Google Forced to Sell Chrome? DOJ's Bombshell Breakup Plan | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

The Department of Justice has a bombshell proposal in the Google monopoly case: forcing the tech giant to sell off Chrome browser. Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway dive into why this could reshape tech competition, what a $20B Chrome sale might mean, and why breaking up big tech has historically led to more innovation. Plus, they explore the political uncertainties with upcoming DOJ leadership changes and what this means for the future of search.

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or at https://podcasts.voxmedia.com/show/pivot

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the doj is asking a judge in the Google search Monopoly case to force the company to sell its Chrome browser as
  2. part of the remedy Chrome has about 67% of the global market and could go for as
  3. much as 20 billion According to some estimates the government also wants to stop Google from getting into paid
  4. agreements with apple and others to be the default search engine on phones and browsers uh the doj stopped short of
  5. requesting a full divesture of Android Google called The doj Proposal extreme and is set to file its own Suggestions
  6. by December 20th remedy hearings will be held in April and the judge judges expected to rule over the summer I I
  7. know you know all these all these uh agencies are sort of waiting for what happens with Trump although you just
  8. never know because he's had some anti- Google um statements and everything else and there'll be a new head of antitrust
  9. at the justice department it's not clear who that's going to be um what do you what do you think of this remedy it
  10. seems like an unusual thing Tech writer John grber noted Chrome and Android are not Standalone businesses they're
  11. appendages to Google it's like saying I have to sell my left foot it's very valuable to me but of no value to anyone
  12. else um and if a buyer of chrome is a company like open a or Microsoft could they be accused of creating as you just
  13. you know another Monopoly with this purchase I like this the potential remedies were a fine you can't come up
  14. with fines big enough uh some sort of administrator from the government bureaucrat that had to they got to go
  15. into any meeting and tell them why they shouldn't do something which they basically can ignore stick the stick the
  16. fat ugly weird kid in the corner and then finally a breakup so I I was happy to see this now whether it holds or not
  17. but I I'm not sure I agree with the writer because because Chrome you know it has about 2/3 Global share I think of
  18. the browser Market that's so much attention um that's so much attention that a lot of different people could
  19. monetize that so it would have no shortage of biders it would it would um uh immediately stop this default uh you
  20. know steering everyone towards their search engine it'd be more of a competition so I like this I think I
  21. generally find that the FDC and the doj and this is because they bring in a lot of my colleagues from Business Schools
  22. are pretty smart about trying to come up with solutions that grow the total Market uh so I I like this I hope it
  23. goes I don't know it'll hold yeah you know there's so much uncertainty because as I said caner is will be leaving John
  24. caner and Lea Khan's tenure may be over or maybe not it's very unclear you might
  25. get someone like Brandon Carr who's making a grab for power at the FCC of which didn't have but may be trying to
  26. do so um there's all kinds of uncertainty on who's going to be able to run this and then who is going to be the
  27. antitrust head and it is all in the hands of a single judge um who's who which then can be appealed Etc and the
  28. government can stop trying right The Government Can Go a different direction depending um you know it'll be
  29. interesting because Sundar Pai the head of alphabet was on the phone with Trump and of course guess who was on the phone
  30. with him there's the whole Elon element Elon was on a phone call with the CEO of
  31. alphabet with Trump I mean there's all these different competing power centers uh happening here
  32. so I I agree with you I think this something should be cleaved off of these companies that's to me the only the key
  33. question is where was Omar Rosa I want her back she would she actually seems quite credible now no she does I can't
  34. believe it but she is you're right I mean it'll be interesting to see what the remedy is but I think the only
  35. remedy is the start to breaking up of parts of their businesses and then creating new vibrant businesses from
  36. them right it just seems healthier in so many ways a Fine's not going to work a threatening with prison's not going to
  37. work you know it's just they should just cut them up and create new businesses and see what could be made I mean having
  38. 67% of the global market and it does it does help their other business I can't tell you how many times I open Chrome
  39. and it says don't you want to make this your default browser right I I unsign out from Google because it's constantly
  40. trying to get me sucked into their system for no good reason so um it seems would rather it be owned by more people
  41. that's my feel search is arguably finished I bet on a gross dollar volume basis search maybe the biggest business
  42. in the world it's 150 I think it's like a quarter of a trillion dollar business but I bet it's got gross margins of 80
  43. or 90 points and that makes even the iPhone look like a distant not not a great business so and essentially all of
  44. this accrets to one player and if you didn't have this incredible data advantage of looking what everyone is
  45. doing on the internet two-thirds of the time and then be able to steer them towards your search engine and then
  46. extract all sorts of payments to be the default you would just have a lot more all of a sudden the biggest Market in
  47. the world wouldn't be a monopoly which would ultimately lower rents on everyone that has to pay the to that's right and
  48. search would be better as a product search and they'd be forced to innovate they might who knows someone might pop
  49. up and say this is search that is uh not going to not going to give this information more reach this is we're not
  50. going to let computers create content I had Eric Schmidt on and he said something I thought was really
  51. insightful he this is a former just for people who know the former Google head former alphabet yeah yeah who I think he
  52. never was alphabet but Google but go ahead oh you're right excuse me um but he said something really interesting he
  53. said humans should have absolutely very strong First Amendment Free Speech rights but he said computers should not
  54. and that really struck me as insightful because I think a lot of the misinformation a lot of the incendiary
  55. cont that polarizes us is not generated by a human and I thought that was really
  56. an interesting place to start around all of this but back to breakups in anti trust ask any Economist or ask any
  57. lawyer trying to fight against this what breakup in US history did not end up being a good idea every time we have
  58. broken up companies you end up with more powerful more valuable companies you end
  59. up with more choice you end up with lower rents you end up with more Innovation the only person that loses is
  60. the person who has the controlling shareholders or the super voting majority shares who want to sit on the
  61. Iron Throne of not just Westeros but all Seven Realms but everybody else every other stakeholder the community the tax
  62. base emplo uh employees they then have more companies vying to rent their labor it's always better it's always better
  63. look at what's happening even over in social media Blue Sky that's that choice that's you know whether you like threads
  64. or not that's that choice it feels so much people get text to me Blue Sky stuff yeah everyone's moving over there but
  65. it's different they have a different like this is how our place is going to be it's not going to be mean and it's
  66. not like that's the whole point of different things is you get to choose what you want and that's the true free
  67. speech that's my feeling is you get to you know everyone's like you have to be you know Elon and his gang are pushing
  68. like you have to be on Twitter like no I don't I can do whatever I want and if I want to be in a bubble great if
  69. I don't great like the ability to make and choose your own venture to me is the the is freedom that's my feeling

Brief Summary

The DOJ proposes forcing Google to sell Chrome to combat its monopoly, sparking debate on antitrust remedies and market competition.

Key points

  • DOJ's Proposal on Google. The DOJ is pushing for Google to sell its Chrome browser as part of a remedy.
  • The Future of Antitrust. Uncertainty looms over the future of antitrust leadership and its impact on Google.
  • Breaking Up Monopolies. Breaking up companies leads to more innovation and choice, according to experts.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes