  441. my first bonus check when I sold my first business there are moments in your life you remember professionally
  442. >> one of those biggest moments for me was three or four years ago during co when
  443. Susan Bennett called me and said we'd like you to be on Bill Marcus it's the only show my dad watches
  444. >> Susan's a producer for having >> a producer >> terrific producer >> and I think the guy is is fearless and
  445. he he brings to light the notion that free speech isn't isn't tested by popular opinions. It's tested by the
  446. people who piss you off. And and he does that. And he's an equal opportunity um agitator. And uh he was one of the
  447. last people in television willing to to make both sides equally uncomfortable. I
  448. mean, he's really an independent voice. And I don't think it his contribution will be remembered as changing minds. It
  449. was proving that you can disagree without deciding the other person is evil. and his legacy, although he's a
  450. great comedian, I don't think his legacy is comedy. It's defending the proposition that democracy requires
  451. conversation, not just conviction. And we have lost so much of that. I don't know him. I I sort of know him, but
  452. don't know him well. But the people he surrounds himself with, here's some things about Bill Maher. He has this big
  453. rant on how he doesn't have kids and married. >> Yeah. >> Everyone around him has been working
  454. with him for 20 years. >> Yeah. the woman in makeup, the guy who brings you to your COVID test,
  455. >> his producers. I think he's a very loyal man. >> I think he shows up. I think he works
  456. very hard. I think he's unafraid. I think he's a great role model for people who, like me, want to be centrist,
  457. distinct of the the hate you get because you piss off everybody. I thought he is
  458. an outstanding >> recipient for the Mark Twain Prize. Anyways, my >> I would agree. My win is the unafraid,
  459. courageous uh believer in free speech that pisses off everybody and everybody wants to be
  460. on his show after 33 years. And that is Bill Maher. >> Good for you. Good for you. You do care
  461. about comments, Scott. You're never going to not care about comments. Never. >> Well, I'm addicted to the affirmation of
  462. others here. It's really pathetic. >> It's not pathetic. You're It's not pathetic. You'll give yourself a hard
  463. time. It does get to you. It gets It doesn't get to me as much as it gets to you, but it gets to me, too. I mean, I
  464. think it's uh I think you will it's okay for it to hurt. I have to tell you that
  465. >> shaming is a very popular a very powerful feeling because until about 50 years ago, if you were shamed and
  466. expuned from the tribe, it meant you were going to starve or beaten by a bear in 72 hours or less.
  467. >> Well, you're not going to get eaten by a bear. >> Yeah, I don't think so. >> You're vulgar, but you're not getting
  468. eaten by a bear. But no, I agree with you. I think Bill deserved that award. And I know people, you know, we often
  469. disagree. We really do. Listen, if you don't like Bill Maher, don't watch him. I don't know what else to say. That's my
  470. feeling. It's like that's what I say to people. And by the way, you know, people
  471. in my family, my one of my kids was like, "Why are you going on his show?" And I'm like, "You know what? It's none
  472. of your [ __ ] business." I am cuz I like I like going on it. I enjoy the show. So,
  473. >> I'm going I'm going I'm going on later. I'm going on I think July 29th. I'm going to take my I'm going to take
  474. Bayata and I'm going to take my both my sons and >> I never take them all to anything. And I
  475. said, "This is important to me. I want you to come with me." >> Anyway, uh good ones. Good ones for you.
  476. That was a good one. Um, can I do one more brief fail and I don't want any I just want to say Scott Weiner is a
  477. friend of mine and what happened to him in San Francisco last week was heinous. Like I don't usually mind criticism
  478. around uh of Israel and I think it's really important for and I don't think every criticism in Israel is
  479. anti-semitic but what happened to him and he has been a supporter of all manner of things in San Francisco he's
  480. was anti-semitic was really truly and strange and that kind of that really shouldn't I feel terrible for Scott for
  481. because he's been you know there's lots of things you could disagree has got on but not what they were yelling at him
  482. about. And so it had a real tinge of real hatred. And I that is a real that really repulsed me in a way that I
  483. usually am okay with some critic with criticism of all manner of countries and stuff like that. And so just that cannot
  484. be tolerated by the Democrats. That cannot be tolerated that kind of behavior. So I would just want to say
  485. that but I feel bad for Scott who's been a really um hardworking public servant.
  486. Anyway, um, all right. So, that's the show. Um, congratulations to Bill Maher. We want to hear from you. Send us your
  487. questions about business, tech, or whatever is on your mind. Go to nymag.com/pivot
  488. to submit a question for the show or call 855-51 pivot. Elsewhere in the Karen Scott
  489. universe, this week on I just spoke to Jim Bankov, the CEO of Vox Media, and Meredith uh Copit Levian, president and
  490. CEO of the New York Times at K Lions, uh, which was really fun. We talked about the ways they adapted to a
  491. changing media landscape and the effects of AI on publishing and it was a great session and thanks to UTA for hosting us
  492. uh and keeping it quiet. Let's listen to a clip. The leverage is even the LLMs will need an information ecosystem with
  493. high quality independently produced verified information. If they don't have it their products will not ultimately be
  494. good either. We all want to live in a society where quality information is available and I believe they do too and
  495. I think that's leverage. >> I believe they do too. >> I think that they the they're these are
  496. information companies. These are information tools and I think information at a certain point for you
  497. to have a healthy functioning democracy you have to have high quality information and people have to be able
  498. to identify the difference. This was a really good uh discussion and we had a little testiness around some a couple of
  499. things but uh they it was great. It was a really interesting discussion about media and where it's going and Meredith
  500. both Scott and I have huge regard for her and that Jim Bankoff guy is nice too. Um
  501. >> so you want a little known fact about the CEO of New York Times. >> No, let me tell.
  502. >> He's got a dreamy boyfriend. He's a tall drink of lemonade. Have you met him?
  503. >> Yes, I have. >> I went up to her and I'm like that dude's so handsome. And she looked
  504. around and she's like I know. He's like literally like I I'll take my masculinity to go. Jesus Christ.
  505. >> She's I I love everything about Meredith. I think she's a great uh executive. She's a great parent. Um
  506. >> she's really she's she's all that in a bag of chips, as they say. So, so lucky
  507. for him to have her. Okay. Uh that's the show. Thanks for listening to Pivot and
  508. be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel. We'll be back on Friday.

Brief Summary

Comcast spins off NBC Universal, OpenAI delays IPO, and Pete Buttigieg faces a false investigation into his family.

Key points

  • Comcast Spins Off NBC Universal. Comcast is spinning off NBC Universal and Sky into a separate publicly traded company, raising questions about the future of its broadband business.
  • OpenAI's IPO Delay. OpenAI is reportedly considering delaying its IPO until next year due to valuation concerns and market conditions.
  • Pete Buddha Judge's Family Targeted. Police investigated a false report claiming his children were at risk, causing distress.
  • Housing Bill Moves Forward. House Speaker Mike Johnson sends a housing bill to the White House, despite Trump's opposition.
  • Supreme Court Rejects Trump's Appeal. The Supreme Court rejected Trump's attempt to overturn a $5 million verdict in the E. Jean Carroll case, marking a significant legal defeat for him.
  • Bill Maher Receives Mark Twain Award. Bill Maher was awarded the Mark Twain Award at the Kennedy Center, celebrating his fearless contributions to free speech.

Tension

65/ 100Some tension

Related episodes