Don Lemon Arrest: "First Step Towards Mass Repression”

Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Ask about Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway

Episode Description

Kara and Scott are back with an emergency episode to talk about the arrest of journalist Don Lemon. They break down how arresting journalists is the first step toward state capture of truth, why countries that do this become poorer and angrier, and what this means for press freedom and the creator economy.

Producers: Lara Naaman Zoë Marcus Taylor Griffin

Video Producer: Manolo Moreno

Vox Media's Executive Producer of Podcasts: Nishat Kurwa

Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email [email protected]

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the more Donald Trump gets away with, if he is allowed to pardon people and there's not enough uproar about it and
  2. nothing happens and he's going to um pick he's going to arrest people without due process on the streets or detain
  3. them uh even if they're American citizens. >> Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York
  4. Magazine and the Fox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisser >> and I'm Scott Galloway.
  5. >> Uh again Scott, we have to do an emergency episode. This is getting kind of ridiculous. uh we had to jump in here
  6. to talk uh to our audience about what's happening right now with journalists and
  7. our friend Don Lemon right now. He was recently on the show uh as a guest host while you were away. Um but he was
  8. arrested by authorities in Los Angeles Thursday night where he was covering the Grammy Awards um accused of violating
  9. federal law tied to a protest he covered as a journalist at a Minnesota church earlier this month. Lemon and three
  10. other journalists were arrested in connection with with this uh this event at the city's church in St. Paul,
  11. Minnesota. Attorney General Pam Bondi said she ordered the arrest of Don and three others citing a connection to a
  12. coordinated attack on the church. Don has repeatedly said he was there as a journalist, not a protester. And if you
  13. watch what he did there, that's what he was doing, including interviewing the pastor and others. A magistrate judge
  14. rejected an earlier attempt by the DOJ to bring charges against Don uh and other protesters. And the DOJ petitioned
  15. a federal appeals court to force the judge to issue an additional warrants only to be denied. But the DOJ went
  16. ahead anyway even though courts and prosecutors within those offices in Los Angeles and Minnesota are resisting
  17. this. Lemon's lawyers called the attack uh the arrest an attack on the First Amendment obviously and says Lemon will
  18. fight the case in court. He's supposed to be uh arraigned uh today in Los Angeles. Obviously, Don's a friend of
  19. ours, a friend of mine. Um he's been uh been reaching uh reaching out Pat when he when he was fired from CNN. He and I
  20. got to know each other because I helped him sort of mount what he was doing, which was independent journalism. And
  21. I've been very proud of him what he's been doing. He's doing a lot of street journalism, taking his his uh microphone
  22. to people, asking them questions. He's built a big following on YouTube. I think he crossed a million subscribers
  23. recently. But what's what he's doing is really amazing. He's doing these things and what he does, he's a man on the
  24. street essentially. And so he went into this church while this event was taking place and um and was doing reporting and
  25. which a lot of reporters should do. You know, I think he's found a new life in doing it as an independent journalist.
  26. And it's pretty um pretty amazing all the stuff he's been doing. very varied and talking to all kinds of people, not
  27. just liberals and but conservatives. He goes in places other journalists don't go. Um, and I think it's a real value
  28. what he's doing. And so he was doing this here. Um, he was then it was the Grammys. I mean, it's very varied where
  29. he goes. Uh, he was in New Orleans for New Year's and stuff. And so what he was doing here was journalism. And because,
  30. you know, he's had a target on him by the Trump administration who never liked him when he was at CNN. And uh and so
  31. this is what they're doing. And they're getting what they were getting is a lot of pressure from church groups for this
  32. group going into a church. And you can debate whether they should have gone in that church, but a journalist certainly
  33. could follow a group of people in there. He did not coordinate the attacks. They're going to try to allege he did
  34. that he was part of it. Um, but it's really again part of this uh what I said on in today's episode that just aired
  35. was they're going to keep escalating because they're desperate and they're losing the public case. Um, and so part
  36. of their their their uh handbook here, the fascist handbook, is to attack journalists. It's happened in Turkey.
  37. It's happened in all manner of the authoritarian countries. And this is what you do. And uh and so doing these
  38. high-profile cases, even though judges and lawyers do not want to do this and say it's full of [ __ ] which it is, um
  39. is really frightening. Um and it's meant to frighten. And what we have to do is push back. We have to fight it. But the
  40. fact is they will keep doing this and they will not back out. They will not deescalate. This is part of the the this
  41. is part of the problem is you all think you can work with these people and you cannot. Uh any thoughts you have? I I'm
  42. it makes me nervous. I have a lot of people who have have been threatening to me and uh it makes every journalist
  43. who's doing any kind of speaking out um really uh really at at risk I would say.
  44. >> Yeah. I think it's important to distinguish that this wasn't uh you know 50 people refusing to leave an area and
  45. they get arrested one by one for trespassing. This was our attorney general, the federal government,
  46. >> specifically targeting specific journalists and essentially >> deciding to criminalize journalism,
  47. which >> at the end of the day, it converts politics into policing. And also, >> this really should be a cause for alarm
  48. be >> well, it's the first step in state capture of truth. They >> they arrest journalists. That's kind of
  49. the first step towards mass repression. And it's not usually just journalists that go after loud critics, polarizing
  50. figures, >> people that the public quite frankly are already split on. So Don Lemon is a
  51. controversial figure. A lot of people don't like him and will celebrate this. But once you normalize
  52. >> criminalizing journalism from whatever political spectrum, >> the enforcement widens really fast. And
  53. just some historical context, >> this happened in Turkey in 2013. The initial arrests were seen as quote
  54. unquote law enforcement and within 5 years Turkey became the world's largest jailer of journalists. Russia in the
  55. 2000s early cases targeted quote unquote controversial reporters and the result now is that Russia now ranks in the
  56. bottom 10% globally for press freedom. The other the you know I always go to the money here. When a society starts
  57. doing this, it almost always uh predates economic collapse. Whether it's Egypt, whether it's Hungary, this isn't a good
  58. move for the economy because what happens here is it's not the censorship itself,
  59. >> but it creates an environment of selfcensorship where people stop >> start spiking stories etc. And this
  60. isn't also this line t >> this the last thing I'll say this line >> tends to be a difficult line
  61. >> to cross back easily once you start normalizing they did it in thear republic they did it in Hong Kong once
  62. you start normalizing the arrests of journalists and controversial figures it's it's a fast hill down and a slow
  63. hill uh back >> yeah I would agree I mean one of the things that's really disturbing is it's
  64. not just this arrest which is the explicit version of it is what we're talking about is the capture by these
  65. tech billionaires of these institutions that are sort of soft pedalling. Now, there's one thing for Fox News. We know
  66. they feel like a state propaganda arm most of the time. Not always, but most of the time, you know, I talked to a lot
  67. of people, they call uh Fox News entertainment, but it's actually propaganda and and everyone kind of
  68. expects it. In this case, there's this sort of this slow burn whether it's Jeff Bezos, you know, uh, you know, deepixing
  69. the Kla Harris um, endorsement or ma or or making changes or gutting out the Washington Post, whether you have Larry
  70. Ellison um, at through Oracle owning a big chunk of Tik Tok and also changing CBS News into this bothsiderism kind of
  71. situation. Um it's it's that too, the sort of soft grab of of press power which happens in these places and then
  72. this very hard grab which is to arrest journalists. And you're right, they're picking someone who they've had a beef
  73. with for a long time who the you know it's in a church. So it creates that kind of like how dare he go in a church.
  74. But this is where journalists go everybody. I'm sorry. You can have your you can this should be litigated through
  75. the courts with the protesters whether they trespassed or not, whether they were on private property, but Don
  76. Lemon's a journalist and he followed them in there. And so, and frankly, more journalists should have followed him in
  77. there. The fact that he was one of the few, there was just a few of them there. And so when you're covering these
  78. protests, often journalists get caught up in um in the they don't get caught up in the protests, but they're there when
  79. there's um you know, say tear gas or whatever. And they're often pushed to the ground. They're often abused. I have
  80. years ago I was in a there was a protest at at a neo-Nazi rally in Germany and I
  81. got hit with all kinds of things and it was it's such a melee kind of stuff and but John was if you go and watch it he
  82. was interviewing people including people at the church and while they may have been offended by the fact that he was
  83. there interviewing them he's allowed to do that under the first amendment and it
  84. let me just say the first amendment says government shall make no law this is the
  85. government acting Um, again, it's it's really frightening. And of course, Pam Bondi, the Justice
  86. Department has been an arm of Donald Trump, not the independent body. It is it has long previously had been in terms
  87. of of relationships with president. She is a lackey. She all these people are lackey um to to this authoritarian
  88. experiment. And let me let me stress Donald Trump's uh poll numbers are tanking like tanking like astonishingly.
  89. Everyone is worse and worse among all kinds of groups of people. And so what they have to do is this. And therefore
  90. next week in Ohio, they're going to they're going to make a spectacle of uh Haitian immigrants there, try to get rid
  91. of them because they lose their ability to stay there. Then they're going to be doing that. They're going to send ice in
  92. with mass goons all over the place. they're going to they go to Georgia and do the election thing. This is not this
  93. is all of one piece and journalists attacking journalists is is is part of it and they will they will double down
  94. and double down and double down until the midterms. And if they can stop those midterms, they most certainly will. I
  95. don't believe they can, but they will do everything in their power to create a a situation where they'll be able to
  96. pull the Insures Act or whatever they want to do so that they can suppress. And the only good thing that you have
  97. here is everybody is speaking out against this. And secondly, um uh that this is a big country. It's a little
  98. harder to control this country. And as you could see from what's happened in Minneapolis, that is the kind of
  99. reaction that you're going to get. These those protests uh were largely peaceful.
  100. People standing up, average citizens. They can't keep pretending everybody is a paid agitator. It's one of their
  101. tricks. And it shows weakness, but it also shows brutality and a kind of strength that should be frightening to
  102. all Americans. Um, I'm not going to get on high of journalists and first amendment, but hello, it's the first
  103. amendment. We have a right to all the amendments, all of all the bill of rights, and slowly uh the Trump
  104. administration is trying to take away your constitutional rights. Uh, and definitely just did that to Don Lemon
  105. today. >> I don't have a background in journalism. you you immediately texted this morning,
  106. you're obviously very rattled and upset by this and I understand, >> but as someone who's watching the whole
  107. thing, but doesn't I don't have a lot of familiarity with the First Amendment or
  108. or a background in journalism, but what I do perceive as the following, and that
  109. is, let's be let's just call this what what it is. The attorney general appointed by the president isn't
  110. arresting journalists to enforce laws. She's arresting journalists to shape reality. And once the state,
  111. the way I see it, once the state decides who may safely speak, politics stops being a debate and it becomes a
  112. permission structure. And also, as someone who spends a lot of time thinking and studying World War II and
  113. 20th century conflict history, history around this around arresting journalists is brutally consistent.
  114. Countries that start arresting journalists in targeted ways, they don't become more stable. They don't become
  115. more truthful or more democratic. They become quieter. Then they become much poorer
  116. and then much angrier. This is a cycle that repeats out consistently. So if you want to be
  117. poorer and you want to be angrier, you let the immediate slide of targeted arrested journalisms turn of journalists
  118. turn into a chill and a quiet. If there's not, history shows if there's not immediate gag reflex push back that
  119. forces the immediate rethinking and withdrawal of targeted arrested journalists. History is clear. It slides
  120. fast. Selfcensorship poor angrier. >> Yep. And let me just say finally, do not let them both sides this. Don't let
  121. them. They're trying to do it with Alex Pettit. They're trying to do it with Renee Good. They're always trying to
  122. find excuses for murder. They're trying to find excuses for arresting journalists. There aren't any here. Uh
  123. and and our heart goes out to Don. I Don Don's a friend. He's been a guest host here. He's very brilliant. And he's
  124. really working really hard to try to do something different. And uh like him or not, and I love him. uh you you really
  125. have to be terrified for people including and let me point out the arrest the the ste the taking of the
  126. Washington Post reporters uh file uh computers and files without a word from Jeff Bezos. I mean he's swanning around
  127. Paris at fashion shows. This is where we are folks and so pay attention. >> Well just again I go to the economic
  128. side of it. The fastest part of growing part of our digital economy is a creator
  129. economy. Yeah. And what does this mean for all creators that you have some sort of Orwellian environment where you can
  130. only certain people can speak about politics, politics >> and and global issues whether it's
  131. climate warming or the incel movement or >> we're talking about you know free speech. There's a wonderful
  132. part of the economy developing where people feel like they can express their views.
  133. >> Yep. And if somebody who leaves traditional media and is successful in the crater economy and ends up in jail
  134. because of the viewpoint seems to be crosshaird with the current administration. I mean you can just see
  135. how this begins immediately to start to damage the economy and also what kind of
  136. message does this send to young people that you have the opportunity to speak out and create your own content only if
  137. it's the right type of content. There's a basic tenant of democratic societies and it's the following and it's simple
  138. and it's you know but it's very straightforward and that is the following. Pretty much anybody should be
  139. able to say pretty much anything about pretty much anyone else. That's it. And we have revered that and we have
  140. protected it. And the moment the moment that falls, it is really hard to put Humpty Dumpty back together again.
  141. >> Absolutely. I mean, I like that you're actually focusing in on the on the on the business part of it because it's
  142. important, too. It's easy to get, you know, a high dudge in here, which I have, but you're right. It this is an
  143. exciting part of the economy. And um and and the fact that that they're doing this is just typical. This is so we are
  144. hungry. We're becoming hungry. We're becoming, you know, this soft descent into hungry. I don't know what else to
  145. say. It's so ridiculous. and and and uh fiction. I'm looking up just uh the first amendment. I'm just going to read
  146. it for people for goodness sake. Let me uh I'm just going to do it. Cong. It's very short, Scott. And it's first, so
  147. it's super easy. Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion or prohibiting the free
  148. exercise thereof or abridging the freedom of speech or of the press or of the right of the people peaceibly to
  149. assemble and to petition the government for redress of grievances. Well, folks, we're agrieved and we're going to
  150. petition them for that. Anyway, Don, we're thinking >> we're going to continue to piece
  151. peaceibly assemble. >> Yes, and we are. You know why it's first? Because it's best. Anyway, uh I
  152. appreciate it, Scott. Thank you so much. I was super rattled this morning. And my
  153. good friend Scott uh as usual has some amazing insights and it's really important that we keep at this. And if I
  154. get arrested, Scott, will you come and get me? Will you come? I I'm literally I'm proud to say and this goes for you.
  155. I'm people's jail call. I always carry a [ __ ] ton of cash and I'm a night person.
  156. So I'll come down anywhere late at night with a bunch of cash and all like that.
  157. >> A lot of discretion, no questions asked. I'm your call, Cara. >> All right. Thanks, Scott.
  158. >> There you go. >> All right, everybody. Thank you very much again. That's the Emergency Show.
  159. Thanks for listening to Pivot. Be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel. We'll be back with a full show
  160. on Tuesday.

Brief Summary

Don Lemon's arrest raises serious concerns about press freedom and government targeting of journalists.

Key points

  • Don Lemon's Arrest. Don Lemon was arrested while covering the Grammy Awards, accused of violating federal law.
  • Attacks on Journalism. The discussion highlights the alarming trend of targeting journalists in the current political climate.
  • First Amendment Under Threat. The conversation emphasizes the dangers of criminalizing journalism and its implications for democracy.

Tension

75/ 100High tension

Related episodes