Elon Musk Is a Trillionaire. "He Can Pick the Next President" | Pivot Excerpt

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Following the SpaceX IPO, Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discuss Elon Musk's new status as the world's first trillionaire and the new power it affords him.

This is an excerpt from the full podcast episode: https://youtu.be/xsXVsxBsttk?si=Txrk4OR2xkK5EGea

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin Todd Wiseman

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. SpaceX uh of course this seems like a hundred years ago officially public and as uh one Scott Galloway predicted it
  2. did indeed close up on its first day of trading and you had said it was going to
  3. be about 20% and not more which is interesting. It was at 19 something%. Shares are at a high of 177 at the time
  4. of this taping after the company's public debut on Friday making the current market cap 2.32 trillion. You
  5. thought it might be a scooch under under two. um his first day on the market. Over 500 million shares traded hands. A
  6. lot of movement here. Um Elon himself of course crossed the milestone thanks to the pot becoming the world's first
  7. trillionaire. There were some notable buyers. Gina Reinhardt, Australia's richest person bought over a billion
  8. dollar stake in the company and Kathy Woods Arc Investment bought more than $500 million worth of stock. So go
  9. through if there's anything surprising there because uh venture and also venture funding for US space technology
  10. firms excluding SpaceX jumps $7.5 billion in 2025 from 2.5 billion the previous years probably we'll see if
  11. that goes anywhere because it's a that's also a money can be a money furnace u as
  12. you the word you use but any thoughts on where it is right now >> I thought that the bankers and and Musk
  13. and look I I think the most significant thing here is that this we've never seen
  14. such engineered manufactured scarcity. There was tens of billions of dollars of demand for this IPO that has never
  15. existed for an IPO before. And then you combine it with the fact that unlike other IPOs that went public on the
  16. NASDAQ, it didn't have to float more than 10%. It only floated 5%. >> Yeah. Very scarcity as you said.
  17. >> So you've just created manufacturer scarcity. Now to be fair, it's up again today. So this has created a level of
  18. excitement in the market. I do think you you have to highlight the positives here
  19. and that is I never want to be someone that demonizes success. There are 14 new billionaires in Texas that you've never
  20. heard of. Those people will give money away. They will start new businesses. Something that's uniquely American is
  21. that we continue to produce companies like this and entrepreneurs like Elon Musk. It's going to create a lot of
  22. economic growth. You're going to see a surge in philanthropy from Berkeley to the University of Texas. It inspires a
  23. lot of people. I it is there's a lot of positives here and we're seeing venture funding increasing in you know space
  24. related um projects. So there there's there's a a lot to like here. You know, I don't like the manufactured scarcity
  25. and the what I'll call the overlying narrative of sort of like the hero's journey here.
  26. >> And the numbers at certain businesses are not great. >> Yeah. Look, this from a valuation
  27. standpoint, and this is this is what Musk has always been able to do is to create this this uh narrative over
  28. numbers that's like no one else in history. Um so but right now the stock is trading 30% above the IPO price. Um
  29. and then he has also again and I'm I go back to governance there's all these different lockups like if you trade on a
  30. certain platform and you bought shares through direct share purchase on a certain platform they technically don't
  31. have a lockup but but they if they sell their shares they can't trade on the platform before which is like a soft
  32. lock up. there's certain uh criteria around when you can sell if the stock is up a certain amount etc. To be fair,
  33. Elon's locked himself up. I doubt he's planning to sell. He'll just borrow against his stock. But what they've
  34. effectively done, what you're not supposed to do, is they've created different class of classes of shares,
  35. which you're not supposed to do. So again, I find that this is this is really inspiring and important and going
  36. to be great for economic growth on certain levels. I also believe that this entire sector is going to have not a
  37. collapse but a pretty serious draw down when people after two or three earnings calls are forced to justify anything
  38. resembling a future that involves the kind of earnings built into this thing >> right
  39. >> and then the rush to space technology firm same thing they're going to overinvest which is normal like I would
  40. assume presumably >> and that and quite frankly that's one of the great things about America because
  41. we overinvested in the internet and the technology survived and a lot of those companies came back and that investment
  42. was good but you didn't want to one of the one of the investors overinvesting initially.com. Yeah.
  43. >> Yeah. So, but I said somebody called me and I said this on pivot. Someone called
  44. me and said I I have allocation. Should I take it? And I said take it and trade out on the first trade.
  45. >> If you buy it and trade out, you don't do as most people don't do as well except in certain cases, right? It's
  46. there were all these like really interesting statistics of buying and selling um that were not good in the
  47. long run over over time. It's just you got to hit the exact right one or you lose mo money most of the time.
  48. >> This was different because so first off uh trading out trading out you you get
  49. short-term capital gains at a higher rate. So there's a lot of evidence that shows that just generally with investing
  50. you're better off just buying and trying to never sell. It's just trading trading
  51. is a difficult is a difficult game. I thought and I said this I said they are going to manufacture a 20% pop. The
  52. bankers exactly >> and everyone are figuring out a way to create a supply demand imbalance that
  53. will exactly peg this at a 20% pop. What's impressive and punctures that theory is that it's up another 11%
  54. today. And the thing that also just the thing that deserves a nod is the best VC
  55. in the world is not Andre Horowitz or whoever initially funded SpaceX. How >> respond? Well, it's in my opinion, it's
  56. Uncle Sam and that SpaceX investors and the banks taking SpaceX public should remember
  57. >> that we would not be here today without grants from the federal government. In
  58. 2008, SpaceX was on the verge of bankruptcy >> and would likely have run out of money
  59. if not for a grant from NASA. >> Yep. >> And the golden law, >> same thing with Tesla.
  60. >> And then the golden law of stupidity here, Trump is trying to cut NASA's funding by more than 20% this year.
  61. >> Same with mRNA technology. Same with the government is one of the greatest investors of all time if you could think
  62. about it that way. best VC in history, whether it's medical research for our universities or electric charging
  63. stations would you know and they would argue back well they're going to get their bite they're going to get enormous
  64. return through tax revenues >> possibly >> the the big debate this will will stir
  65. is in America we've been talking about for decades now what's dominated the conversation is how you create wealth
  66. the conversation that is superseding that is what you should do with wealth once you have it. And so right now Elon
  67. Musk could buy all of Manhattan, every building, every condo, every park with his that's how much money he has right
  68. now. And whether or not this level of concentration of power which comes in a capitalist society for money
  69. presents a risk. And I'm of the mind that I think it's important that eventually and I I'm in favor of of
  70. eventually having trillionaires, but we should have guard rails over the power and progressive taxation, which we don't
  71. have right now. >> Can I just say one thing I want to push back on, and that you've created all
  72. these rich people are going to give to charity. If you look at the statistics, I don't think they're going to be
  73. charitable. I don't think they're going to do good things. I just don't I don't think this class I don't think Elon Musk
  74. has had a very good record. So, I just I I'm not expecting these people to be I think they're going to be on an ongoing
  75. quest for more money and more power and more consolidation. So, I'm not impressed with their charitable uh
  76. thoughts. And I'm I'm glad they're creating jobs, but they would immediately cut you if they had to.
  77. That's I just don't think they have that in them. >> You're talking about Okay. But I I think
  78. we need to parse that. And that is if you look at billionaires and their wives, the wives have hands down been
  79. more philanthropic. And it doesn't and and the the quote unquote billionaire masters of the
  80. universe have not acquitted themselves well on a lot of levels. But there's just no doubt this type of
  81. wealth creation event is going to result in a surge in philanthropy. It just does. That would be great
  82. >> because you're going to have a lot of people who wake up and have $20 million
  83. and think, I'm going to give 2 million bucks to the local food bank or I'm going to give 50,000. I I talked to, you
  84. know, I'm I'm involved with the University of California. They're all revising their giving goals up for next
  85. year because of the IPOs coming down the and they have so many alumni. I'm not talking about Elon Musk. I think
  86. it would be you could you could make a credible argument that he's not the most philanthropic person. I get that and you
  87. can definitely make an argument that Mackenzie Scott and Melinda French Gates are more philanthropic than their
  88. husbands. But when you see these types of liquidity events, local philanthropies surge in terms of in
  89. terms of uh uh money. There's look there's for all of SpaceX's problems and income inequality, there isn't a nation
  90. on Earth that wouldn't kill to have those problems. I I would agree. I just think it's going
  91. to go into political activism in a way that could be deletarious to most of us. That's
  92. >> that's where it's going. It's not going to helping a kid. >> Let's be clear. >> Elon Musk, in my view, can probably
  93. decide who the next president is. >> Yeah, that's correct. >> He spent $250 million
  94. and had influence on the election. Maybe he didn't decide it, but he had influence on it. He thinks what happens
  95. if he decides to put 2.5% of his net worth or 25 billion or 100 times what he spent
  96. >> last time. >> Yeah, he's a freight train. >> And also to be to be fair, are we
  97. comfortable and I he deserves credit. One of the one of the things that doesn't get he doesn't get enough credit
  98. for is he has turned off Starlink for Russia and it is it has put Russia at a severe disadvantage to Ukraine. And I
  99. think that is a wonderful thing and he deserves credit for it. Having said that,
  100. >> he changes his mind. >> Well, that's exactly right. Having said that, is should that power reside in a
  101. private citizen that has no government or electoral oversight? >> No, it's not. >> But look, it's a ton of economic growth.
  102. The banks made a ton of money. You have a lot of people. 4,000 people became millionaires on Friday.
  103. >> I get it. I hope they're better better at it. I just think I'm not even Musk is
  104. one thing, but I'm worried about others that aren't quite so broad. I just like I always whenever I see a box, I think
  105. the Ulain's the Eul I N E. I don't know how to pronounce it, but they're like huge givers to crazy right-wing causes.
  106. And so I just am like, "Oh god, the boxes, the this, the that." Anyway, I I just hope that they um that they
  107. >> the Citizens United problem. I hope that they're charitable. That's that's what I
  108. hope.

Brief Summary

SpaceX's IPO sparks debate on wealth concentration and philanthropy among billionaires like Elon Musk.

Key points

  • SpaceX's Historic IPO. SpaceX's IPO saw unprecedented demand, with shares trading at a high of 177.
  • The Role of Government in Wealth Creation. The discussion highlights the government's crucial role as a significant investor in companies like SpaceX.
  • Elon Musk Becomes World's First Trillionaire. Elon Musk crosses the milestone of becoming the world's first trillionaire, sparking discussions on wealth concentration.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes