Google Document Leak and AI Failures | Pivot

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss the leak of 2,500 Google documents that shed light on how the search really works, plus the recent rollback of the faulty AI Overviews feature. Can Google regain consumer trust?

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Google is dealing with a Fallout from a massive leak after 2 200 pages of documents from inside its search
  2. division were shared by SEO experts the documents detail the data that Google collects from websites and users they
  3. offer an unprecedented look at the search process and how content is ranked uh Google is saying of course that uh
  4. these are out of context um the document suggest that Google might have misled the public in terms of ranking content
  5. uh uh it denied in the P that users click clicks play a role in ranking websites but leak documents indicate
  6. otherwise they're saying actually it's not what it says um it's not it's not the best thing at the same time it has
  7. an AI problem on its hands speaking of the current days that's its old business the company is scaling back on the new
  8. uh AI overviews feature the one that put some wildly incorrect AI generated answers at the top of search results
  9. some are correct let's be fair uh some of the major reported errors included users being told to put glue on Pizza
  10. that was the famous one on a claim that John F Kennedy graduated from college in
  11. 1993 um wow there's a lot going on at Google um they're going to disable the misleading advice uh limiting answers
  12. from some sites um they had a similar problem with their image tool if you remember it was too woke whatever um you
  13. know these things work themselves out my issue with these companies is away from the the leaked documents is
  14. they're always beta testing on users without about putting out products that are fully baked that's always been my
  15. experience with Silicon Valley um I don't think this is a good look for Google it makes it look like they're not
  16. competitive with Microsoft openi and meta um thoughts I'll turn it back to you and my only observation because I
  17. think you know more about this than I do my only observation is that it feels from an observations of a bystander that
  18. Google got caught flat-footed and their investors and the entire world said let me get this it was invented here and
  19. everyone's making trillions but us and I think that the ultimate like hurry up and catch up like you better hurry up
  20. has resulted in kind of a ready ready fire aim mentality that's haunting them a little bit because I think they feel
  21. real pressure to catch up and they do people internally I I just can't imagine that QA hasn't been a little bit more
  22. promiscuous here because they need to show their investors that they are catching up but you know there so much
  23. better than I do I I know nothing about this well you know these leaks these search leaks is Google has always sort
  24. of been such a formative company in terms of We're the better people we're the you know don't be evil they always
  25. had that nonsense when you knew you know they were doing all kinds of stuff behind the scenes that weren't in line
  26. with what they said they were doing um this search leak is interesting and it's an important and big deal that they had
  27. been sort of doing search in a different way now again it's only 2 200 Pages they're older some of them um the fact
  28. that they were doing whether user clicks played a role in ranking websites um they had in they had insisted they were
  29. giving you the best things versus what was most popular as I recall um I'm not sure if the leak is that damaging but it
  30. does suggest you know that they weren't being fully honest with people which is I think a disease of all these companies
  31. completely disease all these companies I'm not so much focused on that although it is interesting um but you're right
  32. this is this they they have been slow slow slow and I think a lot of people are complaining about CEO Sundar Pai as
  33. being indecisive I think that's been a take on him for many years now um and not being fast enough and I you know
  34. I've had that experience when he when he they were very slow to Cloud I had lunch
  35. with him I'm like why exactly are you letting at AWS dominate when you have much this is your area you know and he
  36. was like well you know he's a very considered person and I think in this case they shouldn't be putting out
  37. products that that are embarrassing because they're a worldwide I mean they're they're the most consumer facing
  38. of all these companies more than Microsoft meta I suppose um but they're the most consumer facing and they're
  39. known what I thought was amazing is this is a company known for searching and getting you the answer you want by
  40. pointing you to the answer then they give you the answer and it's wrong it ruins the brand in seconds right isn't
  41. that their whole promise of being correct or being helpful I I don't know from a brand perspective I think it's
  42. disastrous yeah but narratives have momentum and the momentum is against cator in alphabet right now they're seen
  43. as they're seen as uh being disrupted in the classic case of the innovators dilemma where they didn't want to
  44. challenge this to booth called Surge and let other people come around them and disrupt it but so so the The Narrative
  45. is negative and some of the things you were talking about uh where he's he quote unquote doesn't make decisions
  46. quickly if the narrative was positive everyone would be saying that he's a thoughtful mature business leader that
  47. the world needs right now because if you look at the numbers the actual numbers the stock is up 37% in the last 12
  48. months I mean the company continues to perform it's touching I'm I think the stock is at an all-time high it's
  49. outperformed even the S&P I I think quite frankly I think these stories are a little bit
  50. I think they make for clickbait I think they're embarrassing interesting but and
  51. you're right it might impact the brand because the media picks up on it because they're funny and it's like seeing it's
  52. tabloid but the reality is they continue to perform this was this was my big Tech
  53. stock pick for 24 they are firing on they have not given up any ground on search their Cloud business is you know
  54. firing on all 12,000 cylinders YouTube is the most dominant video platform among young people and they are trying
  55. fast to catch up and AI I I don't The Narrative right now is is is bad and momentum is against them but the the
  56. data gets in the way of the narrative here this company is performing really well y That's a fair point that's a fair
  57. point I just don't think a thing like this this leak comes out when they're under the justice department scrutiny
  58. and this idea it works well for the people that are trying to slow them down for definitely for the justice
  59. department right it shows it shows them you know saying one thing and doing another I think it's um someone the guy
  60. who one of the people who leaked this information I think or he had this information where's this guy's name
  61. fishkin is a veteran search engine optimization industry told the the The Verge um you know here's the last part
  62. which I thought was important journalists and Publishers of information about SEO and Google search
  63. need to stop uncritically repeating Google's public statements and take a much harsher more adversarial view of
  64. the search Giants Representatives when Publications repeat Google's claims as though they're a fact they're helping
  65. Google spin a story that's only useful the company and not to practitioners users are public the reason why that is
  66. important is because everybody that is a black box nobody gets to see the inside
  67. of and they're just starting to see it right and that's and it you know it's not what they did a lot of people get
  68. those sort of erroneous answers I mean how many consumers were actually exposed to that yeah I don't know I don't know
  69. it's just I I don't know and in this case this is the about the leak documents I think it just it's not a
  70. it's not a great Public Image for a company in the middle of a of a justice department thing so we'll see where it
  71. goes

Brief Summary

Google faces scrutiny after a leak reveals contradictions in its search ranking practices and AI-generated results.

Key points

  • Google's Massive Leak. A leak reveals Google's internal documents, suggesting they misled the public about search rankings.
  • AI Problems at Google. Google scales back its AI features after generating wildly incorrect answers.
  • Public Image Under Scrutiny. The leak raises questions about Google's transparency amid ongoing scrutiny from the justice department.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes