Is Apple's Budget Laptop Brand Suicide? | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara and Scott are live at SXSW! They discuss billionaires' unprecedented influence in recent elections, and the reality of wealth taxes. Then, Apple introduces a budget MacBook — smart market expansion or a risky move for a luxury brand? Plus, Pete Hegseth calls CNN "fake news" and cheers on the Paramount-Warner Bros. deal, and Polymarket's AI deal.

00:00 Intro 5:26 Billionaires and Taxes 18:29 March Madness and Betting Markets 25:07 Trump Administration’s “Fake News” Complaints 34:56 Apple’s Affordable Era 42:55 Wins and Fails 50:04 Q&A

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin

Video Producer: Rich Shibley

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Support for this show comes from ODU. Running a business takes everything you've got, and a lot of the tools out
  2. there that are supposed to make your life easier just aren't great at talking to each other. And that means you end up
  3. having to toggle between a dozen different apps and services just to keep the lights on. Enough of that. Now
  4. there's ODO, the all-in-one fully integrated platform that actually might help you get it all done. Thousands of
  5. businesses have made the switch, so why not you? Try ODO for free at odo.com. That's odd.com.
  6. >> Why not just remove the broadcast networks from those rules? Why are they I I'm some like they shouldn't be bound
  7. by that [ __ ] Brandon Carr who's clearly looking for his next job which will be
  8. Dancing with the Nazis. >> Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast
  9. Network. I'm Cara Swisser. >> And I'm Scott Galloway. >> And we are live from South by Southwest
  10. in Texas. >> So before we before we get to it, um again I we're psyched to be here uh this
  11. live episode. We want to thank our presenting sponsor ODU. They've supported they sponsored our pivot tour
  12. last year. So they're really into us. Um we will get to everything else, but Scott, I have a surprise for you. I
  13. don't know if you know this, but I have a television show coming up on CNN. >> Really?
  14. >> Yes. >> I heard it's a horror film called Cara's Going to Live Forever. >> Yes. So, I'm going to play a little
  15. clipboard cuz someone that I work with is in the show itself. Cuz largely I felt sorry because he's had so many
  16. disasters in television. I thought he should be part of a hit series. >> Zero for five. Five TV series. I haven't
  17. seen any of them, have you? >> Yeah. All right, let's go. This is going to be a huge hit and it's going to
  18. really chap his ass. So, go ahead. >> Wow. >> Wow. >> Doesn't this land in the backyard of a
  19. Colorado household owned by a woman named Mindy? >> Mor. Mor and Mindy. >> It's a state-of-the-art sound therapy
  20. pod that is using sound playing in your body. So, there's a lot of science-based
  21. frequencies designed to calm your nervous system at a cellular level. We typically call it an inner and out of
  22. body experience. You know those moments where you suddenly have to ask yourself,
  23. "How did I end up here?" >> This feels like the lamest crypt in the world, and I'm stuck with Cara.
  24. >> Well, Emily Ratikowski was busy. >> This was one of those. I was deep inside a concrete basement in New York City
  25. about to embark on an auditory journey that is designed to help my body repair, restore, and transform itself.
  26. >> We're going to take you on a beautiful sound journey. >> Sound journey, Scott.
  27. >> All right. My traveling companion was my good friend and podcast partner Scott
  28. Galloway. >> I just had a deep insight. Cara, this longevity trend. >> Hasn't the earth suffered enough?
  29. Shouldn't we just die? Um, anyway, it's coming uh April 11th, but the the plot spoiler there is Scott
  30. falls asleep in it and has no journey. He just snores. Um, and there is no real science to that.
  31. So, just among other things we prove, but we had a nice time. >> Yeah. And that's definitely going to
  32. save CNN. >> Yeah. Oh, well, I won't be there when the Ellison's take over, so that's fine with
  33. me. Um, anyway, uh, we've got a lot to get to. Well, first of all, you having a good time here? Are you enjoying it?
  34. >> I'm having a great time. I went out last night. I'm so sick of rolling up to the
  35. the parties now kind of suck cuz you meet some guy and you're like, I want to grab a drink and he's like, I'm 8 years
  36. sober and now I'm a Pelaton influencer. [ __ ] you. I want to find the guy who's in a
  37. custody battle so he can never see his kids. That dude I'll roll with. Anything? No,
  38. >> I'm having a nice time. >> You're having a nice time. >> Everyone is working on their sleep.
  39. Well, good for you. >> So, uh, you're leaving. You're going to the Van Fair Oscar party. That should be
  40. fun. >> Hello. >> Yeah, that should be good. I'm not going. I'm staying. >> I was the plus one. And the plus one
  41. RSVPd yes. And Cara said no. >> So, you'll have a good time. Try not to bother the celebrities. That's my only
  42. advice. Just be cool. Okay. Can you do that? >> Thank you for that. That's hugely
  43. helpful. Thank you. Just be cool for me. >> Is there anyone you want to meet? Is
  44. there like Sean? He probably won't be there. He's >> I want to meet simple. I want to meet
  45. the um >> I was going to say the gay hockey guys. What's it called? >> Heated rivalry.
  46. >> Heated rivalry. I'm sorry. I'm just announcing now executive producer season 2 heated rivalry.
  47. Swedish women's team. Biggest show of next season. Biggest show of next season. >> Oh god. I'm going to go for two here.
  48. >> I'm I'm going to alert security at the Vanity Fair Oscar party for this. But anyway, just be cool. Say nice things.
  49. They You'll probably get recognized by some of them. It'll be nice. >> I'll be at the bar. That's all.
  50. >> All right. Excellent. All right. We've got a lot to get to today. We've got a
  51. lot to talk about. There's so much. It's crazy amounts of news all the time and every every moment. But, uh, first
  52. thing, surprise, surprise. Wealthy people are swaying elections with their money. billionaires made up about 19% of
  53. all reported campaign donations of 2024 federal elections. This is a a well it's
  54. a quantum leap in numbers. Within the 19% for every dollar that went to Democrats, $5 went to Republicans. The
  55. billionaire families gave an average total of $10 million each, roughly equal to the amount a h 100,000 typical donors
  56. give combined. Um Scott, before Citizens United, the share of billionaire spending was under 1%. This is 19%.
  57. That's an enormous amount of people, enormous number for a small amount of people. Let's talk a little bit about
  58. that because obviously billionaires taxes are being discussed. Um there's all there's all manner of things
  59. happening here, but their influence is absolutely clear. >> Yeah. I mean, if you think about 19%
  60. from 900 people, it's um look, it's the boring stuff that kind of moves the needle that that's not that interesting
  61. to talk about. But we're gonna wash, rinse, and repeat a cycle of autocrats. Uh I actually believe there's uh if you
  62. look at history, there's as much danger of an autocrat coming from the far left as from the far right. I believe the far
  63. left is as dangerous as the far right. It's the extremes that present a threat to society. And the two things that are
  64. probably most important to avoiding a strong man or a strong woman uh from either side of the party are very boring
  65. things. But until we have them, we're going to have the weaponization of a decline in the structural and economic
  66. standing in my opinion of of middle class, especially middle class males who tend to be unfortunately more violent
  67. and upset when they don't have economic or romantic prospect. But the two major reforms that need to happen or we're
  68. going to have a cycle of strong men and strong women for the next 50 years is one, we need to dej gerrymander the US
  69. because the the general election no longer matters. It's the primary. And who turns out in the primary? The
  70. crazies. So every district now is hard blue or hard left. And we keep sending um 535
  71. very far-left or very far-right people who share no comety, no no collective values, don't want to work together, and
  72. nothing happens and they genuinely don't like each other. And the the narrative from our leadership is not
  73. how do we work together and get something done. It's that the other guys are wrong. And so it creates a level of
  74. division and stasis that's really unproductive. And then the other thing is Citizens United. We can't have a
  75. small group of people who aren't evil, but incrementally will say, "Hey, Charles Schumer," and I'll use a
  76. Democrat as an example because we always talk about Republicans. Democrats take a
  77. lot of money, too. It's Republican it's it's Republican donors typically, but also Democrats do do bask in a lot of
  78. the pack money. And what happens is Republicans are much more overt about trying to get tax cuts for who they
  79. think are the most productive people and corporations in the world. What Democrats do is just ring their hands
  80. and kill stuff in committee and say they have concerns about things. But if you have until we have Citizens United
  81. overturned and dejerrymander, we're just going to ping from the far left to the far right for the foreseeable future. it
  82. I I do think the Republicans are sort of doing things in plain sight in a in an effective way by channeling all this
  83. money, right? And but the number from going from 1% to 19%, it's a very and you're right, it's a very small amount
  84. of people. And actually, it's a small amount of people from Silicon Valley. So, it's a very particular I mean,
  85. there's there's the Ulanes, the box people, there's a bunch of other rich people you don't know as well. And by
  86. the way, look on your bottom of your boxes. That's what you're getting from Amazon is from this very far-right
  87. family. Um, but one of the things that's the problem here is that that this stuff
  88. is done in plain sight. And what's they're not going to under overturn Citizens United from what I understand.
  89. I interviewed Larry Leig recently who has another case that could hollow out Citizens United in terms of super PACs
  90. and dark money. >> Um, but what is the solution until then? Because I don't think they're letting
  91. up. I don't I think they won't let up in this presidential election. It doesn't seem like all of a sudden Elon Musk is
  92. gonna call start calling himself they them. It's not happening for us. So what what could be done in the interim
  93. because he will continue to spend. He's sort of the the poster child for this. But then you quietly have a whole bunch
  94. of them doing the same thing. >> The honest answer is I don't know. I don't know if there's a way to prohibit
  95. certain political spending across certain more targeted media. Mhm. >> Um, so I have a movement called Resist
  96. and Unsubscribe and neither Alphabet nor Meta would take my dollars to drive traffic, but if you want to, you know,
  97. promote Cole and get in the way of the earned child tax credit, spend away. So I also I think there might be some
  98. workarounds that people have talked about by going state by state. >> Mhm. >> But until
  99. I I think until unless it's overturned, which I agree with you, it doesn't look >> this is all a word salad of saying I
  100. don't know. >> Yeah. So when you think about we've talked a lot about the billionaire tax.
  101. Um, you have proposed other things like an AMT tax and there's some things in committee right now, speaking of
  102. Democrats, which seem much more effective, which is giving tax relief to people under a certain number. Um, and
  103. then at the same time making the group of people taxed larger. >> Well, there's three different tax
  104. proposals. So the Democrats, to our credit, have finally wised up and realized that they need to move from
  105. their objective of redistributing virtue, telling other people they're not as worthy, constantly talking through
  106. identity politics about what's right and what's wrong with the world. And if you
  107. tell billionaires they're evil and white people they're racist, and young men that they're predators, they'll leave
  108. the party. I'm like, "Okay, this part is not for me." And if you look at those three groups, they have largely
  109. abandoned the Democratic party. So what they realize is that the key to 26 and 28 is to talk less about redistributing
  110. virtue and redistributing income. And also that the best narrative for redistributing income is tax cuts, not
  111. not handouts. Now the three there's the Conor proposal, there's the Booker proposal, and then there's the Warren
  112. um proposal. Warren is basically class warfare. It's a 5% tax, wealth tax every year. That may not sound like a lot, but
  113. the majority of people don't have 5% liquid taxes sitting around. I can't imagine the hundreds of thousands of
  114. people who would be hired to try and diminish or decrease or lower the value assessed value of billionaires wealth.
  115. It goes after basically 900 people. Actually, that's not true. People over a billion, it's 5%. But to tell
  116. billionaires they have to come up with 5% of their wealth every year, I do think that that's the tipping point
  117. where you would lose somewhere between a quarter at least from a residency standpoint to a third of billionaires in
  118. the US. The example is the non-dom tax in the United uh in the United Kingdom. It was theoretically it made all the
  119. sense in the world. It's like you've been here for a while, you should pay UK taxes. The tax receipts this year are
  120. going to be lower because 10,000 millionaires have moved away in the last year and people have this populist
  121. [ __ ] of let them go. Well, okay, who's going to pay for the NHS? So, the wealth tax doesn't work. The wealthy are
  122. the most mobile people in the world. They have homes all over the world. They can have really nice lives in Milan or
  123. in London. So, if you're looking to actually be effective, not, you know, not just right, the wealth tax doesn't
  124. work. Rose is more about social services and and corpor corporate taxes, expanded
  125. child tax c tax credit. The one I like the most is Bookers. His he's saying, okay, it's the first 75,000. It's
  126. taxfree. Right now, what people don't realize is that first off, the myth that wealthy don't pay their taxes. The top
  127. 1% paid 19% in 1980. Now they pay 42%. It's the 0.1% that are getting away quite frankly with murder that can use
  128. all sorts of tricks to lower their tax rate into the high teens. But the 1% the workh horses mom's a baller at a law
  129. firm. She's a partner making a million half 2 million bucks. Dad owns three chiropractic clinics. He's making 800
  130. grand. They make 2.3 2.8 million. They probably live in a blue state in a blue city. They're paying 48 or 52% uh
  131. marginal tax rate. So the whole notion of tax the rich doesn't go very far. What I think what Booker is saying is
  132. essentially if you go the first 70 the first 29,000 pay almost no pay no federal taxes right now. He's saying be
  133. at the first 75,000. Now, the devil in the details is that even though it sounds like, oh, that benefits people
  134. who make up to 75,000 the most, it actually benefits people who make 150,000 the most because they get to
  135. apply that free 79 in the lower tax rate on a larger base. It's a good idea. It's
  136. time that we level up the middle class. So, I like that. And it's it's a little bit more elegant. Whenever you send
  137. money to Washington as opposed to lowering taxes, there's some inefficiency and friction in Washington.
  138. So, I think it's a good idea, but I think there are more elegant ways to raise tax revenue. Um, lower basically
  139. do away with or lower the estate tax, the uh the exemption on money that's inherited from 30 million to 1 million.
  140. We're creating dynastic wealth. And the key is to have taxes that are least taxing. If your kids inherit 11 million
  141. instead of 14 million, you're obviously no less happier because you're not around to see it. and the kid isn't any
  142. any less happier if he gets 11 million or she gets 11 million versus 14 million. The other thing we need is uh
  143. AMT and that is if you make over say a million bucks or you're a corporation that makes over 10 million bucks use the
  144. 4,000 pages of loopholes to skirt it down skirt it down 1202 depreciation but if you're not paying at least 40%
  145. there's an AMT. So, an alternative minimum tax and then um triple the budget of the IRS because the biggest
  146. tax cut in history that we don't talk about is that the Trump administration has essentially neutered uh the IRS. So,
  147. crime's going to go up when there's no cops on the beat. Supposedly, $750 billion a year is called the tax gap,
  148. which is uncollected taxes that are owed. So, get rid of the estate tax exemption, alternative minimum tax of
  149. 40%. support the IRS >> and support the IRS as opposed to what feels a little bit like class warfare.
  150. >> That's an interesting thing. I don't think it works very well because people are aspirational. That said, the the
  151. tech people especially who are the wealthiest um have not really slathered themselves in glory in terms of people
  152. we I mean they the brand has gone down. And so I think people don't when when Jeff Bezos rents Venice or uh or or Alex
  153. Karp talks about disenfranchising white Democratic women. I think that's what he was sort of saying in his
  154. statements the other day. Um it it feels like let's get them like they're they're
  155. sort of they're they're creating an anger toward them that uh that I think is unnecessary and unproductive and at
  156. the same time you sort of want to take all their you know leave them naked without clothes. Um, not well I don't
  157. want to see them naked. That's not true. Um, but it's a real it's a real conundrum and I do think one of the
  158. things that has to happen is there's got to be some neutering of Citizens United
  159. in that regard because I think it's very clear what the trends have been. On a middle metal level, the biggest tax cut
  160. would be having the stones to go after entitlements because we spent $7 trillion on $5 trillion in receipts.
  161. And every time we do that, in order to keep the government pumped up and going, and the asset prices, the assets which
  162. you and I own, keep them elevated, we issue more debt. So the biggest tax cut in history would be fiscal
  163. responsibility. And it's a tax cut on your kids in the future who are going to have absolutely no money in the
  164. government to invest in education or technology. And if you really want to get serious about quote unquote taxing
  165. future generations, some Democrat is going to have to be the adult in the room and say that if you make over a
  166. million dollars a year as a senior citizen, you're not getting social security. And we need to move back the
  167. age and we need to means test it and we need to distribute GLP1 and bring down health care costs. But if we're serious
  168. about lowering taxes on future generations, we can have populist ideas. But what we need to do, quite frankly,
  169. is just have more of a fiscal responsibility because the deficit every day is a $2 trillion tax on future
  170. generations because someone's going to have to pay the ship back. >> Well, that may be true, but it's the
  171. Trump administration who's brought up the deficit more than any other of any of the
  172. >> we that's been a bipartisan thing. >> Certainly, but Trump is >> 7 trillion George B George Washington to
  173. George Bush, 30 trillion since George Bush. But Trump's been the worst. >> Been the worst. So, um, we're going to
  174. move on to March Madness. Kicks off this week. The the and sports books are expecting to take in $4.5 billion in
  175. bets on the NCA college basketball tournaments. Now, only 11% of that will come from the prediction markets this
  176. year, which is a large amount, but that's a perfect time for Poly Market to announce that it's bringing in Palunteer
  177. and uh TWWG AI to monitor sports contracts and flag anything suspicious. Reminder, Poly Market is backed by Peter
  178. Teal and 1789 Capital, which is uh Donald Trump Jr.'s fund in AI system monitoring predictions markets. It seems
  179. like that's the fox guarding the hen house. >> But is it meant to is it meant to so in
  180. the MAMI race, what was strange when you see billboards everywhere saying that mom dami chance of winning 91%.
  181. If you're voting for Cuomo or some other candidate, I I supported a guy named, you know, Whitney Tilson. I'm not a New
  182. York resident, but my friend Whitney ran. Anyways, you don't show up or you think, "Oh, great." You get excited. So,
  183. these prediction markets actually the polls have the polls have an influence on the actual voting. I think AI in
  184. terms of monitoring, I like the idea. I I've always felt that AI could be used for defensive measures as much as
  185. offensive measures. whether or not Peter Teal has other objectives that's a little bit scarier.
  186. >> Maybe he does. >> So that you're right. It's not AI as a defense mechanism or for compliance.
  187. It's the fact that Peter Teal who believes in in >> no democracy I believe is his
  188. >> Yeah. Feels like democracy is an outdated mode. So but just in terms of gambling huge threat to young men and
  189. what people don't know about gambling as an addiction is that it's got the highest suicide rate of any addiction.
  190. Because if you have a meth addiction, people people notice it and they weigh in. You can spend your kids' college
  191. fund, mortgage your house, spend everything, and people have no idea. And often times people feel like it's it's
  192. it's just too late. And when in states where they legalize gambling, bankruptcies skyrocket 35% in that same
  193. year. I was just in Vegas. Vegas is dying because why be in Vegas when Vegas is in your pocket? And I I'm curious
  194. what you think cuz you have sons. I have sons. >> They don't gamble. >> Yeah, but you're a better parent than
  195. me. So, >> yes. Yeah. >> The But the question is, speaking theoretically as a parent,
  196. >> I don't think they gamble. >> For young men, do we infantilize them? Do we have more regulation? Is it a
  197. lifeless? >> You know, I think young men do have a a higher risk profile. I mean, just
  198. between my my daughter, it's more comparable. uh my daughter who's six and my son who's four, he's so risk I mean
  199. penis out every moment of the day like and it's you're always like wow those that's gonna hurt when you get to the
  200. bottom of those stairs on your head like and my daughter is very careful so it's
  201. a really it I hate to say that because I don't like to play into gender tropes but it's true it just is um but
  202. >> trope away we're different and that's okay >> she happens to be I was very risktaky
  203. when I was a kid Um, I I'm I'm with you, aren't I? Hello. Um, and someone's like, "What's your biggest
  204. risk?" I go, "That any moment it will be over with Scott." Like, which which it never happens. It's like a really
  205. exciting series that ends on a cliffhanger every every episode. Um, but one of the things that I think about
  206. with gambling is I I my sons don't gamble, which is interesting, and I kind of like gambling better than they do,
  207. which is interesting. But um I think the fact that it's you're right AI should be
  208. used in positive ways and we should mitigate the negative ways. But again, a lot of this is controlled by people with
  209. self-interest that you never understand. And so what are they um and earlier today I did an interview with the cast
  210. of the Audacity which talks about these issues. It's a new Silicon Valley show >> and the idea of the manipulation of our
  211. information for in all manner of way I think we do not understand where it's about to go and so who owns it and who's
  212. running it. Same thing with media. Where are the interests is going to be a huge
  213. problem going forward. >> But your point is your point is the right one in what you just said and that
  214. is AI should be applied to monitoring and compliance. It should just be an AI that reports to a federal agency that's
  215. trying to prevent a tragedy that comments, not to Peter Thiel. >> But keep I mean it's this is a difficult
  216. one because I think a lot about young men and between 24 by7 porn and gambling and an economy that's basically linked
  217. to dopa hits trying to evolve a new species of asocial asexual males. I believe that our economy now is
  218. essentially tied to evolving this new species of male that is basically a shitty citizen who starts blaming
  219. immigrants, prone to conspiracy theory, prone to misogyny, prone to obesity, depression, anxiety, never develops the
  220. skills outside of their house. Males aged 20 to 30 are now spending less time outdoors than prison inmates. And
  221. unfortunately, they're up against this indomitable foe of an AIdriven platforms that at the exact right moment will
  222. convince you, hey, don't go to class, bet on the Jets game. Or, hey, you know, you can get rich and screenshots of
  223. people trading crypto and why go through the effort, perseverance, cost, showering, resilience, developing a rap.
  224. You know what movement I'm going to go off script here. You know what movement I [ __ ] hate? What
  225. >> I think the worst movement in America right now besides some of the farright crazy [ __ ] is the incel movement
  226. and involuntarily celibate and I speak to a lot of young men and some of them identify as being incelss and they say
  227. it as a point of pride like they they have found their community and that it's not their fault and they just come out
  228. and say I'm an incel and they give up. 62% of men under the age of 30 aren't even trying to date. 42% of men 18 to 22
  229. have never asked a woman out in person. And this movement infuriates me cuz just
  230. just a heads up, a spoiler alert. For 99% of history, 99% of men have been involuntarily celibate. And the notion
  231. that somehow this is a movement. Well, welcome to the [ __ ] work week. Level up, [ __ ] It's been hard for all of us.
  232. >> You know what? Um, I I feel like there's a book in there. Um, anyway, um, speaking of someone I wish was
  233. incelibate, um, in case anyone's wondering where the defense secretary Pete Hess
  234. stood, oh my god, stood on the Paramount uh, Warner deal. Uh, we know now. uh at a
  235. briefing on Friday, Hegathth, who's a [ __ ] called uh that's just I mean it's factual. Um called a CNN report on the
  236. war in Iran fake news and said the sooner David Ellison takes over the network the better. Um, also Brandon
  237. Carr, Morren number two, oddly enough, not even as smart as Pete Heg, which is an awfully low bar, is threatening
  238. networks because he doesn't like their coverage of the war and is calling it fake news. It's astonishing that the
  239. head of the FCC says these things. It's actually illegal what he's saying. Um, and he's threatening the broadcast
  240. licenses of networks who do not comply with the correct news. Um, Teamsters are also, by the way, urging the DOJ to
  241. block the deal unless Paramount agrees to protect jobs and increase US production. talk talk about this because
  242. they like you'd think they'd be on their back foot at this point, but they're doubling down on lack of con well just
  243. everything terrible. But this was sort of astonishing to hear from him and then followed by the FCC chairman around a
  244. deal where obviously the the Ellison's licked Trump up and down like it wasn't even I mean they did
  245. >> um they didn't even pretend this is not what they were doing. They made promise
  246. they're making they apparently made promises well reported about CNN uh and and what they're going to do there. What
  247. talk a little bit about this and where you >> him saying the the loud part out loud I
  248. guess. >> Well, it's not only wrong but it's stupid because it creates but it creates
  249. legal. It's exhibit A in a case trying to block this to say it's an unfair merger and that it's not based on market
  250. dynamics. is based on government interference which it's not supposed to. I'm not as worried and I mean you're the
  251. journalist here but >> I am worried >> I am not as worried about suppression of speech because what I see as alternative
  252. media niche media thriving despite these threats and it only brings oxygen >> you know bull work and you know puck
  253. they'll have their biggest days today being outraged about this on YouTube >> so I don't think I I don't think that as
  254. much as these folks would like I still think the courts will hold around first amendment. But what it indicates in my
  255. opinion is something more dangerous and that is we generally decide we have regulated competition and if we have
  256. regulation it applies to everybody and that everybody gets to play by the same rules. And when the president starts
  257. deciding I know how to run a steel company, which microchip companies we should invest in and who's saying the
  258. right speech and who isn't, it reflects I just think I think we're just going to
  259. get and I've said this before, we're going to get poorer. our earnings rate at the highest price earning multiple
  260. because of systemic laws where you don't get on the wrong list and get the wrong
  261. call. I'm not as worried about I mean it's just so nakedly anti-first amendment but I think it'll be slapped
  262. down in court. >> Yeah. But the the the tactics they use is they create a problem and they get
  263. slapped down in court like they just did with Jerome Powell with box of you know
  264. prosecutor box of wine. Uh Janine per whatever box of wine lady watches strong on her perfect. um you know, they do the
  265. thing, create the damage, cause a chilling effect, and then move on when they lose in court, right? Or they get
  266. pushed back, and then they're outraged about losing in court, and then attack the courts. I mean, it just goes, it
  267. does cause actual damage to people. And not just outrage, it's not just, I can't
  268. believe they said that. I totally believe they said it. I I I don't I don't find it outrageous. I just find it
  269. astonishing that they they do it in order to create the kind of crisis that will occupy people until they're slapped
  270. back. And by the time they're slapped back, it's too late. the the tension, the fear is that it creates a chill and
  271. people think twice before writing an article about the Trump administration and are more promiscuous writing
  272. articles truthtelling about Democrats and Republicans, >> we start having a chill around speaking
  273. openly around Republicans. My sense is that if you look at Kimmel, Cole Bear is that quite frankly it's only emboldened
  274. um uh journalists and institutions uh to write and also I don't know if the chill is working and I think it's giving
  275. rise to a new set of media players who can honestly say we're about truth to power and we're unafraid and that
  276. there's a market for it. >> Well well why not just remove the broadcast networks from those rules? Why
  277. are they I I'm like they shouldn't be bound by that [ __ ] branding car who's clearly looking for his next job which
  278. will be dancing with the Nazis. But anyway, >> it's wrong. I guess the question is we
  279. always talk about the difference between being right and being effective. >> They're wrong and my sense is so far
  280. they've been ineffective. I think the best thing to happen to Co Bear and Kimmel the ratings exploded when the FCC
  281. threatened >> threatened them. So my sense is the autoimmune response of Americans who
  282. value free speech is kicking in here and it's working really well >> perhaps. But at the end of the day, the
  283. Ellison's own will own this and then we'll have say over it and we'll quietly do you know smother people possibly. I
  284. don't even know if they will. Honestly, I don't I don't care to stick around and
  285. find out. But one of the things is that you create a situation where where you don't trust your your owners, right? You
  286. don't I mean when I worked at the Washington Post I mean it was there's it was a different environment for media
  287. and everything else but I completely trusted the grams. I got, you know, I didn't feel like they would toss me over
  288. under a Bezos thing. Abs and I know he was just there this week talking to some of the reporters and was answering
  289. questions which he should. >> Um I I can't I have no idea what they do and in fact probably opt to go to Mara
  290. Lago over protecting something he bought. >> Look, you you're going to forget more
  291. about journalism than I'm going to know. So I'm going to defer to you, but what I
  292. see happening is the following. They make these ridiculous, ownorous, fascist, autocratic statements trying to
  293. control the press and trying to put a chill around free speech. I feel like that attempt to chill free speech is
  294. backfiring. I also don't have any nostalgia or think that we've talked about this. I don't think the CNN I
  295. think CNN and the Washington Post can go away and it's not going to mean anything. I I just don't I I I think
  296. that these folks quite frankly many of them I think Freed Sakaria starts a podcast and a newsletter and has the
  297. same reach with a lower cost of production. I think these incredible journalists go to different places start
  298. alternative media that quite frankly is maybe more effective. So I think that you're going to see a dispersion of
  299. truth to power and journalism. The key is as long as the courts at the end of the day support those people and fall in
  300. the light of first amendment. But I think what happens a lot of times when we talk about this is that journalists
  301. and these organizations see themselves as iconic and very precious. What's precious is first amendment protection
  302. to speak truth to power. And what I see is that every person who's laid off from
  303. the Washington Post or CNN who has any talent now finds incredible platforms and outlets and subscribers. I just
  304. launched on Substack and it's so much fun. you see subscribers and you can make good money. You know, a lot of
  305. people who've left big institutions and are doing well now. >> So, I I feel like the attempt to chill
  306. is like when they when they hit CNN, it breaks into a hundred different alternative niche media companies.
  307. >> The only issue with that is covering a war costs money. Covering you have to have a larger thing. And so one of the
  308. things instead of reforming the costs of something like a CNN or whoever fill in
  309. the blank NBC, instead of reforming that that economy, they're doing damage to it
  310. so it can't revive itself in a way that's cost that that those things cost like that kind of thing. And so you're
  311. not going to have a a a logger go over to Iran and do the correct coverage. Anyway,
  312. >> we'll see what happens. Okay, we need to take a quick break and when we come back, we'll get to more of the latest
  313. headlines. >> Support for the show comes from Odo. Running a business is hard enough, so
  314. why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't speak to each other? One for sales, another for
  315. inventory, a separate one for accounting. Before you know it, you are drowning in software instead of growing
  316. your business. This is where ODO comes in. Odo is the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one,
  317. fully integrated platform that handles everything. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR, and more. No more app
  318. overload, no more juggling login. Just one seamless system that makes work easier. And the best part, ODU replaces
  319. multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. It's built to grow with your business, whether you are just
  320. starting out or already scaling up. Plus, it's easy to use, customizable, and designed to streamline every
  321. process, so you can focus on what really matters, running your business. Thousands of businesses have made the
  322. switch, so why not you? Try odo for free at odo.com. That's odo.com. >> Scott, we're back. Recording live from
  323. South by Southwest. So, Apple is entering its affordable era. Affordability counts. The company
  324. just introduced the MacBook Neo, a laptop priced at $599, roughly half the price of a MacBook Air and powered by an
  325. iPhone chip. While some analysts are saying this is a smart way of getting new market share, others online are
  326. wondering if the budget Apple laptop is a quote recession indicator. talk about this about Apple, what's happening uh
  327. over there and where it goes as they start to figure out uh their next leadership group which has been in there
  328. since a long forever actually since its revival back 25 30 years ago. It's the same executives.
  329. >> So I think the strongest luxury brand in the world is not Chanel or Vuitton. I
  330. think it's Apple. And essentially Apple says Apple is the most the perfect luxury brand is one that says you're
  331. wealthy, you're part of the creative class, but you're not trying to exhibit your wealth. When you roll around with a
  332. Birkin bag, you're saying I'm rich and I want you to know it and I or I have such an incredible sense and
  333. passion for this type of design. I'm willing to sacrifice a great deal of resources for it. The iPhone basically
  334. the the iPhone is become so dominant in identifying the billion wealthiest people in the world. They're billion
  335. iPhone iOS contracts and the other six billion when you pull out an Android it's like sending a date
  336. a request or a Venmo you're not getting laid. It's it's sort of when when you when you have an Android,
  337. you're essentially saying to the world, life hasn't really panned out the way I'd hoped
  338. and I should be starch from the gene pool. Um, and the pricing people don't recognize.
  339. I'll go back to my subsack. Most most substacks are eight bucks a month or, you know, 12 bucks a month, 100 bucks a
  340. year. We purposely did 20 bucks a month and 200 bucks a year because pricing is a signal. And one of the case studies I
  341. love that we talk about in my brand strategy course. The most successful or fastest zero to billion alcohol brand in
  342. history was Greygus. Uh, and I do a taste test in class and everyone thinks, "Oh yeah, you know, all
  343. these young douchebags, I can tell the difference." And none of them could tell the difference between Smeirnoff, Sky,
  344. Absolute, and Greygus. None of them, like nine out of 10, not even that, can tell the difference. But the owners of
  345. Greygus said, "All right, the fifth of V or whatever costs about 35 bucks. Charge
  346. 55." Because think about it, when you walk into a store and you're looking at anything, you're immediately sort of
  347. want to check out the most expensive thing. Pricing is a really strong signal. And I think that Apple's genius
  348. is its self-expressive benefit. The strongest self-expressive benefits in the world are the the country you come
  349. from. I'm proud to say I'm from the US. As much as as head up our ass as we are right now, I still like telling people
  350. when I'm overseas and I'm American. It makes me feel good. The second strongest self-expressive benefit is where you
  351. went to college. If you have two people in a mating environment and the dude went to a good school and doesn't have
  352. much else going on, he's like, "Well, at Cornell." Um, that's the second strongest self-expressive benefit. The
  353. third strongest self-expressive benefit is your phone because it's immediately apparent and the Apple has really
  354. become. >> So you think this Neo is a mistake? >> I would always be premium priced if I
  355. were Apple. I'd always be unattainable for 78 85% of the world's population. >> Really? What do you think is an
  356. indicator of that? >> I don't know. They you know more market share. They see a market for the near
  357. near luxury or they want to expand their market. And by the way, these are some of the smartest marketers in the world.
  358. Second most valuable company in the world. So if it's like the strategy team at Apple or Scott Galloway, you go with
  359. the strategy team at Apple. But I I think this is this is a luxury brand. I mean, keep in mind what Apple's been
  360. able to pull off. Margin is is Latin for irrational. When you pay a lot of margin for
  361. something, it's either because you think it'll make you feel closer to God, it's
  362. a monopoly, or it thinks you make makes you um more attractive to potential mates. Margin means irrational. And the
  363. irrational margins that Apple has been able to garner, I was on the board of Gateway Computer, remember them? Which I
  364. realize is the weakest flex in the world, but our margins were 8%. If we sold a computer for a,000 bucks,
  365. it cost us 920 to assemble the thing. Meanwhile, Apple was getting 30 and 40 points of margin because people wanted
  366. to I was I remember when the the seat belt light goes off, do you grab a Dell computer that says you work for a
  367. corporation? Do you, you know, grab an ASUS, which means you work for a bad corporation, or do you pull out your
  368. Apple and say, "I'm in the creative community. I'm interesting. I think different." Right.
  369. >> Right. And so what you have with Apple, they have pulled off the impossible. The
  370. impossible. And that is they have >> I want you to say why they're doing it then.
  371. >> Okay, >> you're in that meeting. We're going to sell a $575$95 computer. >> Just let me finish my last sentence
  372. here. Apple has the margins of Ferrari with the production volumes of Toyota. No company has ever pulled that off
  373. before. They think they're going to expand share and and clear out a bunch of their competition is why they're
  374. doing this. and and good bad you think it's a great >> I think it works in the short run. I
  375. think in the in the long run if Chanel came out with a $400 bag they would sell a [ __ ] ton of them and then over time it
  376. erodess their margins and the truly aspirational people stop start buying you know more Hermes or what have you.
  377. So, I think it's a I think it's a a trade-off of market share in the short run for what is the core asset and that
  378. is a rational margin as the premier luxury brand in consumer products. >> And very briefly, how are you feeling
  379. about their stock right now as as they transition away from Tim Cook? >> Well, I've been selling down my Apple
  380. stock because I think Tim Cook is a duplicitive [ __ ] who's benefited from the American society and is not is
  381. not giving back. Um, >> okay. But that's why you did >> I would stock as you're investing.
  382. >> I would hold on to Apple stock. I I think Apple is I think these are incredible companies.
  383. Uh it hurts to sell the stock. I I'm just trying to walk you trying to walk the walk and virtue signal. So
  384. >> resist and unsubscribe. >> You know it. >> Um anyway, we need to take a quick break
  385. and we come back we'll get to wins and fails. >> Support for the show comes from ODO.
  386. There's an endless supply of software out there that promises to streamline your workflow. That may be true for a
  387. specific aspect of your business, but if you need one app for accounting, one for
  388. inventory management, and another for sales, how streamlined can your workflow actually be if you have to be the
  389. middleman between them? ODO says they're the answer you're looking for. The only
  390. business software you'll ever need can be your one-stop shop for CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, HR,
  391. and more. Plus, it's super customizable and easy to use out of the box. And the best part, they say not only can they
  392. replace multiple applications, but they say they'll do it for a fraction of the cost. Whether you're just starting out
  393. or already well on your way to scaling, ODO wants to help you put the clutter aside so that you can do what you set
  394. out to do when you started your company. Thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you try ODO for free
  395. at odo.com. That's odo.com. Scott, we're back recording live from South by Southwest. All right, we're
  396. going to do one win and one fail each. Um I think I am going to start. Um I think um the win this week uh for me was
  397. um the impression I don't know the guy's name of Tucker Carlson on SNL last night. If you watched it, it was [ __ ]
  398. superb. And oddly enough, in some cases, um, in some of the things he's Tucker Holson's a terrible person. Let's I'm
  399. not going to agree with him, but I thought it was a beautiful rendition of a lot of these sort of noisy
  400. right-wing people who are parodies of themselves. And I thought it was it just got to the heart of the problem with
  401. him. Um, that I thought was just beautiful and it was highly entertaining. It made me laugh. And by
  402. the way, Harry Styles was terrific. And I love Harry Styles so much. I don't know why, but I do. I find him
  403. incredibly appealing. Um the negative this week was uh Elon Musk saying Grock didn't quite work as planned at at the
  404. same time and they're and everybody leaving Grock even though it has these incredible valuations. Nine of the 11
  405. original founders have left. Um obviously you have Mecca Hitler, you have all manner of things that is doing.
  406. You have uh consent uh non-consentual sexual images, child pornography. It's not doing great as an AI product. And
  407. again, a low bar. Um, but I thought it was interesting uh um that he admitted what a mess it was. Um it still will not
  408. have any effect on the valuation because any anything Elon does, they will invest
  409. in no matter what. But I thought it was a moment where he sort of admitted what a disaster Grock is. And I think you're
  410. going to see more of that going forward. And at the same time, uh, in continuing
  411. disasters wrought by Elon Musk, the two, if do yourself a favor and watch the the
  412. testimonies, the the the interviews on video of two of the Doge B bros, they're worse than you thought. Like, it's I
  413. couldn't believe they were worse than you thought. But these were, speaking of incels, like an incelled mode. I don't
  414. know if they're incelss or not, but they should be. Women, any women thinking of
  415. dating them should watch these. Um, I thought they were just sort of this benality of evil kind of thing where you
  416. just watch these ignorant stupid young men telling you why they were cutting and essentially in many cases murdering
  417. people across the globe by do using chatgbt and search to decide and make decisions and someone I couldn't believe
  418. this kid asked I mean maybe I could I don't I kept thinking who raised I want to find this parent and go have a
  419. discussion with them but one of of the things they said is why did you cut it? And he's like, do you think you're
  420. qualified to make the decision on something that was very complex around expertise and everything else? And he
  421. said, yeah, I'm qualified. And he goes, why? And he goes, well, you don't have to read all the books to know things. I
  422. was like, actually, you need to read all the books to know things. And if you do
  423. if you do yourself any favor, it was such a failure of these obviously probably very good coders in technology
  424. and that had talents in a certain area being being unleashed upon things that took a lot more. And I don't think you
  425. can't cut government programs. I'm not one of those people. But the fact that they made these decisions in such a
  426. haphazard, ridiculous, stupid way is something it's it's a real sight to see. And one of the things many years ago I
  427. found a column I did um that I wrote about the need for ethics history and philosophy courses uh with technology
  428. people and vice versa by the way uh liberal studies people should understand AI and everything else and one of the
  429. things that I thought I one of the better things I think I did as a as a parent and and Megan my ex-wife is here
  430. too is our son Alex for example is a techn is in technology but he takes design he's really interested in history
  431. He's he's got like a wider range of interests around politics and everything else. And I I don't that's not our
  432. fault, but I think we encouraged him to have a wider range of Louie could learn more about AI. Our older son could
  433. probably learn more about AI than he does, but um but it was it was really a moment where I thought, what are we
  434. making? What kind of children are we making here that they think this is right? And so I thought it was a real
  435. it's an eyeopener to watch these testimonies and they sit there with these very fresh young faces and it was
  436. so disturbing to me on every level. So I encourage you to watch it and be disturbed yourself. Go ahead. Win and
  437. fail. >> I like that. Um my fail is it the Save Act? The one that's trying to It looks
  438. like it's going to be dead on arrival, but the act would force people to show up with either a passport or a birth
  439. stick of it. Only 50% of Americans have a passport. They cost $160 to get. A lot
  440. of people have to change their birth certificate because they get married or they hyphenate their name. This is just
  441. such a naked attempt to suppress voter turnout. It's just it's it's difficult. And I do it does feel like it's dead on
  442. arrival, but it's difficult to imagine anything more anti-American. >> Yeah. >> They're doing everything to pass it.
  443. >> Yeah. I'm hoping >> getting your senator John Cornin who is just literally the wor the worst. I
  444. mean, Ken Paxton's already sort of criminalishious or criminal adjacent, but this guy used to have values and now
  445. his anything to be in office. Uh and to to the other side, my win is we uh interviewed uh rep state representative
  446. James Talerico yesterday and he had he had the most moving um description of and he wasn't framing it this way of
  447. masculinity. And he said that his father every weekend would mow his lawn and then without asking, without talking
  448. about it, would go next door and mow their lawn. And he said that was masculinity. I
  449. thought that was just so perfect. You know, I struggle with trying to identify it through a series of adjectives and it
  450. just it just without asking mowing your neighbor's lawn. I just love that. That's my
  451. >> You mow my lawn? I have several lawns. >> I'm not going to go there. I I'm >> I I I I
  452. >> I did walk. >> Is this too easy and too wrong? I'm just just season 2 Swedish US women's hockey
  453. team. >> All right. Uh he's I got to meet him. He's the baby Jesus is very attractive.
  454. >> Oh my gosh. Yeah. I really >> I was planning to ask all these zingers like, "Dude, we follow the same people
  455. on Instagram." Um you'll get it. He's supposedly supposedly follows all these hot women
  456. on Instagram. >> I wanted to ask him if he dates and I just couldn't do anything that he's so
  457. >> earnest. >> That's right. >> He's so real and so earnest and you're just looking to I'm like literally like
  458. take my money. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Anyway, it's a real It's going to be an
  459. interesting race. Anyway, um, okay, we need to take a quick break and we come back, we'll take
  460. some questions from the audience. Scott, we're back recording live from South by
  461. Southwest. All right, we're ready to take some questions from the audience. We only
  462. have time for just a few, so keep them short that we can answer quickly and and easy for Scott, please.
  463. >> Hey guys, Melissa Richards Person and I'm from Louisville, Kentucky. Um, >> wow. My dad is turning 10 in three
  464. months. And the reason I offer that, thank you. Is that he was a civil engineer and he was engineering things
  465. built to last. >> Got it. >> And I think about us, have we as a have we lost the ability to think long term
  466. as opposed to short term? >> That's a great question. That's a great question, Scott.
  467. Um well technically we're focused on shareholder value and the markets reverse engineer earnings way out in the
  468. future. So technically these big capex investments that are driving the economy you would argue are actually long-term
  469. investments. So I think the financial markets would say no we are actually still the second largest manufacturer in
  470. the world. Um, I think people have a fondness and a nostalgia for quote unquote building stuff, but the reality
  471. is 80% of Americans think we should have more manufacturing, but only 20% of Americans want to work in manufacturing.
  472. You can't bring your dog to the factory floor. So I I would argue that Americans
  473. still do have more risk capital to invest long term, but quite frankly, just like we were talking about CNN,
  474. Washington Post, we have this romanticism for manufacturing, but very few young people other than Kerous when
  475. you ask them what they want to do say, I want to I want to go into manufacturing.
  476. Um, so I still think we're thinking long term and make make great things. I think
  477. our products are still some of the best in the world. I do think we go through cycles of that and I think we're
  478. probably headed into a more long I think especially if you if anyone who's a young person they're moving away from a
  479. lot of this quick fast I've noticed just a little more community and doing this series there's a lot more of a need and
  480. a desperation for community connection long-termness I picked it up and that's just anecdotal
  481. >> hey Cara and Scott thanks for taking questions Eve Grant um Scott you talked about the attempt to chill free speech
  482. is backfiring I'll tend and alternative media will fill the gap as long as courts protect them. I like your
  483. optimism. What about the Go Gawker media lawsuit that demonstrated the courts didn't protect them and money wins?
  484. >> It's a it's a fair point. I'll I'll turn to my journalist. >> I think you're right. I I am much more
  485. concerned. I think they can chill people. Uh I I worry myself. I like you think about it. You know, I don't do it.
  486. I of course immediately run right into the breach. But I do think it does create a situation when I always like to
  487. see the enemy, right? Like back in the day when everyone's like, "How dare these anti-gay people?" I'm like, "I can
  488. see them. It's the ones I can't see I'm worried about." And so I like to I see what their move is. And so now it's an
  489. easier person to fight when you see who they are and what they're up to. And what they're up to is very typical of
  490. autotocracies is try to slowly bring it down. I do think there's a lashback because we do have so many tools
  491. available to us and power has shifted from uh the typical broadcast networks to people like us to others and so it
  492. does tend to um unintended consequences of being such incredible morons is is is what's going
  493. to happen and again I think Brennan Carr is an embarrassment and will end it will
  494. end badly for him eventually just maybe just because you don't know the And just
  495. because you don't know the end of the story doesn't mean that's how it's going to end. That's how I look at things. All
  496. right. Uh that's all the time we have for today. We really appreciate South by Southwest and we do appreciate all our
  497. fans. Thanks for listening to Pivot and be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel because we have a face
  498. for radio. Uh we'll be back later this week. Thank you so much. South by Southwest.
  499. Thanks again to ODU for supporting this show. ODU wants to be your ultimate all-in-one fully integrated platform to
  500. handle everything. Seriously, everything. Inventory, CRM, accounting, HR, and much more. No more shopping
  501. around or settling for expensive services that can only handle a fraction of your business. Thousands of
  502. businesses have made the switch, so why not you? Try ODO for free at odo.com. That's odo.com.

Brief Summary

Cara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss billionaires' election influence, Apple's new budget laptop, and gambling's impact on young men.

Key points

  • The Challenges of Business. Running a business demands everything you've got, often leading to frustration with tools.
  • A Surprising Television Show. Cara reveals she has a new television show coming up on CNN, surprising Scott.
  • Billionaires Influence Elections. Billionaires made up 19% of all campaign donations, a significant increase in influence.
  • The Risks of Gambling Addiction. Gambling addiction has devastating effects, including the highest suicide rates among addictions.
  • The Incel Movement's Impact. A shocking statistic reveals that many young men are giving up on dating altogether.
  • Chilling Effects on Free Speech. Attempts to control media and speech may lead to a backlash and increased alternative media.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes