How Reddit's IPO Will Impact the Market

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Reddit shares quickly popped on the company's first day of trading on the New York Stock Exchange. What will a successful Reddit IPO mean for the larger market? Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway share their thoughts and predictions.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Reddit has officially gone public uh the social media company made its debut on the New York Stock Exchange on Thursday
  2. with a share price of $34 the high end of the targeted uh range its share price puts Reddit value at around 6.4 billion
  3. which seems te tiny these days which is what they were aiming for but uh below the10 billion valuation from a private
  4. fundraising round in 2021 we're recording this as trading is getting underway H how do you think it'll go
  5. well I voted with my I'm trying to get shares here so look this is if if JP Morgan and
  6. Goldman saxs uh uh and Morgan Stanley could do this this is what they would do they themselves would find $100 million
  7. each and buy into this buy into the first trades and try and send the stock soaring because the IPO Market has been
  8. in a deep thaw for two years it's been some of the slowest 2-year period 24mth period in sever
  9. decades yesterday the The Landing lights got lit by um this company this company
  10. estera if a popular not a popular but a well-known consumer Internet Brand Reddit gets a big pop we're back in
  11. business baby and the amount of money that flows from the IPO market in terms of Downstream secondary green shoe
  12. followon wealth management all the they creat so much fees let me push back here this is an advertising company this
  13. is not an AI company first of all which is a little different different um just for people to be aware Reddit sold I
  14. mean it's almost fully an advertising company completely $800 million in advertising it's very small it's like a
  15. Snapchat kind of situation um I think Snapchat's a lot bigger actually I think double pretty sure um Reddit sold just
  16. for people that we are just above 15 million shares in the offering and existing shareholders sold another close
  17. to 7 million shares getting some taking some money off the table I think right away um and uh you were talking about
  18. estera a s t r a for people who who don't know um but it's a dry spell um uh there has been a dry spell in these
  19. things uh just so people aware reddit's Revenue was $84 Million last year uh it Rose from
  20. $667 million but it lost 90 uh million in almost $91 million where and the year before lost
  21. $159 million um it's trying to get into other businesses like data licensing um it it get it got just around $66 million
  22. from Google in a data licensing deals um to train these AI models it's it it want
  23. it got a a query from the Federal Trade Commission for this it's also Sam told me I me excuse me Sam um Steve told me
  24. he was uh you know they're looking at Commerce and other businesses besides advertising um uh and they think they
  25. have a good advertising story because it's safer because of contextual advertising in and also because you can
  26. reach individuals this is decentralized content moderation and decentralized groups um I don't know I I I think it's
  27. an advertising business so I think and also the last thing is they're famous for Wall Street BS uh which and and in
  28. Wall Street bets they were betting they were going to short the stock so there's
  29. a meme possibility here too that they will that there's that the people that are on the site will try to work against
  30. it and then the last thing moderate some of the mods are getting shares um and not all of them liked it necessarily
  31. because this is a very um noisy noisy company among the people who run it it's run by people who are volunteers and
  32. stuff anyway it's a lot happening here I mean you still think because it's an ad
  33. business I mean and you know the ad business that it'll it'll be it it'll mean as much so there's Reddit the
  34. specific company its performance and how how it performs the market and then there's a larger question about what
  35. what it means the IPO this morning of Reddit to the larger market so let's talk about Reddit you're right it's an
  36. ad business they basically have a series of boards and redditors that manage those boards they have unbelievable
  37. traffic but they haven't really figured out they don't have the ad stack in the business model to really monetize it the
  38. way other companies have run it it's an $800 million business not a big business
  39. it grew 20% last year it's still losing money it's going out or it's priced at about eight times revenues which draws
  40. sharp relief between as you pointed out an ad-based business and an AI business the question surrounding Reddit is the
  41. following they have the worst monetization of any of any platform that gets this kind of traffic I think meta
  42. gets something like 30 to 50 times the monetization per person on the platform as Reddit now it's like my dad told me I
  43. remember my dad telling me this when he was trying to test whether I'd be a good
  44. salesman he's like a Salesman goes over to Africa and this Mark the time this was the 70s and he comes back and one
  45. salesman goes he's a shoe salesman one salesman comes back and says terrible Market Force nobody wears shoes here
  46. another salesman goes over and comes back and says this is amazing nobody has shoes so the question is is reddit is
  47. the fact that they have the worst monetization given the traffic an an incredible opportunity if they figure
  48. that out or is it a company that's never been able to figure it out and is going
  49. to go nowhere that's the question but at $65 billion dollar a lot of people are about to take I believe that bet now the
  50. bigger issue here is what it means for the market would you buy Reddit I don't buy into these things so would you buy
  51. I'm trying to yeah yeah oh you are oh you are I'm sorry that's correct so because you think that it's undervalued
  52. in that regard um because I don't think people think that the that the data stuff is going to be the big money maker
  53. at all the data stuff and no and the Commerce stuff is absolutely nent and like I sell more t-shirts than they do
  54. that kind of thing um so you think the $34 price share is what oh too much too little I'm buying for two
  55. reasons um okay uh the first is this could be I think this I think there is a ton of pent-up demand in
  56. 2021 um there were um uh 397 IPOs and of those 397 IPOs because a ton of them were spacks and and caught up in
  57. the man Mania eight out of 10 of them 82% of them are trading below their IPO price and the market feels burned and
  58. jilted so as a result in 2023 there were only um 108 IPOs uh the reason I'm investing in this
  59. is two reasons one um I think that essentially uh it's a global brand and two it's the most traffic site in
  60. America that isn't know by alphabet and it's trading all of this set against a a
  61. valuation of $6.5 billion there are real issues as you pointed out with this company they have
  62. they have not yet figured out a way to monetize anything resembling the fire hose of traffic they have right I it's
  63. not that big 500 million users 76 he he was focused in on the daily users 76 million and that they have this
  64. dispersed group of people so advertisers could reach if you're in the skiing area
  65. and it's not ugly they've really cleaned it up quite a bit compared to a Twitter
  66. where everyone's in the same pile of crap um you know everybody's in the same feed or whatever but go ahead sorry but
  67. this I mean there there's there's a lot to not like about this company they haven't figured out monetization when I
  68. go on the site it feels like you know lyos or alav Vista called and wants their UI back I don't think it's very
  69. elegantly done but for $6.5 billion dollar a company that is if you type in most traffic sites in the US it goes It
  70. goes Google it goes YouTube and then it's Reddit and so and I and also I think there's so much money on the
  71. sidelines hoping to get back into the IPO Market but if Reddit comes out at a healthy pop We're Off to the Races again
  72. Cara you're going to see a ton of companies file in the greed glander and the animal spirits are going to get
  73. going again so Reddit is actually Reddit is more important to investment banks in
  74. the IPO ecosystem and the broader Market I would argue than almost any company in
  75. a while this IPO has much bigger meaning and ramifications than just what shareholders of Reddit are going to
  76. Garner in the midst of this of of all these things that are happening uh two things interesting uh one of the big
  77. Winners could be K Nas parent company Advance who stake in Reddit will be worth around 1.4 billion I don't think
  78. they can sell though maybe they're selling a little bit of shares in the in the I they might be among those sers um
  79. that's they made a $10 million investment for K Nas to buy Reddit in 20 uh 2006 and then they spun it out again
  80. so you know this company got spun bought in and then spun out uh it's been through a lot in in the many years
  81. second thing um Reddit had to reveal the FTC is conducting an inquiry tied to the
  82. company's deals to uh to license data as we said and then also uh Reddit along with YouTube and meta also has been
  83. ordered by New York State judge to face a lawsuit tied to that 2022 racially motivated shooting in Buffalo the
  84. lawsuit claims the platforms helped radicalize the shooter and prepare him for an attack of course the Supreme
  85. Court found differently when it was a Google case so I'm not sure this will go anywhere um so there's all those things
  86. hanging around um so what do you is it will this set it off or will something else set off the IPO Market because
  87. instacart didn't do very well others didn't do very well you think this will set it off like I said the table's been
  88. set with a stero Labs up 72% if a big consumer Internet Brand Reddit comes out at a healthy pop markets the IPO Market
  89. is back in business Scott Galloway here coming in with an update uh since we've Saed
  90. Reddit has begun trading the stock opened at 47 buck and at its peak the company had a market cap of get this 11
  91. billion and uh also ended up closing up I think around 45 or 50% I would argue that um essentially this is enormous for
  92. the markets that this has turned the IPO Market from sort of like blinking yellow
  93. to to you know illuminant Green the IPO Market the animal spirits I think are back in some estera Labs kind of
  94. illuminated the runway yesterday and this big consumer Internet Brand Reddit landed the plane with a huge pop today
  95. uh this is big for the markets it's actually the the bigger part of the news here isn't a consumer Media company uh
  96. up whatever it was 45 or 50% the bigger story here is the IPO Market I believe is back the animal spirits are back John
  97. cholta is on the Dance Floor

Brief Summary

Reddit's IPO performance signals potential recovery for the IPO market amid ongoing monetization challenges.

Key points

  • Reddit Goes Public. Reddit officially debuts on the New York Stock Exchange with a share price of $34.
  • Valuation Insights. Reddit's valuation stands at approximately $6.4 billion, below its previous $10 billion target.
  • IPO Market Revival. Reddit's successful IPO may signal a revival in the sluggish IPO market.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes