Elon Musk Torches Advertisers in DealBook Summit Interview

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss what to make of Elon Musk's bizarre interview at the New York Times DealBook Summit and examine the repercussions for X and Musk.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi everyone this is Pivot from New York Magazine and the VOX media podcast Network I'm Cara swisser and tell me
  2. you're abusing ketamine without telling me you're abusing ketamine Cara I am only bereft that Jonathan had to be
  3. there to witness that Jonathan Ross sorin uh did you see that part our friend our Canadian he called our
  4. Canadian friend Jonathan his and Andrew is like I'm Andrew oh my God I could see
  5. that he said you're my good friend Jonathan and I was thinking why did he think Jonathan H the only sort of Jewish
  6. sounding name he could think of I I don't even know what he was doing there well if this if that whole um dialogue
  7. cemented or proved anything it is that in fact Andrew Ros sorin is Canadian one he was on stage the entire time
  8. unarmed we can talk about it more in a minute but go ahead he was on stage the entire time both unarmed and had health
  9. insurance Canadian yeah and you know how you get a Canadian to apologize how you
  10. step on his foot and that has some relevance here yeah yeah which we'll get to Andrew felt bad
  11. it was like a the way Andrew felt I don't know if he felt bad for the audience he didn't know what to say
  12. we're going to go right to our first story as we were talking about Elon Musk gave quite a performance at the New York
  13. Times dealbook Summit on Wednesday which was chalk full of really good interviews
  14. in a lengthy conversation with Jonathan Ross sorin also known as Andrew Elon addressed numerous topics uh ranging
  15. from from his anti-semitic comments to his grudge against Biden and waited on open AI aliens monkeys and more and
  16. something about Earth I don't quite understand what that was about and when they apologized for that anti-semitic
  17. tweet it was a comment directed at X's advertisers that caused the most chaos let's listen you don't want them to
  18. advertise no what do you mean if somebody's going to try to Blackmail me with advertising blackmail
  19. with money go [ __ ] yourself but go [ __ ] yourself is that clear I hope it is hey Bob impressed on
  20. what it would mean for his company this is what he said tell it to Earth uh you know you have to watch this in a whole
  21. because it's the entire thing is bizarre not just this um his diet tribe against
  22. uh not being invited to a Biden comab um everything was so strange tell it to Earth what did you think as you watch
  23. this uh the shout out to was to Bob Iger by the way who earlier who was in the audience who earlier in the day asked
  24. about when asked about Elon and advertising on next said that the association was not necessarily A
  25. positive one let me have some other highlights if we want to call them that elon's issues with Biden go back to
  26. Tesla getting excluded from this White House Event on electric vehicles he shortly after Biden took office he said
  27. it wasn't fair um he's he's obviously hurting from it um he said I have done more for the environment than any other
  28. person on earth when talking about electric vehicles sales Nikki Haley uh was dismissed as Pro censorship
  29. candidate more on her later open AI should be renamed super closed source for maximum profit AI haha Scott please
  30. go ahead I was on a plane watching it uh last night I came home from Miami and I
  31. found it difficult to watch um you know I think the most generous thing you could say is it was
  32. an intense uh bout of jet lag but there's something going on here and I of course went to chat GPT and I typed
  33. in what are the symptoms of a narcissist having a breakdown and it came back with
  34. intense rage and anger blame shifting emotional disregulation paranoia depression and
  35. anxiety manipulative behaviors isolation self-destructive behaviors increased sensitivity to criticism and breakdown
  36. of relationships I mean his statements were so ridiculous Cara do you realize that 497 of the Fortune 500 uh companies
  37. in the United States are clearly blackmailing us because they refuse to advertise on our platform I know and
  38. then to to go after Disney and it's like it just the whole thing was just and to
  39. be that to be that profane and that aggressive and then to somehow threaten advertisers that the world will hold you
  40. accountable if Twitter goes down and then talking about I thought the most disturbing part is someone who raises
  41. boys I'm talking about as a 13-year-old just the incredible hardship and dysfunction he faced his answer or his
  42. response to this incredible abuse being the son of a model and a emerald Miner was the decision that to save Humanity
  43. by making us an interplanetary species I mean he's literally he's just like kind
  44. of [ __ ] lost his [ __ ] you know again his stands literally were like this was
  45. great he did told it like it was this is and then let me just say uh Linda yaker
  46. well it's it's it's really sad it's sad it's sad I don't feel sorry for him but it's sad to watch um he thinks he's
  47. great his clothes were strange like he was a he was dressed as a fighter pilot from World War II I guess yeah I did
  48. notice that I don't really know um which is fine he can wear whatever he wants but it just the whole the whole visual
  49. was weird he looked exhausted he looked unshaven um you know I thought Lindy yino did the worst job of any CEO in
  50. recent memory but he has managed to top it he bested her um two things Lind Linda Yer was in the audience she then I
  51. thought she must have been horrified but instead she put up a lengthy post on X afterwards I'm not going to read it in
  52. full because it was such it was so full of nonsense um and and enabling when it comes to advertising X's standing at a
  53. unique and amazing intersection of free speech and Main Street block that [ __ ] metaphor but okay I think she
  54. just got run over by by you know a truck essentially driven by Elon Musk um one was how do you think she's feeling today
  55. at that intersection um she is she is really a piece of work I got to say because she's not she seems nuts but she
  56. is obviously something else my understanding of Linda is that she was outstanding at her job she was a
  57. fantastic head of sales well I'll get to that and so you put someone as a head of
  58. sales for a traditional company with a lot of products a lot of outstanding ass sets
  59. to sell and then you show up and you're you're fighting a fire with a squirt gun
  60. and then you find out that the person who you're fighting the Fighting For Keeps putting gasoline in your squirt
  61. gun she doesn't have to go this far she can leave she cannot put out quotes like
  62. this this was shocking to me you gota I I can't decide whether she's she's part of the problem I there's been very few
  63. people who have who have gone from zero to Global awareness and then in in almost as fast a a time a period have
  64. absolutely destroyed the reputation now you could argue in this day and age it's
  65. just all about awareness and I think she'll be able to get another job but it just she just looks she looks totally
  66. flaccid in the face of a owner who doesn't respect anything about her role of CEO she's not she's not a CEO and all
  67. is again the analogy is she's the the circus clown following this elephant around scooping up his [ __ ] all the time
  68. yeah yeah it's you know she was also the subject of a not very flattering profile
  69. in The Hollywood Reporter by Kim Masters Wednesday where the writer Kim Masters spoke with unnamed former NBC colleagues
  70. the article quotes someone who said Linda let her ego get the best of her she thought she could control them it
  71. was a level of ego and huous uh you rely see um I thought it was a pretty Fair article others thought it was you know
  72. it was all unnamed sources but it was accurate it was I know her that's she was tough she's a tough and somewhat of
  73. a chaotic manager not that I care lots of bad people don't manage as well but she definitely is way in way over her
  74. skis but then continues to double down that that's the tragedy here is this sort of like fullscale embracing of this
  75. lunatic Behavior by Elon um why would any Advertiser stay with X at this point what you know he's done this before
  76. remember when he first got to the company he he insulted advertisers of that ad first advertising meeting don't
  77. advertise with us then he just hates anyone in control of his Destiny I guess or something the answer is no big
  78. advertisers going to um or no or no advertisers that wor is worried about their reputation I mean I I found his
  79. comments everyone wants to peer try and peer into his heart to really understand
  80. if he's an anti-semite and my view is if you say and do anti-semitic things and boom you're an
  81. anti-semite and so big companies that are correctly more sensitive to this sort of scrutiny and criticism as they
  82. should be are going to stay away from this thing because here's the thing there are about a billion other options
  83. to spend your money in term there's no shortage there are fewer ad dollars than there are platforms to spend those
  84. dollars on and Twitter is not particularly effective as many people are pointing out like why why take the
  85. risk it's never been known as as being a great product in terms of Roi the people
  86. or the the firms that will continue to advertise well because the outflow of advertising will be so
  87. dramatic logically speaking the ROI on the ad dollars that would remain should go up because there'll be fewer of them
  88. so if you're trying to sell an ear cleaning product I wouldn't be surprised and I hate to say this I wouldn't be
  89. surprised if the ROI on your ad dollars on Twitter that are going to be competing with much fewer dollars for
  90. eyeballs will actually go up so they'll probably see a bit of a bump uh the smaller advertisers in terms
  91. of Roi because it'll just be so few dollars chasing what is still a fairly large audience the ads have gotten
  92. really scary they've gotten really weird ear cleaning product is one of them that
  93. and that weird glue now you haven't been on it but there's a weird hand glue I don't really know what it is um uh you
  94. know what's H how is this going to end how is Earth what is Earth going to do because they you know from a business
  95. point of view X was last week the New York Times reported that X was in danger of losing $75 million earlier this week
  96. in advertising before the interview what you're in a room with marketers right now who are still on the platform what
  97. is being said here's my b to narcissism I've worked with 27 of the 100 CMOS of the Fortune 100 globally none of them
  98. would have anything to do with this platform right now none of them it's all let me get this the product's not that
  99. great you might be accused of enabling an anti-semite oh and if you decide to stop
  100. advertising he's going to say you're blackmailing them and and start threatening revenge against you I mean
  101. okay what is the upside here let's look at the upside versus the down there there are a few things that CMO can be
  102. fired for kind of UN harmoniously if you were to go on Twitter and spend some money and then it were to blow up in
  103. your face say your Pepsi your you know Diet Pepsi ad ends up next to a swastika and then a really decent question would
  104. be like you saw this [ __ ] happening and you made the conscious decision to put
  105. us at risk like this so no nobody you or me know knows is going to be advertising
  106. on this platform yeah it's a real it is a traffic accident speaking of f you know F the corner of free speech in
  107. Maine um I don't know this is just it was so bizarre I was in New York I didn't go you used to be
  108. friends with him do you know anyone that knows him I wasn't friends he was so he
  109. was so funny he was referring to Andrew as a friend Jonathan as a friend Jonathan's not his friend either um he
  110. thinks anyone who's nice to him as his friend it's really sad actually um Andrew and I are just reporters uh I
  111. liked him I certainly thought he was interesting um no I don't everyone just shakes their head everyone just shakes
  112. their head but I I do think on a on a meta level I do think the world is having a healthy immune response to Elon
  113. Musk yeah the audience certainly did you could hear it they were like but we don't have a president of
  114. the world we don't have one company that controls the world we have several that
  115. are Marching towards that but generally speaking over time the ecosystem doesn't
  116. like an invasive species and it starts to fight back against it yeah and when one person Aggregates this much power I
  117. think the world does have a healthy Earth it's called yeah it does have healthy immune gag reflex and I feel
  118. like we're starting to really choke on this guy

Brief Summary

Elon Musk's chaotic DealBook Summit appearance sparks discussion on his controversial comments and implications for advertisers.

Key points

  • Elon Musk's Controversial Performance. Elon Musk addresses anti-semitic comments and more at the Dealbook Summit.
  • Linda Yaccarino's Struggles. Linda Yaccarino faces criticism for her handling of the advertising crisis at X.
  • The Future of Advertising on X. Concerns arise over the viability of advertising on X amid controversy.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes